UNIVERSITY  OF  CALIFORNIA  LIBRARY 


LIBRARY 

OF   THE 

University  of  California. 

GIFT    OF 

^>^..  \j 0^,.<-A/'-V-^""'.-^-'. "... W.^.-t^^s-^yLx? 

Class 


LIBRARY  OF  CONGRESS 


LIST  OF 
REFERENCES 


ON 


RECIPROCITY 


COMPILED  UNDER  THE  DIRECTION  OF  THE 
CHIEF  BIBLIOGRAPHER 

FIRST  EDITION 

APPLETON  PRENTISS  CLARK  GRIFFIN 

SECOND  EDITION,  WITH  ADDITIONS 

H.  H.  B.  MEYER 


For  aale  by  the 

Snpei-intendent  of  Documents 
Government    Printing    OflBce 


WASHINGTON 

GOVERNMENT   PRINTING   OFFIOH 

1910 


Price  16c 


^L^    LIBRARY  OF  CONGRESS 


LIST   OF 
REFERENCES 

ON 


RECIPROCITY 


COMPILED  UNDER  THE  DIRECTION  OF  THE 
CHIEF  BIBLIOGRAPHER 

FIRST  EDITION 

APPLETON  PRENTISS  CLARK  GRIFFIN 

SECOND  EDITION,  WITH  ADDITIONS 

H.  H.  B.  MEYER 


WASHINGTON 

GOVERNMENT   PRINTING    OFFICE 
1910 


L.  C.  card,  10-35003 


PREFATORY  NOTE 


The  first  edition  of  a  "List  of  references  on  reciprocity"  was  pub- 
lished in  1902  and  a  "Select  list  of  books,  with  references  to  periodi- 
cals, on  reciprocity  with  Canada,"  in  1907,  and  later  a  typewritten  list 
on  Cuban  reciprocity  was  prepared.  The  material  contained  in  these 
has  now  been  brought  together,  with  the  addition  of  later  literature, 
and  grouped  under  the  following  headings: 

Reciprocity  in  the  United  States  [comprehensive]. 

Reciprocity  with  Canada  and  Newfoundland. 

Reciprocity  with  Hawaii. 

Reciprocity  under  the  McKinley  act,  1890-1894. 

Reciprocity  with  Cuba. 

Reciprocity  in  Great  Britain  and  other  countries. 

To  the  general  works  to  which  special  attention  was  directed  in  the 
first  edition,  such  as  Adams's  "American  economic  supremacy," 
Bastable's  "Theory  of  international  trade;"  Chapman's  "History  of 
trade  between  the  United  Kingdom  and  the  United  States;"  Rogers's 
"Economic  interpretation  of  history,"  should  now  be  added  Ashley's 
"Modern  tariff  history;"  Dietzel's  "Retaliatory  duties;"  Fisk's 
"International  commercial  policies,  with  special  reference  to  the 
United  States,"  and  Laughlin  and  Willis's  "Reciprocity." 

Documents  and  treaties.— In  a  subject  of  this  kind  the  public  docu- 
ments are  of  the  first  importance,  and  this  fact  is  emphasized  by 
placing  them  at  the  head  of  each  section.  By  means  of  them  the  leg- 
islative history  of  the  reciprocity  treaties  or  projects  from  the  year 
1815  to  the  present  time  may  be  traced.  The  texts  of  the  various 
treaties  and  agreements  are  given  in  "Treaties,  conventions  .  .  .  and 
agreements  between  the  United  States  of  America  and  other  powers, 
1776-1909"  (Senate  document  no.  357,  6lst  Congress,  2d  session).  ^ 

The  diplomatic  negotiations  in  connection  with  the  treaties  of  1815 
and  1818  with  Great  Britain  are  set  forth  in  Lyman's  "The  diplomacy 
of  the  United  States;"  Wharton's  "Digest  of  international  law" 
devotes  a  section  to  the  Hawaiian  reciprocity  treaty,  and  another  to 
"Treaty  regulations  of  reciprocity  with  Great  Britain."  Wharton 
is  practically  superseded  by  Moore's  "Digest  of  international  law," 
which  discusses  in  addition  the  fate  of  the  reciprocity  treaties  negoti- 
ated under  the  McKinley  act.  Foster's  ^'A  century  of  American 
diplomacy"  considers  the   Canadian  reciprocity    treaty;    Schuyler's 


2  PREFATORY    NOTE 

"Amcriciin  diplomacy  and  the  furtheianceof  commerce''  <,aves  a  good 
survey  of  the  commercial  treaties  from  ITH-i  to  1884. 

Canada — The  Canadian  reciprocity  treat}''  of  1854  is  the  subject  of 
a  monograph  by  F.  E.  HaN'nes,  forming  American  economic  associa- 
tion publication,  volume  7,  no.  6,  and  is  one  of  the  two  treaties  in 
C.  Robinson's  ''History  of  two  reciprocity^  treaties." 

The  following  give  the  Canadian  view  of  the  treaty:  Gray's  "Con- 
federation; or,  The  political  and  parliamentary  histor}^  of  Canada;" 
Laurence  Oliphaut's  ''Episodes  of  a  life  of  adventure;"  Mrs.  Oli- 
phant's  ''Memoir  of  Laurence  Oliphant;"  Sir  E.  W.  Watkin's 
''Canada  and  the  United  States."  Hopkins,  "Canada;  an  encj^clopte- 
dia  of  the  countrv;"  Porritt's  "Sixty  3'ears  of  protection  in  Canada." 

The  British  and  Canadian  parliamentary  papers  containing-  the  oflfi- 
cial  record  of  the  treaty  negotiations,  diplomatic  correspondence,  etc., 
are  given  in  a  g-roup  immediately  after  the  United  States  documents. 

The  movement  for  the  abrogation  of  the  treaty  in  1864  brought  out 
several  reports,  notably  Derby's  "Preliminary  report  on  the  treaty  of 
reciprocity,"  Washington,  1866,  which  examined  the  effects  of  the 
operations  under  the  treaty  of  1854.  This  was  reprinted  in  his  "Let- 
ter to  the  Hon.  William  H.  Seward,"  1867,  and  in  Senate  executive 
document  no.  30,  39th  Congress,  2d  session. 

The  negotiations  for  the  renewal  of  the  treaty  iu  1868-69  are  discussed 
in  Gray's  "Confederation,"  in  the  Sessional  papers  (no.  47)  of  the 
Canadian  Parliament,  and  in  the  United  States  documents  of  the  period. 
For  later  negotiations  the  documents  remain  the  most  important 
sources,  but  the  periodical  literature  becomes  of  increasing  significance. 

Official  Canadian  statistical  publications  to  be  noted  are  the  "Tables 
of  the  trade  and  navigation  of  the  Dominion  of  Canada"  and  the 
"Unrevised  monthly  statements  of  imports  entered  for  consumption" 
and  "Exports  of  the  Dominion  of  Canada,"  both  published  })v  the 
department  of  customs;  the  "Annual  report  of  the  Department  of 
trade  and  commerce."  the  "Monthly  report"  of  the  same  department, 
and  the  "Statistical  yearbook  of  Canada,"  issued  by  the  Department 
of  agriculture.  Non-official  publications  containing  material  on  trade 
relations  of  Canada  are:  "The  Canadian  annual  review,"  Toronto; 
"The  Canadian  manufacturer,"  semi-monthly,  Toronto;  "The  Cana- 
dian gazette,''  weekly,  London;  and  "Canada,"  weekly,  Montreal. 

Reciprocity  tvlth  Spairinh  America. — The  greater  part  of  the  mate- 
rial under  the  heading  "Reciprocity  under  the  McKinley  act,  1890- 
1894"  treats  of  the  negotiations  with  the  Spanish  American  states. 
The  minutes  and  reports  of  the  International  American  conference, 
held  at  Washington  in  1890,  and  Curtis's  "Trade  and  transportation 
between  the  United  States  and  Spanish  America"  afford  valuable 
information  on  reciprocity  with  the  American  republics.     Secretar}-^ 


PREFATORY    NOTE  3 

Blaine's  writings  on  the  subject  are  noted  in  the  list.  Consult  further 
the  Bulletins  of  the  International  bureau  of  the  American  republics. 

Among  the  discussions,  mostly  periodical,  called  out  by  theMcKinley 
act  may  be  mentioned  Kasson's  ''Reciprocity^"  Washington,  1901; 
John  P.  Young's  "Economic  aspects  of  reciprocity,"  in  the  Protec- 
tionist, vol.  13,  pp.  80-91:  Brooks  Adams's  "Reciprocity  or  the  alter- 
native," in  the  Atlantic  monthly,  vol.  88,  pp.  145-155;  J.  B.  Osborne's 
"Expansion  through  reciprocity^"  in  the  Atlantic  monthly,  vol.  88, 
pp.  721-731;  G.  B.  Waldron's  "A  calm  view  of  reciprocity,"  in  the 
Chautauquan,  vol.  34,  pp.  237-242;  E.  J.  Gibson's  "Reciprocity  and 
the  foreign  trade,"  in  the  Forum,  vol.  32,  pp.  466-480;  George  Gun- 
ton's  "Our  industrial  foreign  policy,"  in  Institute  of  social  economics, 
Lecture  bulletin,  December  2,  1901,  pp.  131-151;  A.  H.  U.  Colqu- 
houn's  "The  reciprocity  of  to-day,"  in  the  Canadian  magazine,  vol. 
18,  pp.  226-228;  John  Charlton's  "Reciprocity  with  Canada"  in  the 
Forum,  vol.  32,  pp.  582-693;  and  A.  B.  Farquhar\s  "The  manufac- 
turer's need  of  reciprocity,"  in  Annals  of  the  American  academy  of 
political  and  social  science,  vol.  19,  pp.  21-39. 

Current  statistics  of  American  foreign  trade  in  tabulated  form  are 
printed  annually  in  the  "Statistical  abstract  of  the  United  States." 
More  detailed  statistics  are  given  in  the  annual  report  on  "Foreign 
commerce  and  navigation  of  the  United  States,"  and  similar  statistics 
in  monthly  form  appear  in  the  "Monthly  summary  of  conniierce  and 
finance  of  the  United  States."  These  are  all  published  by  the  Bureau 
of  statistics  of  the  Department  of  commerce  and  labor.  The  consu- 
lar reports  of  the  United  States  and  of  Great  Britain  contain  reports 
on  specific  subjects  of  commerce. 

In  the  compilation  of  this  list,  it  has  not  been  considered  feasible  to 
include  works  concerned  with  the  commodities  which  have  been  the 
subject  of  reciprocity  unless  they  illustrate  general  principles;  for 
example,  sugar.  This  subject  alone  required  a  list  of  238  pages,  which 
shows  the  inadvisability  of  attempting  to  include  works  on  commodi- 
ties. The  purpose,  in  brief,  has  been  to  present  materials  dealing 
with  the  principles  and  history  of  reciprocit3\ 

The  following  were  examined  too  late  for  inclusion  in  the  body  of 
the  list: 

Butler,  Charles  Henry.     The  treaty-making  power  of  the  United  States. 
New  York:  The  Banks  law  pub.  CO.,  J 902.     2  vols.     8°. 

See  index  under  headings  Commercial  treaties,  "  Most  favored  nation  "  clause,  Reci- 
procity, etc. 

Tazewell,  Littleton  Waller.     A.  review  of  the  negociations  between  the  United 
States  of  America  and  Great  Britain,  respecting  the  commerce  of  the  two 
countries,  and  more  especially  concerning  the  trade  of  the  former  with  the 
West  Indies. 
London:  J.  Murray,  1829.     iv,  130,  (2)  pp.     8°. 

Printed  with  the  signature  "Senex"  in  the  Norfolk  (Va.)  herald. 


4  PREFATORY   NOTE 

United  States.  Supreme  court.  Field  v.  Clark.  Appeal  from  the  Circuit  court  of 
the  United  States  for  the  Northern  district  of  Illinois.  Boyd  v.  United 
States.  Sternbach  v.  United  States.  Appeals  from  the  Circuit  court  of  the 
United  States  for  the  Southern  district  of  New  York.  Nos.  1052, 1049,  1050. 
Argued  Nov.  30,  Dec.  1,  2,  1891.— Decided  Feb.  29,  1892. 

(In  its  United  States  reports,  vol.  143,  pp.  649-700.  New  York,  1892.  S°.) 
"The  authority  conferred  upon  the  President  by  section  3  of  the  act  of  October  1, 
1890,  to  reduce  the  revenue  and  equalize  duties  on  imports,  and  for  other  purposes,  26 
Stat.  c.  1244,  pp.  567,  612,  to  suspend  by  proclamation  the  free  introduction  of  sugar, 
molasses,  coffee,  tea,  and  hides,  when  he  is  satisfied  that  any  country  producing  such 
article  imposes  duties  or  other  exactions  upon  the  agricultural  or  other  products  of 
the  United  States,  vhich  he  may  deem  to  be  reciprocally  unequal  or  unreasonable,  is 
not  open  to  the  objection  that  it  unconstitucionally  transfers  legislative  power  to  the 
President  (Fuller,  C.  J.,  and  Lamar,  J.,  dissenting;)  but  even  if  it  were  it  does  not 
follow  that  other  parts  of  the  act  imposing  duties  upon  imported  articles  are 
inoperative." 

H.  H.  B.  Meyer 

Chief  Bibliograjpher 
Herbert  Putnam 

Librarian  of  Congress 

Washington,  D.  C,  June  27,  1910 


TABLE  OF  CONTENTS 


General— United  States: 

United  States  documents—  ^*^^- 

General - ^^^ 

Chronological  list 

Foreign  documents 

■ni  ^6—6 1 

^«°^^--. -.-y.--; ..    38-50 

Articles  in  periodicals 

Reciprocity  with  Canada  and  Newfoundland: 

United  States  documents 

Canadian  and  British  documents ^^^^ 

Books 74-82 

Articles  in  periodicals 

Reciprocity  with  Hawaii:  ^^^ 

United  States  documents 

-r,,  oo-yu 

Books Qj^ 

Articles  in  periodicals 

Reciprocity  under  the  INlcKinley  act,  1890-1894:  ^^^^ 

United  States  documents 

90 

Foreign  documents ^^_gg 

Books - gg_jQQ 

Articles  in  periodicals 

Reciprocity  with  Cuba:  101-104 

United  States  documents 105-107 

Books..------...-.- ;-;;  ^^^^^^ 

Articles  in  periodicals 

Reciprocity  in  Great  Britain  and  other  countries:  IH-IU 

'^ook^.. ------ ;;;;  ^^^_^^^ 

A rticles  m  periodicals ^ ^^  ^^^ 

Author  index 125-137 

Subject  index 


LIST  OF  REFERENCES  ON  RECIPROCITY 


GENERAL  WORKS.     RECIPROCITY  IN   THE  UNITED  STATES 
UNITED  STATES  DOCUMENTS 


GENERAL 


United  States.     Bureau  of  statistics  (Department  of  commerce  and 
labor).     Monthly  summary  of  commerce  and  finance  of 
the  United  States,  July  lS66-June  1893;  new  series,  July 
1893-date.     vol.  i-date. 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1866-date.     4°- 

Bureau  of  statistics  (Treasury  depaHment).     Modern  tariff 

systems.  The  maximum  and  minimum,  conventional, 
and  general  tariff  systems  of  the  principal  countries  of 
the  world.  <From  the  Summary  of  commerce  and 
finance  for  March,  1904.  > 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1904.  Hi,  3333- 
.     3431  pp.     h°- 

"The  most  favored  nation  clause:"  pp.  3335-3337. 

Congress.     House.     Committee  on  ways  and  means.     Imports 

and  duties,  1894-1907.  Comparative  statement  of  import- 
ed merchandise  entered  for  consumption  in  the  United 
States,  by  articles,  with  the  quantity,  value,  duty  collected, 
average  price,  rate  of  duty,  and  equivalent  ad  valorem 
rate  of  duty  for  each;  showng  operations  under  the  general 
tariff  laws  of  1890,  1894,  and  1897;  the  Porto  Rican  and 
Philippine  tariff  acts,  and  the  reciprocity  treaties  with 
Cuba,  France,  Germany,  Hawaii,  Italy,  Portugal,  Spain, 
and  Switzerland,  during  the  fiscal  years  ende(l  June  30, 
1894  to  1907,  inclusive.  Compiled  under  the  direction  of 
the  Committee  on  ways  and  means,  from  the  annual 
reports  of  commerce  and  navigation,  by  William  W.  Evans. 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1909.  1000  pp.  8°. 
(60th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  doc.  no.  1504.)       5548 


8  LIBRARY    OF    CONGRESS 

United  States.  Congress.  Senate.  Committee  on  foreign  relations. 
C'ompilation  of  reports  of  Committee,  1789-1901,  First 
Congress,  first  session,  to  Fifty-sixth  Congress,  second 
session. 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1901.  8  vols.  Plates. 
Maps.  Plans.  8°.  {56th  Congress,  2d  session.  Senate 
doc.  no.  231,  pts.  1-8.)  4047-4054 

Department  of  state.     General  index  to  the  piibhshed  vol- 

umes  of    the   Diplomatic    correspondence    and    Foreign 
relations  of  the  United  States.     1861-1899. 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1902.     9J^5  pp.     8°. 
See  entries  under  headings  Reciprocity,  Treaties,  etc. 

Laws,  statutes,  etc.     Compilation  of  customs  laws  and  digest 

of  decisions  thereunder  rendered  by  the  courts  and  Board 
of  United  States  general  appraisers. 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1908.     1383  pp.    8°. 
(Treasury  department.     Document  no.  2499.     Customs.) 
"Contains  the  tariff  acts  of  1897,  1894,  1890,  and  1883,  complete, 
except  certain  provisions  relating  to  internal  revenue  and  other 
matters  not  germane  to  this  work,  and  also  the  customs  admin- 
istrative act  of  1890."     cf.  Prefatory  note,  p.  3. 
For  references  to  decisions  under  the  various  reciprocity  agree- 
ments, consult  the  index. 

Tariff  acts  passed  by  the  Congress  of  the  United 

States  from  1789  to  1897,  including  all  acts,  resolutions, 
and  proclamations  modifying  or  changing  those  acts. 
Compiled  and  indexed  under  the  direction  of  the  Joint 
committee  on  printing,  by  Robert  G.  Proctor. 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1898.  689  pp.  8°. 
(55th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  doc.  no.  562.)  3700 

Treaties,  etc.     Reciprocity  treaties  and  agreements  between 

the  United  States  and  foreign  countries  since  1850. 

(In  U.  S.  Bureau  of  statistics  (Dept.  of  commerce  and  labor). 
Monthly  summary  of  commerce  and  finance  of  the  United 
States,  n.  s.,  vol.  12,  Aug.  1904,  pp.  525-558.  Washington, 
1904.     4°.) 

Treaties,  conventions,  international  acts,  protocols 

and  agieements  between  the  United  States  of  America 
and  other  powers,  1776-1909;  compiled  by  WiUiam  M. 
Malloy  under  resolution  of  the  Senate  of  January  18, 
1909. 

Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1910.     2  vols.     8°. 
(61st  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  357.) 
For  reciprocity  treaties  and  agreements,  see  index. 


CHRONOLOGICAL   LIST 

Note.— The  heavy-face  numerals  at  the  end  of  the  titles  are  the  serial  numbers  used  in  the  check  list 
of  documents,  published  by  the  Superintendent  of  documents. 

1816.  Correspondence  between  the  American  and  British  pleni- 
potentiaries relative  to  the  commercial  convention  con- 
cluded on  the  3d  of  July,  1815.  January  16,  1816. 
Printed  by  order  of  the  House  of  representatives.  50 
pp.  Folded  sheet.  8°. 
Ij^th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  of  RepreseiHatives,  no.  27. 

1818.  Report  of  the  committee  to  whom  was  referred  that  part  of 
the  President's  messao;e,  which  relates  to  the  commercial 
intercourse  of  the  United  States  with  the  British  West 
India  islands  and  North  American  colonies,  and  also  on 
the  petition  of  sundry  inhabitants  of  different  parts  of 
Maine,  on  the  same  subject.  Feb.  9,  1818.  25  pp. 
Folded  tables.  8°. 
15th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc.  no.  87.  8 

1818.  Great   Britain — convention   of  Oct.   20,    1818.     Convention 

signed  at  London,   Oct.  20,   1818,   between  the  United 
States  and  Great  Britain,  together  with  the  documents 
showing  the  course  and  progress  of  the  negotiation.     Dec. 
29,  1818. 
15th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate. 

{In  Annals  of  Congress,   vol.   34,   col.    1445-1594.     Washington, 
1855.     8°.) 

1819.  British  colonial  trade.     Report  by  Mr.  Macon,  from  the  Com- 

mittee on  foreign  relations,  to  whom  was  referred  so  much 
of  the  documents  accompanying  the  commercial  conven- 
tion with  Great  Britain,  as  relates  to  the  colonial  trade. 
Feb.  19,  1819. 
15ih  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate. 

(In  Annals  of  Congress,  vol.  33,  col.  249-250.     Washington,  1855. 
8°.) 

1823.  Message  from  the  President  transmitting  (pursuant  to  a  reso- 
lution of  the  House  of  Representatives,  of  the  22d  ult.) 
the  correspondence  between  the  government  of  the 
United  States  and  Great  Britain,  relating  to  the  negotia- 
tion of  the  convention  of  the  2()th  October,  1818.  Feb. 
15,  1823.  152  pp.  8°. 
17th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  pa/pers,  no.  71 .  76 


10  LIBRARY    OF    CONGRESS 

1825.     Message  from  the  President,  Dec.  6,  1825.     188  pp.     Folded 

tables.     8°. 

19ih  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  2.  125 

Pp.   4-5,   on  commercial   relations   with  other  nations,  favoring 

reciprocity.     Recommends  negotiation  of  treaties  "with  all  the 

independent  South  American  states  on  the  basis  of  entire  and 

unqualified  reciprocity."  ^ 

1839.     Report  from  the  Secretary  of  state     .     .     .     showing  the 

nature  and  extent  of  the  privileges  and  restrictions  of 

the  commercial  intercourse  of  the  United  States,  with  all 

foreign  nations.     Dec.  30,  1839.     73  pp.     8°. 

26tli  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  reimrt  no.  80.  356 

1839.  Trade  with  the  British  colonial  ports.  Letter  from  the  Sec- 
retary of  the  treasury,  transmitting  a  report  on  the  effect 
and  operations  of  the  existing  arrangements  between  the 
United  States  and  Great  Britain,  regulating  the  trade 
with  the  British  American  colonies.  Dec.  30,  1839.  31 
pp.  8°. 
26th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc.  no.  14-  364 

1842.     Colonial  trade— Great  Britain.     April  14,  1842.     [Report  of 

the  Committee  on  foreign  affairs.]     218,  40  pp.     8°. 

27tli  Congress,  2d  session.     House  report  no.  650.  409 

An  investigation  of  the  effect  upon  American  commerce  of  the 

reciprocity  treaty  concluded  between  the  United  States  and 

Great  Britain  in  1815. 

1844.  Report  by  Senator  Rufus  Choate,  from  the  Committee  on 

foreign  relations,  to  whom  was  recommitted,  on  the  1st 
instant,  the  convention  with  Prussia  and  the  other  states 
of  the  Germanic  association  of  customs  and  commerce. 
June  14,  1844. 
28th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate. 

(In  Journal  of  the  executive  proceedings  of  the  Senate,  vol.  6, 
pp.  333-336.     Washington,  1887.     8°.) 

1845.  Report  by  Mr.  Archer,  from  the  Committee  on  foreign  rela- 

tions, to  whom  was  referred,  on  the  10th  of  December 
last,  a  message  relating  to  the  convention  with  Prussia, 
and  other  states  of  the  Germanic  association  of  customs 
and  commerce,  and  to  whom  was  referred,  on  the  23 
December,  the  said  convention.  Feb.  26,  1845. 
28th  Congress,  2d  session.     Seriate. 

(In  Journal  of  the  executive  proceedings  of  the  Senate,  vol.  6, 
pp.  406-410.     Washington,  1887.     8°.) 


reciprocity:  u.  s,  documents  11 

1860.  Consideration  by  the  Senate,  in  Committee  of  the  whole, 
of  the  treaty  of  transits  and  commerce  between  the 
United  States  and  the  Mexican  Repubhc,  dated  at  Vera 
Cruz,  Dec.  14,  1859. 

{In  Journal  of  the  executive  proceedings  of  the  Senate,  vol.  11, 
pp.  192-199.     Washington,  1887.     8°.) 

1863.     Tonnage  duties — United  States  and  Spain.     Letter  from  the 
Secretary  of  state  addressed  to  the  Committee  on  com- 
merce, in  relation  to  reciprocal  duties  between  Spanish 
ports  and  the  United  States.     Jan.  13,  1863.     5  pp.     8°. 
37th  Congress,  3d  session.     House  misc.  doc.  no.  12.         1171 

1870.  Message  of  the  President  of  the  United  States  communicat- 

ing .  .  .  information  in  relation  to  the  condition  of 
the  commercial  relations  between  the  United  States  and 
the  Spanish-American  states  on  this  continent,  and 
between  those   countries   and   other  nations.     July   14, 

1870.  13  pp.     8°. 

Jf-lst  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  112.  1407 

Report  from  the  Secretary  of  state,  with  accompanying  documents. 

1871.  Foreign  commerce  and  the  practical  workings  of  maritime 

reciprocity.     Letter  from  the  Secretary  of  the  treasury 
[Geo.  S.  Boutwell]  in  relation  to  the  foreign  commerce  of 
the    United    States.     Jan.    25,    1871.     64    pp.     Folded 
charts.     8°. 
Jflst  Congress,  3d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  76.  1454 

1871.  Memorial  of  a  committee  appointed  by  the  Commercial  con- 
vention, held  at  the  city  of  Cincinnati,  in  October,  1870, 
urging  that  measures  be  taken  for  a  congress  of  repre- 
sentatives of  all  the  governments  on  the  western  con- 
tinent to  consult  upon  the  best  means  for  inaugurating 
an  American  system  of  commercial  intercourse.     Feb.  3, 

1871.  5  pp.     8°. 

Jflst  Congress,  3d  session.     Senate  misc.  doc.  no.  51.         1442 
Committee:    Peter  Clark,  of  New  York;  Thomas  C.  Fletcher,  of 
Missouri;  William  M.  Burwell,  of  Louisiana. 

1878.     Report  antl  accompanying  documents  of  the  Committee  on 

foreign  afl'airs  on  the  relations  of  the  United  States  with 

Mexico.     April  25,  1878.     xlii,  461,  173,  (1)  pp.     8°. 

Ji.5th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  report  no.  701.  1824 

Commercial  relations  with  Mexico:  pp.  xxix-xxxvi. 

Appendix  F.  Commercial  relations  with  Mexico;  [Documents]: 

pp.  389-433. 
The  report  considers  the  desirability  of  a  treaty  of  reciprocity 
with  Mexico  and  reaches  an  adverse  conclusion. 


12  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1882.  Report  of   the  Tariff  commission,  appointed  under  act  of 

Congress  approved  May  15,  1882.     2  vols.     8°. 
47ih  Congress,  2d  session.     House  misc.  doc.  no.  6,  pt.  1,  2. 

2116-2117 

1883.  ^lessage  from  the  President,  transmitting  a  treaty  of  com- 

merce concluded  on  the  20th  day  of  January,  1883,  as 
amended,  between  the  United  States  and  Mexico.     Feb- 
ruary 7,  1883.     February  19,  1883. — Injunction  of  secrecy 
removed.     6  pp.     8°. 
IflQh  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  75.  2076 

1884.  Trade  between  Mexico  and  the  United  States.     Letter  from 

the  Secretary  of  the  treasury,  transmitting  ...  in- 
formation in  regard  to  the  trade  between  the  United 
States  and  Mexico,  and  to  the  traffic  over  the  railroads 
connecting  the  two  countries.  Feb.  8,  1884.  89  pp.  8°. 
48th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  86.  2200 

1884.  United  States.  Department  of  state.  Commercial  relations 
between  the  United  States  and  Central  and  South  America. 
Mar.  26,  1884.     3  pp.     8°. 

Communication  from  Secretary  Frelinghuysen. 
"The  true  plan,  it  seems  to  me,  is  to  make  a  series  of  reciprocity 
treaties  with  the  states  of  Central  and  South  America,  taking 
care  that  those  manufactures,  and  as  far  as  is  practicable  those 
products,  which  would  come  into  competition  with  our  own 
manufactures  and  products  should  not  be  admitted  to  the  free 
list." 

1884.     Report  by  Mr.  Miller,  of  California,  from  the  Committee  on 
foreign  relations.     Apr.  10,  1884.     2  pp.     8°. 
48th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  report  no.  432.  2175 

Includes  a  letter  from  Secretary  Frelinghuysen  on  proposed 
amendments  to  the  consular  and  diplomatic  bill  for  an  appro- 
priation to  defray  the  expenses  of  a  conference  of  the  independ- 
ent American  nations  to  promote  commerce  and  general  peace. 
A  series  of  reciprocity  treaties  advocated. 

1884.     Commercial    rehxtions    with    South    and    Central    America. 

[Report]  from  the  Committee  on  foreign  affairs.     May  7, 

1884.     6  pp.     8°. 

48th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1445.  2257 

Recommends  the  passage  of  a  bill  providing  for  the  appointment 

of  commissioners  to  investigate  means  and  facilities  for  the 

promotion  of  closer  commercial  relations  with  the  countries  of 

Central  and  South  America. 


RECIPROCITY  :    U.   S.  DOCUMENTS  .  13 

1885.  Report  from  the  Central  and  South  American  commissioners. 

Message  from  the  President,  transmitting  a  communica- 
tion from  the  Secretary  of  state,  with  a  report  from  the 
Central  and  South  American  commissioners.     February 
13,  1885.     4.38  pp.     8°. 
/fSth  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  226.         2304 

1886.  Reports  of  the  Commission  appointed  under  an  act  of  Con- 

gress, approved  July  7,  1884,  "To  ascertain  and  report 
upon  the  best  modes  of  securing  more  intimate  interna- 
tional and  commercial  relations  between  the  United  States 
and  the  several  countries  of  Central  and  South  America." 
Jan.  12,  1886.  491  pp.  Folded  maps.  8°. 
Jf-Qth  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  50.  2392 

1886.     American  customs  union.     Report  from  the  Committee  on 

foreign  affairs.     Apr.  15,  1886.     1  page.     8°. 

JfQth  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1645.  2440 

Adverse  report  on  joint  resolution  requesting  the  President  to 

invite  the  cooperation  of  the  governments  of  American  nations 

in  securing  the  establishment  of  free  commercial  intercourse 

among  those  nations  and  an  American  customs  union. 

1886.     Commercial  relations  between  the  United  States  and  Mexico 
and  Central  and  South  America  and  Brazil.     Report  from 
the  Committee   on   foreign   affairs.     April    15,  1886.     1 
page.     8°. 
49th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1647 .  2440 

Adverse  report  on  bill  "for  the  encouragement  of  closer  com- 
mercial relationship,"  etc. 

1886.  American  commerce  and  arbitration.  Report  from  the  Com- 
mittee on  foreign  affairs,  to  which  was  referred  the  bill 
(H.  R.  7267)  authorizing  the  President  of  the  United 
States  to  arrange  a  conference  for  the  purpose  of  promot- 
ing arbitration  and  encouraging  reciprocal  commercial 
relations  between  the  United  States  of  America  and  the 
republics  of  Mexico,  Central  and  South  America,  and  the 
empire  of  Brazil.  April  15,  1886.  12  pp.  8°. 
49th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1648.  2440 

Favorable  report. 

Views  of  the  minority:  pp.  5-12. 

1886.     ]\Iexican    treaty    of    January    20,     18S3.     Adverse    report. 
May  25,  1886.     52  pp.     Map.     8°. 
49th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  2615.  2443 

To  accompany  bill  H.  R.  1513. 
27306°— 10 2 


14  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1890.     Trade   and   transportation  between  the  United  States  and 
Latin  America.     By  William  Eleroy  Curtis.     February 
13,  1890.     xvi,  355  pp.     8°. ' 
51st  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  54-  2685 

1896.     Agricultural  and  manufactured  products  exported  to  foreign 
countries,  etc.     Feb.  4,  1896.     2  pp.     8°. 
54th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  252.  3457 

1896.     Report  of  the  Committee  on  ways  and  means  concerning 
reciprocity    and    commercial    treaties.     June    6,     1896. 
643  pp.     8°. 
54tli  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  2263.  3466 

Contents. — Introductory,  p.  5;  History  of  the  reciprocity  policy, 
pp.  6-13;  Results  of  reciprocity,  pp.  14-20;  Protests  against  the 
repeal  of  reciprocity,  pp.  21-26;  Effect  of  reciprocity  upon 
exports  of  breadstuffs,  pp.  27-34;  The  situation  in  France  and 
Germany,  pp.  35-37;  Discriminations  against  American  com- 
merce, pp.  38-39;  The  situation  in  Cuba,  pp.  40-42;  Present 
condition  of  our  export  trade,  pp.  43-52;  Views  of  the  minority, 
pp.  53-60;  Appendix:  A.  Reciprocity  with  Canada,  pp.  61-76; 
B.  Trade  with  the  Argentine  Republic  and  Uruguay,  pp.  77- 
104;  C.  Trade  with  Japan  and  China,  pp.  105-124;  D.  Adulter- 
ated foods  exported  to  the  United  States,  pp.  125-133;  E.  Re- 
strictions on  American  products  by  foreign  countries,  pp.  135- 
143;  F.  Replies  of  commercial  and  industrial  organizations  to 
inquiries  from  the  Committee  on  ways  and  means,  pp.  14.5-189; 
G.  Addresses  before  the  Committee  on  ways  and  means  by 
representatives  of  the  live-stock  industry,  pp.  191-200;  II.  Ad- 
dresses by  representatives  of  the  flour  industry,  pp.  201-262; 
I.  Addresses  by  representatives  of  various  industries,  pp.  263- 
291;  J.  Replies  from  merchants,  manufacturers,  exporting  and 
commission  houses,  steamship  companies,  etc.,  pp.  293-545; 
K.  Statistical  tables  relating  to  the  foreign  commerce  of  the 
United  States,  pp.  547-601;  L.  Rates  of  duty  imposed  by  for- 
eign countries  upon  articles  exported  from  the  United  States, 
pp.  603-625;  Index  to  appendices,  pp.  627-643. 

1896-7.     Tariff  hearings  before  the  Committee  on  ways  and  means. 
1896-97.     2  vols.     8°. 
54th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  doc.  no.  338.       3542-3543 
"Free   list.     Reciprocity   and    miscellaneous   matters":    vol.    2, 
pp.  2003-2105. 

1898.     United   States.     President  (McKinley).     Proclamation  [of 
commercial  agreement  with  France].     May  30,  1898. 

{In  U.  S.  Statutes  at  large,  vol.  30,  pp.  1774-1776.  Washington. 
1899.     4°.) 


reciprocity:  u.  s.  documents  15 

1899.  United  States.  President  { Mc Kinley) .  Reciprocity  with 
Portuy;al.  A  proclamation  [of  commercial  agreement 
with  Portugal].     May  22,  1899. 

(In  U.  S.  Statutes  at  large,  vol.  31,  pp.  1913-1914.  Washington. 
1901.     4°.) 

1899.     Commercial    conventions    between    the    United    States    and 

Great  Britain  for  Barbados,  Bermuda,  British  Guiana, 

Jamaica,  and  Turks  and  Caicos  islands,  signed  in  June 

and  July,  1899.     Dec.  11,1899.     26  pp.     8°. 

56th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  20.  3846 

1899.  Convention  between  the  United  States  and  Buenos  Aires. 
Message  from  the  President,  transmitting  a  convention, 
signed  at  Buenos  Aires,  July  10,  1899,  between  the  United 
States  and  the  Argentine  Republic.  Dec.  6,  1899.  5 
pp.  8°. 
56th  Congress,  1st  session.     Seriate  doc.  no.  21.  3846 

1899.  Convention  between  the  United  States  and  France.     Con- 

vention signed  at  Washington  July  24,   1899,   between 

the  United  States  and  France.     Dec.  6,  1899.     7  pp.     8°. 

56th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  22.  3846 

1900.  Documents    relating    to    the    reciprocity    convention    with 

France.     March  16,  1900.     165  pp.     8°. 
56th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  225.  3858 

Reprinted  in  "Compilation  of  the  reports  of  the  Committee  on 
foreign  relations,  United  States  Senate,  1789-1901"  (56th  Con- 
gress, 2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  231),  vol.  8,  pp.  474-635. 

Contents.— Text  of  reciprocity  convention  with  France;  Sections 
from  the  United  States  tariff  of  July  24,  1897,  as  modified  by  the 
pending  French  treaty;  Comparison  of  the  actual  concessions 
granted  by  the  United  States  and  by  France  under  the  provisions 
of  the  pending  treaty,  based  upon  United  States  statistics  of 
imports  and  exports  for  the  fiscal  year  1898,  the  exports  being 
those  of  domestic  origin  only;  Statements  and  letters  favoring 
ratification;  Memoranda  of  facts  relating  to  the  pending  French 
treaty;  Statements  and  letters  in  opposition  to  ratification. 

1900.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmitting 
additional  and  amendatory  articles  to  the  connnercial 
conventions  between  the  United  States  and  Great  Britain 
for  Bermuda,  British  Guiana,  Jamaica,  and  Turks  and 
Caicos  islands,  respectiveh^,  signed  at  Washington,  March 
16,1900.  March  19,  1900.  4  pp.  8°. 
56th  Congress,  1st  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive A,  Part  2. 


16  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1900.  Extending  time  for  ratification  of  commercial  convention 
between  the  United  States  and  France.  Message  from 
the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmitting  an  addi- 
tional and  amendatory  article  extending  the  period  fixed 
for  the  ratification  of  the  commercial  convention  between 
the  United  States  and  France,  signed  at  Washington,  July 
24,  1899.  March  21,  1900.  2  pp.  8°. 
56th  Congress,  1st  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive E,  pt.  2. 

1900.  Imports  from  France  under  reciprocal  commercial  arrange- 
ment, etc.  Letter  from  the  Secretary  of  the  treasury, 
transmitting  a  statement  showing  the  quantity  and  value 
of  merchandise  imported  into  the  United  States  under 
the  reciprocal  commercial  arrangement.  May  8,  1900. 
3  pp.  8°. 
56t}i  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  34-6.  3875 

1900.     United    States.     President    (McKinley).     A    proclamation 
[of  commercial  agreement  with  Portugal].     June  12, 1900. 
(In  U.  S.  Statutes  at  large,  vol.  31,  pp.  1974-1976.     Washington, 
1901.     4°.) 

1900.  United  States.  President  (McKinley).  Reciprocity  wdth 
Itaty.  A  proclamation  [of  commercial  agreement  wdth 
Italy].     July  18,  1900. 

(In  U.  S.  Statutes  at  large,  vol.  31,  pp.  1979-1981.     Washington, 
1901.     4°.) 

1900.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  trans- 
mitting a  commercial  convention  between  the  United 
States  and  the  Dominican  Repubhc,  signed  at  Washing- 
ton June  2  [i.  e.  25]  1900.  Dec.  5,  1900.  6  pp.  8°. 
66th  Congress,  2d  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive B. 

1900.     Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  commercial  convention  with  the  Republic  of  Ecua- 
dor, signed  July  10,  1900.     Dec.  5,  1900.     4  pp.     8°. 
56th    Congress,   2d   session.     Confidential.     [Senate]    Execu- 
tive C. 

1900.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  commercial  convention  between  the  United  States 
and  Nicaragua,  signed  October  20,  1899,  and  supplemen- 
tary convention  extending  the  time  within  which  the 
exchange  of  ratifications  shall  be  effected.  Dec.  5,  1900. 
5  pp.  8°. 
56th  Congress,  2d  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive D. 


reciprocity:  u.  s.  documents  17 

1900  Commercial  convention  with  Denmark  for  island  of  St.  Croix, 

signed  [Washington]  June  5,  1900.     Dec.  5,  1900.     3  pp. 

8° 
66th  Congress,  2d  session.    Confidential.    [Senate]  Executive  E. 

1901  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 

tincr  a  supplementary  convention  signed  at  Washmgton, 
March  8,  1901,  by  the  plenipotentiaries  of  the  United 
States  and  France,  prolonging  for  eighteen  months  from 
March  24,  1901,  the  time  for  the  ratifications  of  the  com- 
mercial convention  between  the  United  States  and  the 
RepubHc  of  France,  signed  July  24,  1899.     March  9,  1901. 

57th  Congress,  Special  session.     Confidential.     [Senate]  Ex- 
ecutive A. 

1901      Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
tinc^  a  convention  between  the  United  States  and  the 
Argentine  RepubUc,  extending  the  period  within  which 
may  be  exchanged  the  ratifications  of  the  commercial 
conventionsignedJulyl0,1899.     Dec.5,1901.     2  pp^    8°. 
57th    Congress,    1st  session.     Confidential.     [Senate]   Execu- 
tive F. 
1901      Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
tino-  a  convention  between  the  United  States  of  America 
and  Denmark,  extending  the  period  within  which  may  be 
exchano-ed  ratifications  of  the  commercial  convention  for 
the  isknd  of  St.  Croix,  signed  June  5,   1900.     Dec.  5, 
1901      2  pp.     8°. 
57th    Congress,    1st  session.     Confidential.     [Senate]    Execu- 
tive G. 

1901  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  convention  between  the  United  States  of  America 
and  Great  Britain,  extending  the  period  withm  which 
may  be  exchanged  the  ratifications  of  the  commercial 
conventions  for  British  Guiana,  Turks  and  Caicos  islands, 
Jamaica,  and  Bermuda,  signed  July  [18-]  24,  1899. 
Dec.  5,  1901.     3  pp.     8°.  .  .      ra       .  i    n 

57th   Congress,   1st  session.     Confidential.     [Senate]   Execu- 
tive H. 


18  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1901.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  convention  between  the  United  States  of  America 
and  Great  Britain,  extending  the  period  within  which  may 
be  exchanged  the  ratifications  of  the  commercial  conven- 
tion for  the  colony  of  Barbados,  signed  June  16,  1899. 
Dec.  5,  1901.  2  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive I. 

1901.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  convention  between  the  United  States  and  the 
Dominican  Republic,  extending  the  period  within  which 
may  be  exchanged  the  ratifications  of  the  commercial 
conventionsigned  June  25,  1900.  Dec.  5,  1901.  2  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive J. 

1901.  Charges  imposed  upon  certain  American  products  by  London 

dock  companies.     Dec.  16,  1901.     H  pp-     8°. 
^57th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  78.  4226 

1902.  Final  report  of  the  Industrial  commission.     Feb.  10,  1902. 

xi,. 1259  pp.     8°. 
57t}i  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc.  no.  380.  4349 

Reciprocity:  pp.  191-192. 

1902.  Charges  imposed  by  London  dock  companies  upon  certain 
American  products.  Message  from  the  President,  trans- 
mitting a  communication  from  the  Secretary  of  state  sub- 
mitting a  copy  of  a  report  made  by  Ambassador  Joseph 
H.  Choate  relative  to  certain  charges  imposed  by  the 
London  dock  companies  upon  American  flour  and  other 
American  products.  January  7,  1902.  48  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  96.  4226 

1902.  Resolutions  adopted  by  the  American  Chamber  of  commerce 
of  Paris,  France,  at  its  annual  meeting  held  in  Paris 
January  18,  1902,  favoring  the  ratification  of  the  pending 
reciprocity  treaty  between  the  United  States  and  France; 
presented  by  Mr.  Cullom.  Feb.  17,  1902.  1  page.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  199.  4234 

1902.  Convention  with  Great  Britain,  signed  Washington,  Mar.  15, 
1902,  extending  time  for  exchange  of  ratifications  of  com- 
mercial conventions  for  British  Guiana,  Turks  and  Caicos 
islands  and  Jamaica  [signed  July  18-22,  1899].  Mar.  18, 
1902.  3  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress  1st  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive N. 


reciprocity:  u.  s.  documents  19 

1902.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  convention  signed  at  Washington  on  April  26,  1902, 
prolonging  the  time  for  the  exchange  of  ratifications  of 
the  commercial  convention  with  Great  Britain  for  the 
island  of  Barbados,  signed  at  Washington  on  June  16, 
1899.  Apr.  29,  1902.  2  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive P. 

1902.  Additional  agreement,  amendatory  to  reciprocal  commercial 
agreement  with  France  of  May  28,  1898.  Signed,  Wash- 
ington, Aug.  20,  1902;  proclaimed  Aug.  22,  1902. 

{In  United   States.     Treaties,  etc.     Compilation   of  treaties  in 
force,  page  278.     Washington,  1904.     8°.) 

1902.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  convention  with  France,  signed  at  Washington  on 
September  24,  1902,  further  extending  the  time  within 
which  may  be  exchanged  the  ratifications  of  the  commer- 
cial convention  of  July  24, 1899.  Dec.  4, 1902.  2  pp.  8°. 
57tli  Congress,  2d  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive A. 

1902.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  convention  with  Denmark,  signed  at  Washington 
on  November  6,  1902,  further  extending  the  time  within 
wliich  may  be  exchanged  the  ratifications  of  the  commer- 
cial convention  for  the  island  of  Ste.  Croix.  Dec.  4,  1902. 
2  pp.  8°. 
57 th  Congress,  2d  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive B. 

1902.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  convention  with  Great  Britain,  signed  at  Washing- 
ton on  September  12,  1902,  further  extending  the  time 
within  which  may  be  exchanged  the  ratifications  of  the 
commercial  conventions  for  the  colonies  of  British  Guiana, 
Turks  and  Caicos  islands,  and  Jamaica.  Dec.  4,  1902. 
2  pp.  8°. 
o7th  Congress,  2d  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive C. 

1902.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 
ting a  convention  with  Great  Britain,  signed  at  Washing- 
ton on  October  26,  1902,  further  extending  the  time 
within  which  may  be  exchanged  the  ratifications  of  the 
commercial  convention  for  the  colony  of  Barbados.  Dec. 
4,  1902.  2  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.  Confidential.  [Senate]  Execu- 
tive D. 


20  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1902.  Jurisdiction  of  the  Senate  to  act  upon  reciprocity  treaties. 

Report  from  the  Committee  on  foreign  relations.     Dec. 
15,  1902.     3  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  J^l .  4420 

Recommended,  as  to  certain  pending  reciprocity  treaties,  without 
reference  to  the  merits  thereof,  "that  each  of  said  treaties  be 
amended  by  the  Senate  by  inserting  therein  the  following  addi- 
tional provision:  'This  treaty  shall  not  take  effect  until  the 
same  shall  have  been  approved  by  the  Congress.'  " 

1903.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 

ting a  report  by  the  Secretary  of  state,  with  accompanying 
papers,  relative  to  the  proceedings  of  the  first  Customs 
congress  of  the  American  republics,  held  at  New  York  in 
January,  1903.     Feb.  26,  1903.     195  pp.    8°. 
57ih  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  180.  4419 

English  and  Spanish. 

Contents. — Letters  of  transmittal. — Report  of  the  United  States 
delegation. — Resume  of  resolutions  approved  by  the  first  Cus- 
toms congress  of  the  American  republics. — Resolutions  of  the 
second  International  conference  of  American  states  calling  for 
the  assembling  of  a  customs  congress. — Journal  of  proceedings 
of  the  first  Customs  congress  of  American  republics. — Ap- 
pendices. 

1904.  Last  speech  of  William  McKinley.     Delivered  at  the  Pan- 

American    exposition    at    Buffalo,    September    5,    1901. 
April  13,  1904.     Presented  by  Mr.  Fairbanks,  and  ordered 
to  be  printed.     11pp.     8°. 
58tli  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  268.  4592 

1906.  Commercial  agreement  between  the  United  States  and  Spain 

under  section  3,  Tariff  act,  July  24,  1897. 

{In  United  States.  Treaties,  etc.  Treaties,  conventions,  interna- 
tional acts,  protocols  and  agreements  .  .  .  1776-1909,  vol.  2, 
pp.  1718-1721.     Washington,  1910.    8°.) 

1907.  United  States.      Treaties,  etc.,  1901-1909  {Roosevelt).     Com- 

mercial agreement  between  the  United  States  and  Ger- 
many. June,  1907.  (2),  24  pp.  8°.  {Bureau  of  manu- 
factures.     Tariff  series  no.  5.) 

1908.  Brazil.     Laws,  statutes,  etc.     Brazil.     Preferential  tariff  on 

American  products.    4  pp.     8°.    {Bureau  of  manufactures. 
Tariff  series  no.  16.) 

1908.  Commercial  agreement  between  Germany  and  United  States, 
with  its  annexes,  etc.  Message  from  the  President  .  .  . 
transmitting  the  commercial  agreement  .  .  .  and  tlie 
report  of  the  American  commission  on  which  it  is  based. 
Jan.  22,  190S.  32  pp.  8°. 
60th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  185.  5240 


keciprocity:  u.  s.  documents  21 

1908.  United  States.  Treaties,  etc.,  1901-1909  {Roosevelt).  Com- 
iiieicial  agreement  between  the  United  States  and  France. 
February  1,  1908.  4  pp.  8°.  {Bureau  of  manufactures. 
Tariff  series  no.  6 A.) 

1908. Commercial  agreement  between  the  United 

States  and  the  Netherlands,  under  section  3,  Tariff  act, 
July  24,  1897.     7  pp.     8°.     {Treaty  series,  no.  505.) 
English  and  Dutch. 
Signed  at  ^\'ashington,  May  16,  1907;  ratified  by  the  Netherlands, 

July  11,  1908;  proclaimed,  August  12,  1908. 
Concerning  tariff  on  brandies  and  other  distilled  spirits  from  the 
Netherlands,  and  on  meat  products  from  the  United  States. 

1909. Supplemental  commercial  agreement  effected 

by  exchange  of  notes  between  United  States  and  Spain. 
Signed  at  Wasliington,  February  20,  1909.  5  pp.  8°. 
{Treaty  series,  no.  517.) 

Relates  to  tariff  on  Spanish  sparkling  wines. 


FOREIGN   DOCUMENTS 

1827.  Great  Britain.  Foreign  office.  Correspondence  relative  to 
commercial  intercourse  between  the  United  States  of 
America,  and  the  British  West  India  colonies.  August, 
1826,  to  January,  1827.  Presented  to  both  Houses  of 
Parliament,  1827.      (4),  27  pp.     F°. 

{In     Great     Britain.     Parliament.     Sessional     papers,     1826/27, 
vol.  25.) 

1830.  Great  Britain.  Foreign  office.  Correspondence  between 
Great  Britain  and  the  United  States,  relative  to  commer- 
cial intercourse  between  America  and  the  British  West 
India  colonies.  Dec,  1829,  to  Nov.,  1830.  Presented  to 
both  Houses  of  Parhament,  1830.     (4),  31  pp.     F°. 

{In    Great     Britain.     Parliament.     Sessional     papers,     1830-31, 
vol.  16.) 

1885.  Great  Britain.  Foreign  office.  Commercial.  No.  4(1885). 
Correspondence  respecting  the  negotiation  of  a  treaty 
regulating  trade  between  the  British  West  India  colonies 
and  the  United  States.     1885.     (2),  24  pp.     F°. 

{In    Great    Britain.      Parliament.      Sessional    papers,     1884-85. 
vol.  71.) 

1890.  Mexico.  Ministerio  de  fomento,  colonizacion  e  industria. 
Reciprocidad    comercial    entre    Mexico    y    los    Estados 

Unidos. 
Mexico:  Ojicina  tip.  de  la  Secretaria  de  fomento,  1890.     350, 
vi  pp.     8°. 

Preface  signed :  M.  Romero. 

Contents. — 1.  pte.  Documentos  oficiales  referentes  al  tratado  de 
reciprocidad  entre  Mexico  y  los  Estados  Unidos,  de  20  de  enero 
de  1883. — 2.  pte.  Discusion  en  la  prensa  periodica  respecto  de  lea 
tratados  de  reciprocidad. 
22 


BOOKS 

Adams,  Brooks.    America's  economic  supremacy. 

y„  York:  The  MaamlUn  company,  1900.    ix,^Mpp.    «■ 

American  academy  of  poUtical  and  social  science,  PKUdel- 

nliia.     Tariff  revision.  ,.  .    -,        j         •  i 

PUUdelpJiia:     American   academy    of  political   and   social 

sdence    1908.     in  AD,  ^05  w     5°.     {TU  annah  of  the 

American  academy  of  political  and  social  science,     vol. 

^''"'XTTEfi-Tariff  revision  a  public  necessity  [by]  I>- M-  Parry.- 
What  provisions  of  the  Dingley  tariff  require  revision?  [by]  A^ 
Clarke  -mat  ought  the  tariff  rates  to  be  on  iron  and  steel 
manufactures?  [by]  A.  B.  Farquhar. -Tariff  rates  on  hardware 
ThvA  C    W    Asbury .-Hides,  leather,  boots  and  shoes  and  the 
tariff  [by]  A    A.  Healv.-mat  ought  the  tariff  rates  to  be  on 
paper  and  pulp?  [by]  C.  W.  Lyman. -Reciprocity  in  our  foreagn 
trade  relations  [by]  W.  R.  Corwine.-Tanff  --^r^.^lSn; 
tion  for  American  labor  [by]  J.  R.  Commons. -Tanff  relations 
Xh  Cuba-actual  and  desirable  [by]  E.  F.  Atkins. -Commercial 
rations  of  the  United  States  -th  Canada  [by]  J.  B^  O^ We .- 
Notes  on  our  tariff  relations  with  Mexico  [by]  F.  B    Loomis. 
Waste  in  external  trade  in  general  and  with  the  One.t  in  par- 
ticular [by]  J.  P.  Young.-Our  tariff  relations  with  the  Philip- 
pics- ctual  and  desirable  [by]  C.  R.  Edwards -The  con ven 
Lnal  tariff  system  [by]  N.  I.  Sto-  -The  Amencan  in  e^^^^^^^^ 
tion  of  the  "most  favored  nation"  clause  [by]  C.  L.  Jones^-The 
Maximum  and  minimum  tariff  [by]  J.  F.  Crowell.-Tanff  mak- 
S^._fact  and  theory  [by]  H.  E.  Miles. -A  permanent  tanff 
commission  [by]  A.  J.  Beveridge.-Import  duties:  how  they 
Should  be  levied  [by]  D.  A.  Tompkins^An  argument  for  a 
permanent  expert  tariff  commission  [by]  H.  E.  Miles. 

.     Tariffs,  reciprocity  and  foreign  trade. 

AiudelvlL     American   academy    of  political   and   social 
science,    1907.     (2),    118   pp.     8^.     (The   annaU   of  th 
American  academy   of  poUtical  and  social  science,    vol. 

''''c!';fNL.-Development  of  the  foreign  trade  of  the  United  States 
[by]  E.  Root.-Reciprocity  with  continental  Europe  b>]  A.  H. 
Landers.-A  brief  history  of  the  ^Z^'IVl^ m'IZ^- 
Curtis.-Reciprocity  and  the  middle  West  [by]  D.  M- Pa^  _ 
Reciprocity  and  its  relation  to  foreign  trade  [by]  G  L.  UuvaL 
What  Americans  must  do  to  to  make  an  export  business  [by] 


24  LIBEARY    OF    CONGRESS 

J.  W.  Van  Cleave. — The  double  tariff  system  [by]  N.  I.  Stone. — 
Tariff  provisions  for  promotion  of  foreign  trade  of  the  United 
States  [by]  G.  G.  Huebner. — American  manufactures  and  for- 
eign markets  [by]  E.  N.  Foss. — The  tariff  and  the  price  of  agri- 
cultural machines  [by]  C.  Deering. — Our  tariff  in  its  relation  to 
the  grain  trade  [by]  L.  Miiller. — The  tariff  and  our  foreign  trade 
in  meats  [by]  J.  O.  Armour. — The  tariff  and  our  foreign  trade  in 
electrical  apparatus  [by]  M.  Coster. — The  leather  industry  and 
the  tariff  [by]  A.  A.  Healy.— The  tariff  and  the  lumber  trade 
[by]  W.  B.  Mershon. 

American  chamber  of  commerce,  Paris.  The  tariff  relations 
existing  between  France  and  the  United  States,  compared 
with  the  customs  duties  determined  by  treaties  of  com- 
merce between  France  and  other  countries.  Report 
printed  by  order  of  the  American  chamber  of  commerce, 
Paris.  Stoddard  Dew^ey,  statistician. 
[Paris]  1897.     15  pp.     8°. 

Ashley,  Percy  Walter  Llewellyn.  Modern  tariff  history:  Germany, 
United  States,  France.  With  a  preface  by  the  Rt.  Hon. 
R.  B,  Haldane. 

London:  J.  Murray,  1904.     ^xiii,  (2),  367,  (1)  pp.     8°. 
Short  bibliography  with  each  part. 
"Reciprocity  under  the  American  tariff":  pp.  252-262. 

Atkinson,  Edw^ard.     Reciprocity. 

Boston:    Pub.  hy  the  American  free  trade  league,  1903.     17 
pp.     8°. 

Barclay,  Sir  Thomas.     Bearing  and  importance  of  commercial  trea- 
ties in  the  twentieth  century;  a  lecture  delivered  on  6th 
December,  1905. 
Manchester:    At  the    University  press,   1906.     27  pp.     8°. 
{Manchester  university  lectures,     no.  3.) 
"United  States  tariff  policy":  pp.  15-19. 

Bass,  William  Louis.     Reciprocidad.     Exposicion  presentada  al  go- 
bierno  de  la  Republica  Dominicana. 
Santo  Domingo:   R.  D.,  Imp.  "La  Cuna  de  America,"  1902. 
126,  U),  110  pp.     12°. 

Articles  on  reciprocity  by  several  authors:  110  pp.  at  end. 

Bastable,  Charles  Francis.     The  commerce  of  nations.     2d  ed.,  rev. 
London:    Methuen  <&  co.,  1899.     x,  216  pp.     12°.     (Social 
questions  of  to-day  [5].) 

"Reciprocity  and   retaliation":    pp.    187-201;    "Treaties":   pp. 
62,71. 


reciprocity:  general  works  25 

Bastable,  Charles  Francis.     The  theory  of  international  trade,  with 
some  of  its  applications  to  economic  policy.     4th  ed.,  rev. 
London,  New  York:    Macmillan  and  co.,  limited,  1903.     xvi, 
197  pp.     12°. 

Bastiat,   Frederic.     Fallacies  of   protection;  being    the   Sophismes 
economiques  of  Frederic  Bastiat,  tr.  from  the  5th  ed.  of 
the  French  by  Patrick  James  Stirling. 
London,  New  York  [etc.]:  Pub.  for  the  Cobden  club  by  Cassell 
and  company,  limited,  1909.     viii,  230  pp.     8° . 
"Reciprocity":  pp.  72-75;  96-98. 

Bates,  William  W.     American  marine.     The  shipping  question   in 
history  and  politics.     2d  ed. 
Boston  and    New    York:  Houghton,    Mifflin  and   company, 
1897.     xiv,479pp.     Portrait.     8°. 

"Declension  under  reciprocity  policy":  pp.  125-149. 

American  navigation;  the  political  history  of  its  rise  and 

ruin  and  the  proper  means  for  its  encouragement. 
Boston  and   New    York:   Houghton,   Mifflin  and  company, 
1902.     xvi,  466,  (2)  pp.     8°'. 

"Extension  of  reciprocity  by  acts  and  conventions":  pp.  234-253; 
"The  second,  third  and  last  acts  of  reciprocity":  pp.  254-276; 
"Maritime  reciprocity  in  theory  and  practice":  pp.  277-289. 

Beaujon,  Anthony.     Handel  en  Handelspolitiek. 

Haarlem:  H.  D.  Tjeenk  Willink,  1888.    (8),  165,  (3)  jrp.     8°. 
"Retorsie  en  reciprociteit " :  pp.  136-154. 

" Handelstractaten  en  het  beding  van  meestbegunstiging " :  pp. 
155-165. 

Bolce,  Harold.     The  new  internationalism. 

New  York:  D.  Appleton  and  company,  1907.     (6),  309  pp. 

12°. 

Contents. — The  Arcady  of  Mammon. — The  international  ad- 
vance.— Reprisals  and  panics. — More  reprisals  and  panics. — -The 
cost  of  commercial  conflict. — Europe's  wealth  America's  oppor- 
tunity.— Our  fanciful  picture  of  foreign  trade. — The  taste  and 
trend  of  Europe. — Advertising  in  Europe. — No  nation  can 
monopolize  commerce. — The  standpatters.— Trade  mistakes  and 
successes. — A  short  cut  to  reciprocity. — Triumphs  and  tangles  of 
reciprocity. — The  world's  progress. 

Bolen,  George  Lewis,     The  plain  facts  as  to  the  trusts  and  the  tariff, 
with  chapters  on  the  railroad  problem  and    municipal 
monopolies. 
New  York,  London:  The  Macmillan  company,  1902.     viii, 
451  pp.     12°. 

"List  of  books  cited":  p.  viii. 

"Reciprociiy  ":  pp.  241,  298,  299,  302,  305,  346,  373,  389-391,  399, 
408-437. 


26  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Borchardt^  Felix.     Entwickelungsgeschichte  der  Meistbegiinstigung 

im  Handelsvertragssystem. 
Kbnigsberg  i.  Pr.:  Hartungsche  BucMr.,  1906.     U),  83,  (3) 
pp.     8°. 

Inaug.-diss. — Heidelberg. 

" Literaturverzeichnis " :  1  p.  at  end. 

Borght,  Richard  van  der.     Handel  und  Handelspolitik.     2.  Aiifl. 

Leipzig:  C.  L.  Hirschf eld,  1907.  xi,  (1),  648  pp.  4°-  (Hand- 
und  Lehrhucli  der  Staatswissenschaften  .  .  .  l.Abt.:  Volks- 
wirtschaftslehre.     xvi.  Bd.) 

"Literatur"  at  beginning  of  chapters. 
"Die  Handelsvertrage" :  pp.  478-500. 

Borgius,  Viktor  Walther  Paul.     Deutschland  und  die  Vereinigten 

Staaten.     Ein  handelspolitischer  Riickblick  bei  Eroffnung 

des  Internationalen  Handelskongresses  zu  Philadelphia, 

Berlin:  J.  Guttentag,  1899.     (8),  124  pp.     8°.     {Schriftender 

Centralstellefur  Vorhereitung  von  Handelsvertrdgen.   8.  lift.) 

Bosc,  L.     Zollalliancen  und  Zollunionen  in  ihrer  Bedeutung  fur  die 
Handelspolitik    der    Vergangenheit    und    Zukunft.     Aus 
dem  franzosischen  ins  deutsche  tibertragen  von  Dr.  S. 
Schilder. 
Berlin:  E.  Staude,  1907.     {24),  365,  viii  pp.     8°. 
"Bibliographische  Abriss":  pp.  i-viii. 

Calwer,  Richard.     Die  Meistbegiinstigung  der  Vereinigten  Staaten 
von  Nordamerica. 
Berlin  [etc.]:  Akademisclier  Verlagfiir  sociale  WissenscJiaften, 
Dr.  John  Edelheim,  1902.     154  PP-     8°. 

Cavarretta,  Giuseppe.     La  clausola  della  nazione  piii  favorita. 
Palermo:  A.  Reher,  1906.     236,  {2)  pp.     8°. 

Review,  by  Daniel  Crick,  in  Revue  de  droit  international  et  de 
legislation  comparee,  1906,  2.  ser.,  t.  8,  pp.  787-789. 

Chapman,  Sydney  J.     The  history  of  trade  between  the  United 
Kingdom  and  the  United  States,  with  special  reference  to 
the  effect  of  tariffs. 
London:  Swan  SonnenscTiein  &  co.,  1899.     vii,  (2),  118  pp. 
Diagrams.     Folded  charts.     12°. 

Chiozza-Money,  Leone  George.     Elements  of  the  fiscal  problem. 

London:  P.  S.  King  &  son,  1903.     (8),  237  pp.    Table.    8°. 
"Most  favoured  nation  ":  pp.  148-161. 


reciprocity:  general  works  27 

Chotteau,  Leon.     Franco-American  treaty  of  commerce.     My  two 
campaigns  in  the  United  States.     1878-1879. 
New  Yorl,  1879.     114  PP-     S°. 

Le  traite  de  commerce  franco-americain.     Avec  une  pre- 
face par  M.  Menier. 
Paris:  Sandoz  c€'  FischhacJier,  1878.     xix,  111,  {2)  pp.     12°. 

Clarke,  Albert.     The  tariflf  made  i)lain;  seven  short  conversations 
that  bring  out  both  sides,  proofs  cited  and  academic  and 
popidar  errors  corrected.     35th  thousand. 
Boston:  The  Home  market  club,  1906.     79  pp.     8°.      (The 
bright  and  strong  papers.) 

Reciprocity:  pp.  25-32,  75-79. 

Cooke,  H.  B.    The  two  tarifi'  systems  compared ;  a  plain  statement  of 
results;  also  concerning  trusts  and  reciprocity. 
Louisville,   Ky.:  Brewers  printing  house,   ['^WOS].     218  pp. 
12°. 

Reciprocity:  pp.  138-153. 

Cummins,  Albert  B.     Reciprocity. 

{In    The    Americana;    a  universal   reference   library,    vol.    15, 
United  States,  no.  47  (4^  pp).     New  York,  [1907].     4°.) 

Curtis,  W.  E.     Trade  and  transportation  between  the  United  States 
and  Spanish  America. 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1889.     xiii,  3^2  pp. 
8°. 

Also  issued  as  Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  54,  of  51st  Congress,  1st  session. 

Davenport,  T.  W.     The  tariff,  the  trusts,  and  the  farmers. 

[Boston:  American  free  trade  league,  1901.]     7  pp.     8°. 

Dewey,  D.  R.     Reciprocity  in  the  United  States. 

{In  Palgrave,  R.  H.  Inglis,  ed.     Dictionary  of  political  economy, 
vol.  3,  pp.  268-269.     London,  1901.     8°.) 

Dietzel,  Heinrich.     Retaliatory  duties.     Tr.  by  D.  W.  Simon  and 
W.  Osborne  Brigstocke. 
London:  T.  F.  Unwin,  1906.     128  pp.     12°. 

Douglas,   Stephen  Arnold.     An  American  continental  commercial 
union  or  alliance.     Ed.  with  preface  by  J.  Madison  Cutts. 
Washington,    D.    C:  [T.    McGill    &    co.,   pHnters],    1889. 
36  pp.     8°. 


28  LIBRARY   OF    CONGRESS 

Dunbar,  Edward  E.     The  Mexican  papers.     The  Mexican  question, 
the  great  American  question,  with  personal  reminiscences. 
A  serial  issued  semi-monthly. 
New    York:  J.  A.   H.   Hashrouck    cfc    co.,   -printers,   1860. 
83-129  pp.     8°.     {First  series,  no.  3,  Sept.  15,  1860.) 

Deals  ■with  the  commercial  treaty  with  Mexico,  which  the  Senate, 
in  1860,  failed  to  ratify.  «■ 

Farquhar,  Arthur  B.     The  need  of  reciprocity. 

[Boston:  American  free  trade  league,  1902.]     6  pp.     8°. 

Fawcett,  Henry.     Free  trade  and  protection.     An  inquiry  into  the 
causes  which  have  retarded  the  general  adoption  of  free 
trade  since  its  introduction  into  England. 
London:   Macmillan  and  co.,  1878.     xvi,  173  pp.     8°. 

"Free  trade  and  reciprocity":  pp.  48-73;  "Commercial  treaties": 
pp.  154-173. 

Ferme,  Gabriel.     O  Brazil  e  o  projecto  da  uniao  aduaneira  ameri- 
cana. 
Paris:  A.  Prince  &  c'%  1887.     92  pp.     4°. 

Fisk,  George  Mygatt.     Die  Handelspolitik  der  Yereinigten  Staaten 
1890-1900.     Ubersetzt  von  Louis  Katzenstein. 

{In  Beitrage  zur  neuesten  Handelspolitik  Deutschlands,  Bd.  1, 
pp.    1-101.     Leipzig,     1900.     8°.     Schriften    des    Vereins    fiir 
Socialpolitik,  no.  90.) 
Reciprocitat:   pp.    23-33;    "Die   Klausel   der  meistbegiinstigten 
Nationen":  pp.  34-46. 

Die  handelspolitischen  und  sonstigen  volkerrechtlichen  Be- 

ziehungen  zwischen  Deutschland  und  den  Vereinigten 
Staaten  von  Amerika.  Eine  historisch-statistischc  Studie. 
Stuttgart:  J.  G.  Cotta'scJie  BucMand.  NacJif.,  1897.  xiv,  254 
])p.  8°.  (MiincTiener  volkswirtscJiaftlicTie  Studien.  20. 
Stuck.) 

"Litteraturverzeichnis":  pp.  ix-xi. 

"DieMeistbegiinstigung":  pp.  62-63,  252-254. 

International  commercial  policies,  with  special  reference  to 

the  United  States;  a  text  book. 
New   York,  London:  The   Macmillan  company,  1907.     xvi, 
288  pp.     12°.     {The  citizen's  library  of  economics.  p)olitics, 
and  sociology,  ed.  hy  R.  T.  Ely.) 
Bibliography  at  end  of  each  chapter. 
"General  bibliography":  pp.  259-272. 
"Commercial  treaties.    Reciprocity  and  the  most  favored  nation 

clause":  pp.  161-176. 
Review,  by  H.  S.  Smalley,  in  Journal  of  political  economy,  vol. 
16,  Mar.,  1908,  pp.  168-170. 


reciprocity:  general  works  29 

Flux,  A.  W.     Do  reciprocally  preferential   tariffs  tend  towards  free 

trade  ? 

{In  American  economic  association.     Publications.     3d  eer.,  vol. 

6,  May,  1905,  pp.  336-358.     New  York,  1905.     8°.) 
Discussion  on  reciprocity  and  preferential  tariffs:  pp.  359-375. 

Foss,  Eugene  Noble.     Reciprocity    as    an    economic    policy    in    its 
relation  to  foreign  trade. 

{In  National  association  of  manufacturers  of  the  United  States  of 
America.  Proceedings  of  the  tenth  annual  convention,  Atlanta, 
1905,  pp.  152-171.     New  York  [1905].     8°.) 

Furber,  H.  W.,  ed.     Both  protection  and  free  trade.     Articles  from 
the  most  eminent  political  economists  and  statesmen. 
Boston:  Boston  'publishing  company,  1888.     528  pp.     8°. 

Glier,  L.  Die  Meistbegiinstigungs-Klausel.  Eine  entwickelungsge- 
schichtliche  Studie  unter  besonderer  Beriicksichtigung  der 
deutschen  Vertrage  mit  den  Vereinigten  Staaten  von 
Amerika  und  mit  Argentinien. 
Berlin:  G.  Reimer,  1905.  xix,  434  PP-  4°-  (Veroffentlich- 
ungen  des  Mitteleuropdischen  Wirtschaftsverein,  Hft.  ii.) 

"Versuch    einer    Chronologic    der    Meistbegiinstigungs-Klausel 

(1703-1903)":  pp.  376-434. 
Review,  by  Sigmund  Schilder,  in  Zeitschrift  fiir  Socialwissen- 
schaft,  Oct.,  1905,  vol.  8,  pp.  622-636. 

Grunzel,  Josef.     System  der  HandelspoHtik.     2.  verb.  Aufi. 

Leipzig:  Duncker  &  Humhlot,  1906.     ix,  615,  (1)  pp^     8°. 
Bibliographical  references. 
"Reziprozitat  und  Meistbegiinstigung":  pp.  455-471. 

Hadley,  Arthur  T.     Reciprocity. 

{In  Lalor,  J.  J.,  ed.  Cyclopasdia  of  political  science,  vol.  3,  pp. 
537-539.     New  York,  1899.     4°.) 

Handelsvertrage . 

{In  Meyers  Grosses  Konversations-lexikon.  6.  Aufl.,  vol.  8,  pp. 
745-747.     Leipzig  und  Wien,  1904.     4°.) 

Harris,  C.  A.     Reciprocity. 

{In  Palgrave,  R.  H.  Inglis,  ed.  Dictionary  of  political  economy, 
vol.  3,  pp.  267-268.     London,  1901.     8°.) 

Herod,  Joseph  Rogers.     Favored  nation  treatment;  an  analysis  of 
the  most  favored  nation  clause,  with  commentaries  on  its 
uses  in  treaties  of  commerce  and  navigation. 
New  York:  The  Banks  law  publishing  co.,  1901.     v,  (1),  134 
pp.     8°. 
27306°— 10 3 


30  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Hesseltine,  Norman  F.     The  sham  of  RepubHcan  reciprocity. 

[Boston:  American  free  trade  league,  1901.]    (8)-ll  pp.     8°. 
(In  pamphlet  with  Davenport,  T.  W.,  The  tariff,  the  trusts,  and 
the  farmers.) 

Hornbeck,  Stanley  Kuhl.  The  most-favored-nation  clause  in  com- 
mercial treaties,  its  function  i;^  theory  and  in  practice  and 
its  relation  to  tariff  policies.  Madison,  Wis.,  1910.  121 
pp.  8°.  (Bulletin  of  the  University  of  Wisconsin,  no.  343. 
Economics  and  political  science  series,  vol.  6,  no.  2) 
Bibliogi-aphy:  pp.  113-121. 

International  American   conference.     1st,    Washington,    D.    C, 
1889-1890.     Minutes  of  the  International  American  con- 
ference. 
[Washington:  Government   printing    office],    1890.     (2),    905 
pp.     4°. 

English  and  Spanish  in  parallel  columns. 

Reports  of  committees  and  discussions  thereon.     (Revised 

under  the  directions  of  the  executive  committee  by  order 

of  the  conference,  adopted  March  7,  1890.)     English  ed. 

Washington:  [Government  printing  office],  1890.     4  "^'ols.     4°- 

Vol.  1,  pp.  103-264:  "Reciprocity  treaties."     Includes  majority 

and  minority  reports  of  the  committee  on  customs  union  and 

discussion  on  the  proposed  customs  union  between  the  nations 

of  America.     Vol.  2:     "Historical  appendix.     The  congress  of 

1826  at  Panama,"  etc. 

2d,    Mexico,    1901-1902.    'Organization   of   the   conference, 

projects,  reports,  motions,  debates,  and  resolutions.    Edi- 
tion issued  under  the  direction  of  the  general  sec^etar^^ 
English  text. 
Mexico:  Government    jwinting    office,    1902.     (2),    403,    (1) 
pp.     F°. 

Report  of  the  committee  on  commerce  and  reciprocity,   with 
discussion  and  resolutions :  pp.  123-130. 

Jefferson,  Thomas.  Report  on  the  privileges  and  restrictions  on 
the  commerce  of  the  United  States  in  foreign  countries. 
[Dec.  16,  1793.] 

(In  his  Writings.     Definitive  ed.,  vol.  3,  pp.  261-283.     Washing- 
ton, 1905.     8°.) 
On  reciprocity:  -pp.  274  etseq. 

Kasson,  John  Adam.     Reciprocity;  the  benefits  that  will  accrue  to 
this  country  by  the  confirmation  of  the  treaties  now  pend- 
ing in  the  United  States  Senate. 
[Chicago:  Rogers  and  Wells  printers,  1901.]     44,  (6)  pp.    12°. 
"Delivered  before  the  Illinois  manufacturers'  association  at  Chi- 
cago, October  24,  1901." 


becipeocity:  general  works  •  31 

King,  William  F.     International  arbitration  and  reciprocity.  •  Work 
of  the  recent  convention  at  Lake  Mohonk — past  and  fu- 
ture   considered    in    connection    with    national    growth. 
Written  for  the  New  York  Times. 
[New  YorJc,  W02f]     3-16  pp.     12°. 
Cover-title. 

Laughlin,   James  Laurence.     Industrial  America;    Berlin  lectures 
of  1906. 
New    Y^or^{::    C.   Scribner's    so7is,   1906.     viii,    (4),    261   pp. 
Maps.     Diagrams.     8°. 

Protectionism  and  reciprocity:  pp.  33-66. 

Laughlin,  James  Laurence,  and  H.  Parker  Willis.     Reciprocity. 

New   Yorl:   Tie  Baker  cfc    Taylor  co.,  [1903].     xi,  583  pp. 
Charts.     8°. 

Bibliography:  pp.  439-471. 

Reviewed  by  W.  H.  Glasson,  in  South  Atlantic  quarterly,  vol.  2, 
July,  1903,  pp.  281-284;  by  I.  M.  Rubinow,  in  Political  science 
quarterly,  vol.  18,  Sept.  1903,  pp.  554-556,  and  by  W.  M.  Daniels, 
in  the  Nation,  vol.  77,  Oct.  1,  1903,  pp.  268-269. 

Lowe,  Francis  J.     Articles  on  reciprocity. 

[Chicago?     Farm  implement  news,  1906 f]     (8)  pj).     8°. 
Reprinted  from  Farm  implement  news,  Chicago. 

Lyman,  Theodore,  jr.     The  diplomacy  of  the  United  States.     Being 
an  account  of  the  foreign  relations  of  the  country  from  the 
first  treaty  with  France,  in  1778,  to  the  present  time.     2d 
ed.  with  additions. 
Boston:    Wells  and  Lilly,  1828.     2  vols.   '8°. 

Commercial  convention  of  1815  with  Great  Britain:  vol.  2,  pp. 
59-75;  Commercial  convention  of  1818  with  Great  Britain:  vol. 
2,  pp.  76-118;  Convention  of  navigation  and  commerce  of  1822 
with  France:  vol.  2,  pp.  170-190;  Colonial  trade  with  Great 
Britain:   vol.  2,  pp.  310-334. 

McKee,  Thomas  Hudson.  The  national  conventions  and  platforms 
of  all  political  parties,  1789  to  1904;  convention,  popular, 
and  electoral  vote.  Also  the  political  c©m^lexion  of  both 
houses  of  Congress  at  each  biennial  period.  5th  ed.,  rev. 
and  enl. 
Baltimore,  Md.:  The  Friedenwald  comjmny,  1904-  (6),  4H) 
(2),  33,(1)  pp.     12°. 

For  mention  of  reciprocity  in  the  various  party  platforms  consult 
the  index. 


32 


LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 


McKinley,  William.  The  last  speech  of  William  McKinley,  presi- 
dent of  the  United  States,  deUvered  at  the  Pan-American 
exposition,  Buffalo,  New  York,  on  the  fifth  of  September, 
1901. 
Canton,  Pa.:  Printed  hy  the  Kirgate  'press  of  Lewis  Buddy, 
3rd,  1901.     (6),  15  2)1).     Portrait.     12°. 

President  McKinley's  Buffalo  speech,  with  some  thoughts 

suggested  thereby. 
[Yonlcers,  1901]     20  pp.     12°. 

"Reprinted  from  The  Yonkers  statesman." 

President  McKinley's  last  public  address  and  proclamation. 

[St.  Louis?    1902?]    7,(1)  pp.     Illustrations.    Portrait.    24°. 
Cover-title. 


The  tariff  in  the  days  of  Henry  Clay  and  since.     An  ex- 
haustive review  of  our  tariff  legislation  from  1812  to  1896, 
New  York:  Henry  Clay  puhlisMng  co.,  1896.     (2),  256,  (6), 
pp.     8°. 

Mallet,  Sir  Louis.     Reciprocity.     A  letter  addressed  to  Mr.  Thomas 
Bayley  Potter,  m.  p.,  as  chairman  of  the  committee  of  the 
Cobden  club. 
London,  New  Yoric  [etc.]:  Printed  for  the  Cohden  cluh,  hy  Cas- 
sell,  Petter  c&  Galpin  [1879].     32  pp.     12°. 

Moore,  John  Bassett.     A  digest  of  international  law. 

Washington:  Government  printing  ofjice,  1906.  8  vols.  8°. 
{56th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  doc.  no.  551.) 

By  the  act  of  Congress  of  February  20,  1897,  a  provision  was  made 
for  "revising,  reindexing,  and  otherwise  completing  and  per- 
fecting by  the  aid  of  such  documents  as  may  be  useful,  the  sec- 
ond edition  of  the  Digest  of  the  international  law  of  the  United 
States."  The  work  thus  referred  to  .  .  .  edited  by  Francis 
Wharton,  ll.  d.,  was  published  in  three  volumes  in  1886.  A 
second  issue,  embracing  about  160  pages  of  new  matter,  added  to 
the  third  volume,  was  made  in  1887.     cf.  Pref. 

Reciprocity  with  Hawaii:  vol.  1,  pp.  483,  485-488,  491-^94;  Reci- 
procity treaty,  1854,  between  United  States  and  Canada:  vol.  1, 
pp.  791-792;  vol.  5,  pp.  722-723;  Legislative  abrogation  of  reci- 
procity treaties  adopted  under  the  McKinley  act:  vol.  5,  pp. 
359-363. 

National  association  of  agricultural  implement  and  vehicle 
manufacturers.      Committee     on     national     legislation. 
Commercial  reciprocity. 
Chicago:  F.  E.  Luhens,  [1901].     95  pp.     8°. 


reciprocity:  general  works  33 

National  association  of  manufacturers  of  the  United  States 
of  America.  Commercial  reciprocit}';  [discussion  and 
resolutions  adopted]. 

(In  Us  Proceedings  of  the  sixth  annual  convention,  Detroit,  1901, 

pp.  95-115.     Philadelphia  [1901].     8°.) 
Paper  by  James  Deering,  submitted  by  William  ('.  IJarker  as  part 
of  his  remarks:  pp.  104-112. 

National  board  of  trade.     [Reports  and  debates  on  reciprocity.] 
(In  its  Proceedings  of  the  .  .  .  annual  meeting,  1894-date.     Bos- 
ton [etc.]     1894-date.     8°.) 

National  reciprocity.     A  magazine  devoted  to  reciprocity  and  its 
value  to  our  trade  with  other  nations,     v.  1,  no.  1-10; 
Sept.  1902-June  1903. 
Chicago:    National  reciprocity  league,  [1902-03].     1  vol.  in  2. 
8°.     Monthly. 

Official  organ  of  the  National  reciprocity  league. 

National  reciprocity  convention.  1st,  Washington,  D.  C,  1901. 
Proceedings  of  the  National  reciprocity  convention  held 
under  the  auspices  of  the  National  association  of  manu- 
facturers of  the  United  States  of  America.  Washington, 
D.  C,  November  19  and  20,  1901. 
[Washington?     1901.]     (2),  186  pp.     8°. 

Oncken,  August.     Handelsvertrage. 

(In  Handworterbuch  der  Staatswissenschaften,   hrsg.  von  J.  Con- 
rad, 3d  ed.,  vol.  5,  pp.  346-362.     Jena,  1910.     4°.) 
"Die  Klaucel  der  meistbegiinstigten  Nation"  :  pp.  351-353;  "Das 
Prinzip  des  Gegenrechts  (Reziprozitat)  ":  pp.  357-358. 

Osborne,  John  Ball.     Expansion  through  reciprocity. 

(In  La  Follette,  Robert  M.  ed.     The  making  of  America,  vol.  2, 
pp.  375-391.     Chicago,  1906.     8°.) 

Reciprocity  in  the  American  tariff  system. 

Philadelphia:  American  academy  of  political  and  social  sci- 
ence [1904?]     55-83  pp.     8°.     (Publications  of  the  Amer- 
ican academy  of  political  and  social  science,  no.  403.) 
Cover-title. 

Reprinted  from  The  Annals  of  the  American  academy  of  political 
and  social  Science  for  January,  1904. 

Patten,  Simon  N.     The  economic  basis  of  protection. 

Philadelphia:  J.  B.  Lippincott  company,  1890.    144  PP-    ^^°- 

Philbert,  V.     De  la  liberte  du  commerce  dans  les  traites  de  commerce. 
Paris:  A.  Rousseau,  1902.     viii,  197,   (2)  pp.     8°.     (Uni- 
versite  de  Paris.     Faculte  de  droit.) 

"La  clause  d'6galit6  de  traitement  entre  les  Strangers  et  les  nati- 
onaux":  pp.  131-150. 


34  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Pradier-Fodere,  Paul  Louis  Ernest.     Traite  de  droit  international 
public  europeen  &  americain,  suivant  les  progres  de  la 
science  et  de  la  pratique  contemporaines. 
Paris:  G.  Pedone-Lauriel,  1885-1906.     8  vols.     8°. 

La  "clause  de  la  nation  la  plus  favorisee"  :  vol.  4,  pp.  394-399; 
Clause  d'  "  etre  traite  comme  les  nationaux  eux-memes  " :  vol.  4, 
p.  399;  Clause  stipulant  "  Ip,  plus  exacte  reciprocite":  vol.  4, 
p.  399. 

Table  generale  analytique. 

Pans:  A.  Pedone,  1906.     (4),  198,  (2)  i^p.     8°. 

Rabbeno,  Ugo.  The  American  commercial  policy;  three  historical 
essays.  2d  ed.  partly  rewritten  and  entirely  revised  by 
the  author.  Tr.  at  the  Translations  bureau,  London, 
W.  C. 

London  and   New    YorJc:   Macmillan  and  co.,  1895.     xxiv, 
414  PP-     8°. 

Raunig,  A.  G.     Der  Zolltarif  und   die  Reciprocitats-Vertrage  der 
Vereinigten  Staaten  von  Amerika. 
Wien:  "  Industrieller  club,"  1901.     4^  pp-     8°. 

Ringwalt,  Ralph  Curtis,     Briefs  on  public  questions,  with  selected 
lists  of  references. 
New  York  [etc.]:  Longmans,  Green,  and  co.,  1905.     x,  (2), 
229  pp.     12°. 

"Commercial  reciprocity  ":  pp.  105-112;  "Reciprocity  with  Can- 
ada": pp.  113-120. 

Rogers,  James  E.  Thorold.  The  economic  interpretation  of  history. 
(Lectures  delivered    in  Worcester    college  hall,  Oxford, 

1887-88.) 
New  York:  G.P.Putnam's  sons,  1889.     xmi,{l),547  pp.    8°. 

Romero,  Matias.     Articulos  sobre  Mexico  publicados  en  los  Estados 
Unidos  de  America  en  1891-1892. 
Mexico:  OJicina    impresora    de    estampillas,    1892.     332,   xi 
pp.     8°. 

" Reciprocidad  y  represalias " :  pp.  216-217;  "Datos  estadisticos 
sobre  el  comercio  de  importacion  y  exportacion  entre  Mexico  y 
los  Estados  Unidos":  pp.  240-245. 

Geographical  and  statistical  notes  on  Mexico. 

New  York  and  London:  G.  P.  Putnam's  sons,  1898.     xiv, 
(2),  286  pp.     Map.     Plans.     8°. 

Also  printed  in  his  "Mexico  and  the  United  States." 


reciprocity:  general  works  35 

Romero,  Matias.     Mexico  and  the  United  States.     A  study  of  sub- 
jects affecting  their  poUtical,  commercial,  and  social  rela- 
tions, made  with  a  view  to  their  promotion.     Vol.  I. 
New  York  and  London:  G.  P.  Putnam's  sons,^  1898.     xxxv, 
{3)    759  fp.     Facsimile.     Map.     Plans.     8°. 

'  Forei<^n  trade  of  Mexico:  pp.  154-169;  Trade  between  Mexico  and 
the'united  States:  pp.  170-186;  247-248;  Reciprocity  treaties 
in  the  Pan-American  conference  of  1889 :  pp.  658-662. 

San  Francisco.  Chamber  of  commerce.  Franco-American 
commerce.  Statements  and  arguments  in  behalf  of 
American  industries  against  the  proposed  Franco-Amer- 
ican commercial  treaty;  submitted  to  the  special  commit- 
tee of  the  San  Francisco  Chamber  of  commerce,  m  con- 
formity with  the  resolutions  of  the  Chamber,  passed  June 
13th,  1879. 
San  Francisco:  Alia  California  booJc  and  job  pnnhng  house, 
1879.     220  pp.     8°. 

Schippel,    Max.     Amerika    und    die    Handelsvertragspolitik ;  eine 
politische  Studie. 
Berlin:  Verlag  der  Sozialistischen  Monatshefte,  G.  m.  b.  H., 
1906  {1905].     133  pp.     8°. 

Schraut,  Max  von.     System  der  Handelsvertrage  und  der  Meist- 
begiinstigung. 
Leipzig:  Dunclcer  d:  Humblot,  188/,.     x,  121,  (1)  pp.     8  . 

Schuyler,   Eugene.     American  diplomacy  and  the  furtherance  of 
commerce.  . 

New  Yorl:  Charles  Scribner's  sons,  1886.     xiv,  469  pp.     8  . 
Commercial  treaties :  pp.  421-457. 

Seabury    George  J.     The  ''constructive  and  reconstructive  forces 
that   are  essential  to   maintain  American  international 
commercial  supremacy"  and  that  -  universal  commercial 
reciprocity  treaties  and   tariff  revision  are  premature. 
[3d  ed.] 
New  YorJc,  [1902].     16  pp.     8°. 

Shaw,  Leslie  Mortier.     Reciprocity.  virions     i2M 

(In  his  Current  issues,  pp.  153-185.  New  \ork,  1908.  12  .) 
CoNTENTS.-Reciprocity  generally;  Our  trade  policy;  Canadian 
reciprocity;  Canadian  competing  products;  The  proposed  tariff 
agreement  with  Germany;  Letter  to  the  President;  Germany  8 
demand  for  a  new  commercial  agreement;  The  trade  agreement 
with  Germany. 


36  LIBKAEY    OF    CONGRESS 

Smith,  Richmond  Ma^'o-,  and  Edwin  R.  A.  Seligman.  The 
commercial  poUcy  of  the  United  States  of  America, 
1860-1890. 

{In  Verein  fiir  Socialpolitik.  Die  Handelspolitik  der  wichtigeren 
Kulturstaaten  in  den  letzten  Jahrzehnten,  Bd.  I,  pp.  1-74. 
Leipzig,  1892.     8°.     Schriften,  Bd.  49.) 

Treaties  of  reciprocity  and  indirect  regulations  of  commerce:  pp. 
34-57;  The  International  AmWican  conference:  pp.  58-74. 

Snow,  Freeman.     Treaties  and  topics  in  American  diplomacy. 

Boston:  The  Boston  hook  company,  1894-     vii,  (1),  515  pp. 
8°. 

Reciprocity  treaties  with  England,  1854:  p.  90;  1871:  p.  95;  with 
Hawaiian  Islands,  1875:  pp.  165,  169. 

Stevens,  Hazard.     Reciprocity.     Address  before  the  Reform  club, 
Boston,  Feb.  26,  1902. 
Boston,  1902.     10  pp.     8°. 

In  opposition  to  protection. 

Swank,  James  Moore.  Notes  and  comments  on  industrial,  economic, 
pohtical  and  historical  subjects.  ^ 

PhiladelpMa:  The  American  iron  cfe  steel  association,  1897. 
xi,  228  pp.     12°. 

"History  of  reciprocity  legislation":  pp.  195-201. 

Thompson,  R.  W.     The  history  of  protectiye  tariff  laws. 

Chicago:  B.  S.  Peale  and  company,  1888.     526  pp.     Portrait. 

8°.' 

Trumbull,  M.  M.     Earl  Grey  on  reciprocity  and  civil  service  reform; 
with  comments  by  Gen.  M.  M.  Trumbull. 
Chicago:  The  Open  court  publishing  co.,  1893.     (2),  27  pp. 
12°. 

Articles  reprinted  from  "Open  court"  of  Dec.  1892,  and  Jan.  1893. 

United  States.      Congress.     Extracts  from  the  Congressional  record 
1854-1904. 
Philadelphia:  Allied  printing  trades  council  [1904]-     [510]  pp. 
8°. 

Reciprocity:  pp.  bl-bll. 

Vosberg-Rekow,  Max.     Meistbegiinstigung. 

{In  Centralstelle  fiir  Vorbereitung  von  Handelsvertragen.  Schrif- 
ten,  15.  Hft.,  pp.  27-44.     Berlin,  1901.     8°.) 

Die    PoUtik    der    Handelsvertrage    in    ihren    Grundziigen 

gemeinfasslich  dargestellt. 
Berlin:  Siemenroth  &  Troschel,  1898.     viii,  189  pp.     Folded 
tables.     8°.     (Schriften  der   Centralstelle  fiir  Vorbereitung 
von  Handelsvertragen.     3.  Hft.) 

"Die  Meistbegiinstigung":  pp.  128-141. 


reciprocity:  general  works  37 

Vosberg-Rekow,  Max.  Die  Zolltarifvorlage  unci  iliie  Begiiinduni^. 
111!  Auftrage  tier  Centralstelle  ftir  Vorbereitung  von 
Ilandelsvertragen. 
Berlin:  J.  Guttentag,  1902.  vii,  (2),  62  jip.  8°.  {Schriffen 
der  Centralstelle  fiir  Vorbereitung  von  Handelsvertrdgen. 
18.  Hft.) 

"Front  gegen  die  Meistbegiinstigung " :  pp.  29-30. 

Webster,  Daniel.     Sound  dues  at  Elsinore,  and  the  German  ZoU- 
Verein.     [Letter  to  the  President,  May  24,  1841.] 
{In  his  Works,  vol.  6,  pp.  406-414.     Boston,  1866.     8°.) 


[Letter  to  Mr.  Everett,  November  25,  1842.] 

{In  Curtis,  George  Ticknor.     Life  of  Daniel  Webster,  vol.  2,  pp. 

173-175.     New  York,  1870.     8°.) 
Commercial  treaties:  p.  174. 

Wharton,  Francis.     A  digest  of  the  international  law  of  the  United 
States.     [2d  ed.] 
Washington:  Government  jirinting  office,  1887.     3  vols.     8°. 

Reciprocity  with  Sandwich  Islands:  sec.  62;  Treaty  regulations  of 
reciprocity  between  Great  Britain  and  the  United  States:  sec- 
302;  Favored  nation:  sec.  134. 

Whitman,  Wihiam.     Objections  to  reciprocity  on  constitutional  and 
practical  grounds. 
Boston:  The  Rockwell  and  Churchill  press,  190 Jf^.     35  jrp.     8°. 

Wilson,  James  H.     Trade  with  the  tropics.     An  address  before  the 
American  free  trade  league,  Nov.  9,  1901. 
[Boston:  American  free  trade  league,  1901].     23  pp.     8°. 

Wise,  Bernard  R.     Industrial  freedom:  a  study  in  politics. 

London:  Cassell  c&  company,  1892.     xxxi,  (1),  372  pp.     12°. 

Wolf,  Julius.     Der  deutsch-amerikanische  Handelsvertrag;  die  ku- 
banische  Zuckerproduktion  und  die  Zukunft  der  Zucker- 
industrie  mit  zahlreichen  statistischen  Tabellen  und  Ex- 
kursen. 
Jena:  G.  Fischer,  1906.     vii,  158  pp.     8°. 

Woolsey,  T.  S.     America's  foreign  policy.     Essays  and  addresses. 
New  York:  The  Century  co.,  1898.     x,  U),  294  pp-     12°. 

Pages  195-209  contain  article  on  "The  fishery  question,"  in  which 
are  discussed  the  effects  of  reciprocity  treaties  upon  fisheries. 


ARTICLES   IN    PERIODICALS 

1844.     Commercial  reciprocity.     C.  C.  Haven. 

Hunt's  merchants'  magazine,  vol.  10  (Apr.,  1844)-  354-359. 

1844.     Commercial  reciprocity  and  the  American  system. 
Democratic  review,  vol.  I4  {May,  1844):  44^^-46 4- 

1844.  Germany,  and  the  commercial  treaty  of  Berlin.     I.  L.  K. 

Hunt's  merchants'  magazine,  vol.  11   {Dec,  1844):  4^1-501. 

1845.  Reciprocity  treaties  and  commercial  intercourse  with  British 

colonies. 
Hunfs  merchants'  magazine,  vol.  12  {Mar.,  1845):  262-266. 

1846.  Commercial  treaties  based  on  reciprocity,  with  reference  to 

the    advantages    of    a    commercial    treaty    between    the 
United  States  and  the  German  ZoUverein. 
Hunt's  merchants'  magazine,  vol.  I4  {Jan.,  I846):  51-56. 

1847.  The  commercial  treaties  of  the  United  States:  with  reference 

to  the  progress  of  commercial  freedom. 
Hunt's  merchants'  magazine,  vol.  17  {Oct.,  1847):  339-357. 

1853.     Reciprocal  treaties  of  commerce. 

De  Bow's  review,  vol.  I4  {June,  1853):  525-535. 

1885.  The  reciprocity  treaties.     Speech  by  Senator  [J.  S.]  Morrill, 

Jan.  7,  1885. 
The  American,  vol.  9  {Jan.  10,  1885):  219-221. 

1886.  The   treaty-making  power  under  the  Constitution.     Simon 

Greenleaf  Croswell. 
American  law  review,  vol.  20   {new  series,   vol.   7),    {July- 
August,  1886):  513-527. 

Upholds  the  validity  of  commercial  treaties. 

1890.     Reciprocity  and  ship  building. 

American  law  review,  vol.  24  {May-June,  1890):  472-474- 

1890.     Reciprocity  with  Spanish  America. 

Public  opinion,  vol  9  {June  28,  1890)<  263-266. 
38 


reciprocity:  periodicals  39 

1893.     La  clause  de  la  nation  la  plus  favorisee  et  la  persistance  de 
ses  efTets.     Ernest  Lehr. 
Revue  de  droit  international  et  de  legislation  comparee,  vol. 
25  {1893):  313-316. 

1896.  Les  societes  etrangeres  et  la  clause  de  la  nation  la  plus  favor- 

isee.    P.  Huvelin. 
Annales  de  droit  commercial,  vol.  10  {Feb.  1S96):  51-53. 

1897.  Keciprocity:  is  it  elusive?     D.  O.  Kellogg. 

Self  culture,  vol.  6  {Dec,  1897):  226-230. 

1898.  The  author  of  reciprocity.     A.  D.  Anderson. 

Intematiomil  bureau  of  the  American  rejmblics.     Monthly 
buUetin,  vol.  5  {Jan.,  1898):  1074-1076. 

1898.  The  development  of  the  poHcy  of  reciprocity.     Jolin  Ball 

Osborne. 
Forum,  vol.  25  {Aug.,  1898):  683-692. 

1899.  Die  Tragweite  der  Meistbegiinstigungsklausel.     Dr.  Fuld. 

Zeitschrift  fur  internationales  Privat-  und  Sfrafrecht,  vol.  9 
{1899):  361-369. 

1899.     Reciprocity  treaty  with  Barbados. 

International   bureau   of  the   American   republics.      Montfity 
bulletin,  vol.  7  {July,  1899):  51-52. 

1899.     Reciprocity  treaty  with  Jamaica. 

International   bureau   of  the   American  republics.     Monthly 
buUetin,  vol.  7  {July,  1899):  53. 

1899      Trade  poHcy  with  the  colonies.     Worthington  C.  Ford. 
Harper's  magazine,  vol.  99  {July,  1899):  293-303. 

1899.     Reciprocity  with  France. 

Puhlic  opinion,  vol.  27  {Aug.  3,  1899):  131-132. 

1899.     Reciprocity  with  the  Argentine  Republic. 

International  bureau  of  the  American  republics.     Monthly 
buUetin,  vol.  7  {Nov.,  1899):  866-867. 

1899.  The  commercial  relations  of  the  United  States  and  Germany. 

James  Howard  Gore. 
Forum,  vol.  28  {Dec,  1899):  ^93-502. 

1900.  Reciprocity  treatv  between  the  United  States  and  France. 

Nation,  vol.  70  {Mar.  29,  1900):  233-234- 


40  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1900.     The  Republican  pledge  on  reciprocity.     D.  W.  D. 
Protectionist,  vol  11  {Mar.,  1900):  643-646. 

1900.     How  to  secure  trade  with  the  South  American  countries. 
J.  H.  Franz. 

Scientific  American,  vol.  82  {June  23,  1900):  390. 

1900.     The  reciprocity  treaty  with  Germany. 

Puhlic  opinion,  vol.  29  {July  26,  1900):  IO4. 
Press  comment. 

1900.     Das  Ende  der  Meistbegtinstigung  ?     Otto,  freiherr  von  Boe- 
nigk. 
Die  Gegenwart,  vol.  58  {Oct.  13,  1900):  225-226. 

1900.     The  work  of  the  reciprocity  commission.     John  Ball  Osborne. 
Forum,  vol.  30  {Dec,  1900):  394-411. 

1900.  The  reciprocity  treaties  and  the  Senate.     John  W.  Foster. 

Independent,  vol.  52  {Dec.  6,  1900):  2897-2899. 

1901.  The  President's  treaties  of  reciprocity. 

Independent,  vol.  53  {Feb.  28,  1901):  509-510. 

1901.     Reciprocity  and  protection.      (From   the  Washington  post, 
Iron  and  steel  bulletin,  etc.) 
Protectionist,  vol.  12  {Feh.,  1901):  472-476. 

1901.     Protection  and  reciprocity.     Commissioner  [John  A.]  Kasson's 
reply  to  resolutions  of  Home  market  club  and  the  Club 
committee's  rejoinder. 
Protectionist,  vol.  12  {Mar.,  1901):  517-530. 

1901.     Reciprocity  and  economics.     John  P.  Young. 

American    economist,    vol.    27    {Apr.    19,    1901):  181-183: 
{Apr.  26,  1901):  193-195. 

1901.     McKinley's  new  departure  [reciprocity]. 
Nation,  vol.  72  {May  9,  1901):  368. 

1901.     Economic  aspects  of  reciprocity.     John  P.  Young, 
Protectionist,  vol.  13  {June,  1901):  80-91. 

Printed  also  in  American  economist,  vol.  27,  May  3-10,  1901,  pp. 
205-207,  217-219. 

1901.     Reciprocity  and  free  trade.      (From  the  Boston  Commercial 
bulletin.) 
Protectionist,  vol.  13  {June,  1901):  109-111. 

1901.     Reciprocity  or  the  alternative.     Brooks  Adams. 
Atlantic  montldy,  vol.  88  {Aug.,  1901):  145-155. 


reciprocity:  periodicals  41 

1901.     Reciprocity  or  war.     H.  Wliite. 

Nation,  iol.  73  {Aug.  15,  1901):  125-126. 

1901.     A  business  man's  view  of  reciprocity.     George  A.  Draper. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Aug.,  1901):  190-191. 

1901.     Senator  Lodge  and  reciprocity. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Aug.,  1901):  198. 

1901.     The  President  on  reciprocity. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Aug.,  1901):  20^-205. 

1901.     Reciprocity.     J.  De  Normandie. 

Nation,  \^ol.  73  {Oct.  2^,  1901):  320. 

1901.     Beet  sugar's  protest  against  reciprocity.     H.  T.  Oxnard. 

American  economist,  vol.  28  {Nov.  29,  1901):  263-264- 

1901.     Reciprocity  or  mutuality?     IT.  W.  Taylor. 
Nation,  iol.  73  {Nov.  14,  1901):  376. 

1901.     Reciprocity. 

Outlool,  vol.  69  {Nov.  30,  1901):  808-810. 

1901.     Former    reciprocity  treaties. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Nov.,  1901):  375-378. 

1901.     The  reciprocity  question.     Some  interesting  and  pertinent 
views  from  protection  journals. 
Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Nov.,  1901):  397-401. 

1901.     Expansion  through  reciprocity.     John  Ball  Osborne. 
Atlantic  monthly,  vol.  88  {Dec,  1901):  721-731. 

1901.     A  calm  view  of  reciprocity.     George  B.  Waldron. 
Chautauquan,  vol.  34  {Dec,  1901):  237-242. 

1901.     Reciprocity  and  foreign  trade.     E.J.Gibson. 
Forum,  vol.  32  {Dec,  1901):  466-48O. 

1901.     Reciprocity  agitation. 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  21  {Dec,  1901):  497-504. 
Opposed  to  reciprocity. 

1901.     The  questions  of  reciprocity.     William  P.  Wilson. 
Independent,  vol.  53  {Dec  5,  1901):  2872-287 U. 

1901.     Our  industrial  foreign  policy.     George  Gunton. 

Institute  of  social  economics.     Lecture  bulletin  {Dec  2,  1901): 
131-151. 

Opposed  to  reciprocity. 


42  LIBEARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1901.     The  demand  for  reciprocity.     John  A.  Kasson. 

National  magazine,  Boston,  vol.  15  {Dec,  1901):  353. 

1901.     McKinley  reciprocity.     J.  R.  Dodge. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Dec,  1901):  439-U^. 

1901.     The  National  reciprocity  convention.     Notable  gathering  of 
manufacturers  in  Washington. 
Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Dec,  1901):  464-475. 

1901.     The  vital  economic  problem.     C.  L.  Lorraine. 
Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Dec,  1901):  479-484. 

A  discussion  of  the  tariff  and  reciprocity. 

1901.  The  most  favoured  nation  article.     Wallwyn  P.  B.  Shep- 

heard. 
Societij   of  comparative   legislation.     Journal,   vol.   3    {D^c, 
1901):  231-237. 

1902.  La  clause  de  "la  nation  la  plus  favorisee"  dans  les  traites  de 

commerce.     L.  E.  Visser. 
Revue  de  droit  international  et  de  legislation  comparee,  2^  ser., 

t.4  {1902):  66-87;  159-177;  270-280. 

1903.  Work  of  the  Reciprocity  convention. 

Chautanquan,  vol.  34  {Jan.,  1902):  257-258. 

1902.     The  Rake's  progress  in  tariff  legislation.     J.  Schoenhof. 
Forum,  vol.  32  {Jan.,  1902):  608-622. 

A  criticism  of  the  Dingley  tariff  act  and  the  reciprocity  treaties 
arranged  under  it. 

1902.     Les     Etats-Unis     et     la     reciprocite     commerciale.     Achille 
Viallate. 
Journal  des  economistes,  5.  ser.,  vol.  49  {Jan.  15, 1902) :  47-61 . 
A  review  of  the  history  of  reciprocity  since  1803. 

1902.     The  practical  side  of  reciprocity.     Albert  Clarke. 
Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Jan.,  1902):  525-529. 

1902.     Le  traitement  de  la  nation  la  plus  favorisee.     D.  Aubry. 
La  Reforme  economique,  vol.  11  {Feh.  9,  1902):  204-206. 

1902.     The  manufacturer's  need  of  reciprocity.     A.  B.  Farquhar. 

American  academy  of  political  and  social  science.     Annals, 
vol.  19  {Mar.,  1902):  185-203. 

1902.     If  reciprocity  is  the  game,  more  than  one  industry  must  take 
a  hand.     A.  J.  D. 
American  economist,  vol.  29  {Mar.  21,  1902):  134-135. 


RECIPROCITY  :   PERIODICALS  43 

1902.     The  earlier  commercial  policy  of  the  United  States.     Thomas 
Walker  Page. 
Journal  of  political  economy,  vol.  10  {Mar.,  1902):  161-192. 

1902.     Reciprocity  a  questionable  experiment. 
Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Mar.,  1902):  637. 

From  an  address  on   "Commercial  expansion,"  by  Charles  A. 
Gardiner. 

1902.     Blaine  reciprocity. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Mar.,  1902):  645-648. 

1902.     Andrew  Carnegie  on  reciprocity. 

American  economist,  vol.  29  {May  2,  1902):  208-209. 

1902.     Orthodox  Republican  reciprocity.     F.  W.  Cushman. 

American  economist,  vol.  29  {May  9,  1902):  218-219,  22^- 


1902.     Meistbegiinstigung  und  nordamerikanische  Konkurrenz.    Paul 
Arndt. 
Die  Nation,  vol.  19  {May  24,  1902):  534-536. 

1902.     Our  growing  dependence  upon  the  tropics.     O.  P.  Austin. 

Forum,  vol.  33  {June,  1902):  4OO-4O8. 

1902.     What  is  Republican  reciprocity? 

Protectionist,  vol.  I4  {June,  1902):  76-80. 

1902.     Concurrence  americaine.     Henri  Rhein. 

La  Re  forme  econoynique,  vol.  11  {June  15,  1902):  884-885. 

1902.     "The  three  R's":  retahation,  revision  or  reciprocity — which? 
Charles  P.  Harris. 
Protectionist,  vol.  I4  {July,  1902):  126-129. 

1902.     Reciprocity  and  nebulosity.     [Editorial.] 

Protectionist,  vol.  I4  {July,  1902):  130-132. 

1902.     Reciprocity.     Edwin  Maxey. 

Anglo  American,  vol.  8  {Aug.,  1902):  59-62. 

1902.     The  W^est  and  reciprocity. 

Protectionist,  vol.  I4  {Aug.,  1902):  196-198. 

1902.     President  McKinley's  last  public  address  delivered  at  Buffalo, 
Sept.  5th,  1901. 
National  reciprocity ,  vol.  1  [Sept.,  1902):  4-IO. 

Reprinted  in  National  reciprocity  for  June,  1903,  pp.  16-19. 


44  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1902.     History  of  reciprocity.     William  E.  Curtis. 
National  reciprocity,  vol.  1  {Sept.,  1902) 

1902.     Die  Zukunft  der  Meistbegiinstigung.     Georg  Gothein. 

Die  Nation,  vol.  20  {Oct.  11,  1902):  18-21. 

1902.     Foreign  commerce.     James  Deefing. 

National  reciprocity ,  vol.  1  {Nov.,  1902):  4-13. 

1902.     Reciprocity  treaties  and  tariff  revision.     [From  the  speech  of 
Henry  Cabot  Lodge.] 
Protectionist,  vol.  I4  {Nov.,  1902):  SU-SdO. 

1902.     Protection  a  national  doctrine. 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  23  (Dec,  1902):  465-475. 

"Reciprocity  is  only  another  name  for  a  scheme  to  dicker  away 
the  American  market  by  special  bargain  instead  of  by  general 
policy." 

1902.  [Reciprocity].     A.  B.  Cummins. 

National  reciprocity,  vol.  1  {Dec,  1902):  13-30. 

1903.  Reciprocity"  in  and  out  of  Congress. 

Chautauquan,  vol.  36  {Feb.,  1903):  454-456. 

1903.     Protection,  not  reciprocity. 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  24  {Feh.,  1903):  II4-II8. 

1903.     Most  favored  nation  clause  in  treaties.     G.  G.  Phillimore. 
Law  magazine  and  review,  vol.  28  {Feb.,  1903):  208-213. 

1903.     Judge  Nathaniel  French's  speech  at  Washington,  D.  C,  Jan- 
uary 15,  1903.     [Reciprocity.] 
National  reciprocity ,  vol.  1  {Feh.,  1903):  3-8. 

1903.     The  famous  reciprocity  speech  of  Senator  Dolhver  of  Iowa, 
dehvered  in  the  United  States  Senate,  January  13,  1903. 
National  reciprocity,  vol.  1  {Feh.,  1903):  9-13. 

Reprinted  in  National  reciprocity  for  June,  1903,  pp.  20-23. 

1903.     A  letter  from  Germany.     Wilham  C.  Dreher. 

Atlantic  montJily,  vol.  91  {Mar.,  1903):  388-398. 

On  reciprocity  and  the  commercial  relations  between  Germany 
and  the  United  States. 

1903.     German- American  ''most  favored  nation"  relations.     George 
M.  Fisk. 
Journal  of  political  economy,  vol.  11  {Mar.,  1903):  220-236. 


RECIPROCITY  :   PERIODICALS 


45 


1903.  Le  mouvement  ^conomique  et  social  aux  Etats-Unis.  La 
reciprocite  commerciale  et  le  protectionnisme  devant 
I'opinion.     Pierre  Leroy-Beaulieu. 

L' Economiste  frangais,  31'  annee,  vol.    1    {Apr.    4,  1903): 
463-405. 

1903.     McKinley's    principles.     Was    the    late    President    a    tariff 
reformer   by  the  competitive  reciprocity  route?     J.  W. 
Allfree. 
American  economist,  vol  31  (May  1,  1903):  214-215. 

1903.     The  results  of  reciprocity  with  Brazil.     Lincoln  Hutchinson. 
Political  science  quarterly,  vol.  18  {June,  1903):  2S2-312. 

1903      Tariff  revision  and  reciprocity.     John  F.  Lacey. 
Protectionist,  vol.  15  {July,  1903):  803-806. 

1903.     Die  Meistbegunstigungsvertrage. 

Export,  vol.  25  {Aug.  13,  1903):  4^1-4^2. 
1903.     The  most-favoured-nation  article.     WallwynP.  B.  Shepheard. 

Society  of  comparative   legislation.     Journal,  vol.   5   {Aug., 
1903):  132-136. 

1903.     Genuine  reciprocity.     Lucius  F.  C.  Garvm. 

Independent,  vol  55  {Nov.  19,  1903):  2750-2753. 

1903.  The  relation  of  reciprocity  to  protection.     Edwin  Maxey. 

Arena,  vol  30  {Dec,  1903):  585-590. 

1904.  The  origin  and  history  of  the  Iowa  idea.     George  E.  Roberts. 

Iowa  journal  of  history  and  politics,  vol.  2  {Jan.,  1904):  69-82. 
"A  contemporary  statement  of  the  origin,  meaning,  and  history  of 
the  proposal  for  tariff  revision  [and  reciprocity]  which  has  come 
to  be  known  as  the  '  Iowa  idea.' '" 

1904.     RepubUcan  reciprocity. 

Protectionist,  vol  15  {Jan.,  1904):  1165-1170. 

1904      Competitive  reciprocitv  always  bad  for  the  United  States. 
Protectionist,  vol  15  {Jan.,  1904):  1203-1204- 

1904.     Principles  of  reciprocitv.     Albert  Clarke. 

Protectionist,  vol  15  {Feb.,  1904):  1241-1243. 

1904.     Republican  reciprocity  defined.     From  the  speech  of  Hon. 
John  Dalzell,  of  Pennsylvania,  in  the  House  of  representa- 
tives, Feb.  29,  1904. 
American  economist,  vol  33  {Mar.  11,  1904):  121,  128-132. 
Reprinted  from  Congressional  record,  58th  Congress,  2d  session, 
vol.  38,  part  3,  pp.  256.5-2571. 
27306°— 10 4 


46  LIBRAEY   OF    CONGRESS 

1904.     American  commercial  union.     Wliarton  Barker. 

North  American  review,  vol.  178  {Mar.  1904):  338-347. 

1904.     Commercial  reciprocity;  from  speech  of  George  J.  Seabury, 
American  economist,  vol.  33  {Ajjr.  8,  1904):  178-179. 

1904.     Reciprocity:  enlarging  the  homQ  market.     Henr}'  Fairbanks. 
Protectionist,  vol.  15  {Apr.,  1904):  1354-1356. 

1904.     The  reciprocity  question  in  Congress:  extracts  from  speeches. 
John  F.  Lacey,  A.  J.  Volstead  and  John  Dalzell. 
Protectionist,  vol.  15  {Apr.,  1904):  1367-1374- 

1904.     It  [reciprocity]  has  never  worked  well.     John  S.  Bird. 
American  economist,  vol.  34  {July  15,  1904):  32-33. 

1904.     The  political  significance  of  reciprocity.     W.  Jett  Lauck. 

Journal  of  political  economy,  vol.  12  {Sept.,  1904):  495-524. 

1904.  Tariff  and  reciprocity.     W.  L.  Douglas. 

Independent,  vol.  57  {Dec.  22,  1904):  1416-1417 

1905.  Kiindigung  der  Meistbegiinstigungsvertrage.     Georg  Gothein. 

Die  Nation,  vol.  22  {Feh.  18,  1905):  323-324. 

1905.     The  international  aspect  of  our  tariff  situation.     N.  I.  Stone. 
North  American  review,  vol.  180  {Mar.,  1905):  381-393. 

1905.     Les  traites  de  reciprocite.     Jules  Domergue. 

La  Reforme  economique,  vol.  14  {July  9,  1905):  955-957. 

1905.     Two    significant    speeches.     Senator   Cullom    and    Governor 
Cummins  at    the  Chicago    reciprocity  conference    [Aug. 
16-17,  1905]. 
American  economist,  vol.  36  {Aug.  25,  1905):  92-95. 

1905.     Reciprocity  [convention]  at  Chicago. 

^tion,  vol.  81  {Aug.  24,  1905):  156-157. 

1905.     The  Chicago  reciprocity  conference  and  our  trade  with  Ger- 
many.    Albert  Clarke. 
Protectionist,  vol.  17  {Aug.,  1905):  161-177. 

1905.     The  Chicago  "reciprocity  conference." 

Protectionist,  vol.  17  {Sept.,  1905):  219-230. 

1905.     The  promise  and  problems  of  reciprocity.     Harold  Bolce. 

Appletons  hoohlovers  magazine,  vol.  6  {Oct.,  1905):  512-520. 


keciprocity:  periodicals  47 

1905.     Die  Meistbeo;iinsti<j!;un<2;  unci  iinser  haiulelspolitisches  Verhtilt- 
iiis  zur  Nord-amerikanischen  Union.     Graf  von  Schwerin 
Lowitz. 
Deutsche  Monatsclirift,  vol.  9  (Oct.,  1905):  17-40. 

1905.  The  new  German  tariff.  It  is  not  reciprocity,  but  retaliation. 
Analysis  of  the  foreign  commerce  of  the  United  States. 
Germany  buys  of  us  mostly  raw  materials  and  but  little 
of  the  product  of  American  skilled  labor.  L.  Wliite 
Busbey. 
American  economist,  vol.  36  (Nov.  3,  1905):  205,  212-215. 

1905.  As  to  our  foreign  trade.  Dissection  of  motives  by  a  com- 
mercial expert  and  political  economist.  A  scientific 
analysis  of  reciprocity  treaties  and  tariff  revision  and  the 
causes  underlying  the  present  movement.  George  J. 
Seabury. 
American  economist,  vol.  36  (Nov.  24,  1905):  249-251. 

1905.  The   alternative  of  reciprocity   treaties  or   a  double   tariff. 

John  Ball  Osborne. 
North  American  review,  vol.  181  (Nov.,  1905):  731-744- 

1906.  Der   deutsch-amerikanische   Handelsvertrag   und   die  Meist- 

begiinstigung. 
Exx>ort,  vol.  28  (Mar.  8,  1906):  171-172. 

1906.     The  reciprocity  movement  in   1905  and  its  present  status. 
J.  B.  McPherson. 
National  association  of  wool  manufacturers.     Bulletin,  vol.  36 
(Mar.,  1906):  1-20. 

1906.     Most-favored-nation    relations    between    Germany    and    the 
United  States.     N.  I.  Stone. 
North  American  review,  vol.  182  (Mar.,  1906):  433-445. 

1906.     Meistbegiinstigung  und  Reziprozitat  in  der  Handelsvertrags- 
politik.     Max  Schippel. 

Socialistische  Monatshefte,  vol.  12  (May,  1906):  360-367. 

1906.  Revision   and  reciprocity.     A  permanent   tariff  commission 

advocated  as  the  true  solution  of  these  questions.    George 
J.  Seabury. 
American  economist,  vol.  38  (Sept.  14,  1906):  128-129. 

1907.  Speaker  Cannon  on  reciprocity  and  a  dual  tariff.     Remarks 

of  Hon.  J.  G.  Cannon  on  the  occasion  of  the  visit  of  the 
delegates  to  the  C^onvention  to  promote  the  foreign  com- 
merce of  the  United  States,  Jan.  16,  1907. 
American  economist,  vol.  39  (Jan.  25,  1907):  37-S9. 


48  LIBRAEY   OF    CONGRESS 

1907.     The  Root  idea   of  reciprocity.     What  was  the  Secretary  of 
state   driving   at   in   his   commerce   convention   speech? 
Arthur  J.  Dodge. 
American  economist,  vol.  39  {Jan.  25,  1907):  47-^8. 

1907.     Inexpensive  reciprocity.     John  Bates  Clark. 

Forum,  vol.  38  {J an.- Mar.,  1907):  413-423. 

1907.     Reciprocity  with  Germany.     H.  Parker  WilHs. 

J ournal  of  political  economy,  vol.  15  {June,  1907):  321-344^' 
{July,  1907):  385-397. 

1907.     Does   the   country  want   tariff  readjustment?     Wilham   R. 
Corwine. 
American  monthly  review  of  reviews,  vol.  36  {July,  1907): 
47-50. 

1907.  German  reciprocity.  Basis  of  the  secret  negotiations  dis- 
closed, involving  a  20  per  cent,  reduction  of  Dingley  tariff 
rates.     H.  P.  R. 

American  economist,  vol.  40  {Nov.  8,  1907):  217-219,  225. 

1907.  Reciprocity  complications.  To  be  "more  liberal"  with 
France  interferes  with  benefits  granted  to  Germany. 
Arthur  J.  Dodge. 

American  economist,  vol.  40  {Nov.  29,  1907):  254-255. 

1907.     Effect    of    "Most-favoured-nation"    clause    in    commercial 
treaties.     Sir  Thomas  Barclay. 
Yale  law  journal,  vol.  17  {Nov.,  1907):  26-32. 

1907.  The  German  reciprocity  agreement. 

Journal  of  political  economy ,  vol.  15  {Dec,  1907):  628-631. 

1908.  Important  tariff  hearing...     Remarks  of  Speaker  Cannon  and 

Chairman  Payne  on  the  subject  of  revision,  reciprocity 
and  a  tariff  commission. 
American  economist,  vol.  41  {Feh.  14,  1908):  73-75,  80-82. 

1908.     Sugar:  a  lesson  on  reciprocity  and  the  tarifl'.     F.  W.  Taussig. 
Atlantic  monthly,  vol.  101  {Mar.,  1908):  334-344. 

1908.     [Reciprocity  with  Germany  and  France.] 

Journal  of  political  economy,  vol.  16  {Mar.,  1908):  164-166. 

1908.     Zur  Frage  der  Meistbegiinstigung.     Franz  Stibral. 

Osterreichische  Rundschau,  vol.  15  {Apr.  15,  1908):  79-80. 


reciprocity:  periodicals  49 

1908.  Meistbegimstifj;iingsrecht  und  -Vcrtraf^e. 

Export,  vol.  30  {Oct.  22,  190S):  637-638. 

1909.  Concerning  the  interpretation  of  treaties.     Charles  Cheney 

Hyde. 

American  journal  of  international  law,  vol.  3  {Jan.,   1909): 
46-61. 

' '  The  most-favored-nation  clause  " :  pp.  57-61. 

1909.     The  most-favored-nation  chiuse.     Stanley  K.  Hornbeck. 

American  journal  of  international  law,  vol.  3  (Apr.,   1909): 
395-422;  {July,  1909):  619-647;  {Oct.,  1909):  797-827. 

1909.  Pour  nous  defendre  contre  les  fitats-Unis.     C.  Clawy. 

La  Reforme  economique,  vol.  18  {June  18,  1909):  745-747. 

1910.  La  pohtica  doganale  degli  Stati  Uniti  e  I'atteggiamento  delP 

Europa.     Antonio  Ravaioli. 
ISluova  antologia,  vol.  232  {July  16,  1910):  276-290. 


RECIPROCITY  WITH   CANADA  AND   NEWFOUNDLAND 

UNITED  STATES   DOCUMENTS 

1849-1853.     Debate  on  Canadian  reciprocity. 

Congressional  glohe,  30th  Congress,  2d  session  {Jan.  8,  1849): 
182-186;  {Jan.  23,  1849):  327-332;  31st  Congress,  1st  ses- 
sion {May  21,  1850):  1009-1011;  32d  Congress,  2d  session 
{Feb.  23,  1853):  803-804;  {Mar.  1,  1853):  953-958;  32d 
Congress,  2d  session  {Appendix)  {Feb.  16,  1853):  197-199; 
{Feb.  24,  1853):  210-212;  {Feb.  17,  1853):  229-231. 

1850.  Reciprocal  trade  with  Canada.     Message  from  the  President 

relative  to  the  reciprocal  admission  of  the  natural  products 
of  the  United  States  and  Canada  free  of  duty.     May  16, 

1850.  37  pp.     8°. 

31st  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  64.  577 

"Copies  of   a  correspondence  between  the  Department  of  state 

and  the  British  legation  in  this  city,  relative  to  the  reciprocal 

admission  of  the  natural  products  of  the  United  States  and 

Canada,  free  of  duty,  into  the  territories  of  both  countries." 

1851.  Report  of  the  Secretary  of  the  Treasury,  in  relation  to  the 

trade  and  commerce  of  the  British  American  colonies  with 
the  United  States  and  other  countries  since  1829.     Feb.  6, 

1851.  775,  (1)  pp.     8°. 

31st  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  23.  590 

Pages  3-51  contain  report  by  I.  D.  Andrews. 

1851.  Commercial  intercourse  between  the  United  States  and  the 

British  North  American  provinces.     [Correspondence  be- 
tween the  Department  of  state  and  the  British  legation, 
March,  1851,  to  June  24,  1851.] 
S2d  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  1.  611 

(In  Message  from  the  President,  Dec.  2,  1851,  pp.  83-92.) 
Same.     32d  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  2. 

1852.  Report  of  Israel  D.  Andrews,  on  the  trade  and  commerce  of 

the  British   North  American  colonies.     Aug.   25,    1852. 
xix,  (1),  906,  (1)  pp.     8°. 
32d  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  112.  622 

Also  printed  a.^  House  ex.  doc.  no.  136,  32d  Congress,  1st  session 
(serial  no.  651). 

51 


52  LIBRARY   OF    CONGRESS 

1853.  [Report  by  the  Secretary  of  state,  Edward  Everett],  relative 
to  the  negotiations  pending  between  the  United  States 
and  Great  Britain,  on  the  subject  of  the  fisheries,  of  recip- 
rocal intercourse  \\ith  the  British  North  American  prov- 
inces, [etc.].  Feb.  8,  1853.  3  pp.  8°. 
32d  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  34-  660 

Also  printed  as  House  ex.  doc.  no.  40,  32d  Congress,  2d  session 
(serial  no.  677). 

1853.     Report  [of]  the  Committee  on  commerce,  relative  to  reciprocal 

trade  with  the  British  North  American  colonies.     Feb.  11, 

1853.     92  pp.     8°. 

32d  Congress,  2d  session.     House  rejJort  no.  4-  687 

Reviews  the  history  of  negotiations  in  regard  to  reciprocal  trade 

from  1815  to  1852. 

1853.  Report  from  the  Secretary  of  state,  in  relation  to  the  fisheries 

on  the  coasts  of  the  British  North  American  provinces. 
Feb.  28,  1853.     21  pp.     8°. 
33d  Congress,  special  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  3.  688 

1854.  United  States.      Treasury  deft.     Communication  from  the 

Secretary  of  the  Treasury  transmitting  .  .  .  the  report  of 
Israel  D.  Andrews  ...  on  the  trade  and  commerce  of  the 
British  North  American  colonies,  and  upon  the  trade  of 
the  great  lakes  and  rivers;  also,  notices  of  the  internal 
improvements  in  each  state,  of  the  Gulf  of  Mexico  and 
straits  of  Florida,  and  a  paper  on  the  cotton  crop  of  the 
United  States. 
Washington:  B.  TucJcer,  1854.  viii,  851  pp.  and  atlas  of  4 
fold.  maps.     8°. 

Reprint  of  Senate  ex.  doc.  112  and  House  ex.  doc.  136,  32d  Con- 
gress, 1st  session. 

1854.  [Report  by  Mr.  Mason  from]  the  Committee  on  foreign  rela- 
tions, to  whom  was  referred  the  treaty  exter^ling  the  right 
of  fishing,  and  regulating  the  commerce  and  navigation 
between  Her  Britannic  Majesty's  possessions  in  North 
America  and  the  United  States,  concluded  in  the  city  of 
Washington  on  the  5th  day  of  June,  1854,  between  the 
United  States  of  America  and  Her  Majesty  the  Queen  of 
the  United  Kingdom  of  Great  Britain  and  Ireland.  July 
11,  1854. 
S3d  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate.  4054 

(In  U.  S.  Senate.  Compilation  of  reports  of  the  Committee  on 
foreign  relations,  a'oI.  8,  pp.  68-106.  Washington,  1901.  8°. 
56th  Congress,  2d  session.    Senate  document  no.  231,  part  8.) 


KECIPROCITY   WITH    CANADA:   U.    S.   DOCUMENTS  53 

1859.  Memorial  of  the  Board  of  trade  of  Portland,  Maine,  praying 
that  the  provisions  of  the  treaty  of  1854  between  the 
United  States  and  Great  Britain,  known  as  the  reciprocity 
treaty,  be  extended  so  as  to  include  the  products  of  the 
workshop  and  the  manufactory,  and  relieve  the  present 
trade  of  all  onerous  and  unjust  taxations.  Feb.  14,  1859. 
3  pp.  8°. 
35th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  misc.  doc.  no.  44.  993 

1859.  Letter  from  the  Secretary  of  the  Treasury,  transmitting  sta- 

tistics of  the  trade  under  the  reciprocity  treaty  with  Great 
Britain.     Feb.  15,  1859.     8  pp.     8°. 
35tli  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  98.  1008 

1860.  Reciprocity  treaty.     Reports  of  Messrs.  Hatch  &  Taylor,  in 

reference   to   the   operations   of   the   reciprocity   treaty. 
June  18,  1860.     60  pp.     8°. 
36th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  96.  1057 

Reports  by  Israel  T.  Hatch  and  James  W.  Taylor,  reviewing  the 
effects  of  the  reciprocity  treaty  of  1854. 

1862.     Report  of  the  Committee  on  commerce,  in  relation  to  the 

treaty   between   the   United   States   and   Great   Britain, 

commonly  known  as  the  "reciprocity  treaty."     Feb.  5, 

1862.     36  pp.     8°. 

37th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  report  no.  22.  1144 

Report  by  Hon.  Elijah  Ward. 

"Without  doubt  the  best  report  made  on  the  subject  up  to  that 

time." — Robinson,  History  of  two  reciprocity  treaties,  p.  80. 
"The  chief  points  for  consideration  are  the  extent,  population, 
position,  and  resources  of  the  British  North  American  provinces 
and  possessions;  the  present  so-called  'reciprocity  treaty';  the 
existing  condition  of  our  commercial  and  fiscal  relations  with 
Canada,  and  the  line  of  policy  most  conducive  to  the  interest 
and  welfare  of  both  countries;  the  tendencies  of  modern  inven- 
tions and  civilization  on  the  intercourse  of  nations,  including 
the  leading  principles  of  the  German  commercial  union  or  ZoU- 
verein,  and  their  applicability  to  the  United  States." 

1862.  Letter  of  the  Secretary  of  the  Treasury,  transmitting  a  tabular 
statement  showing  the  quantity  and  value  of  the  different 
articles  of  merchandise  imported  into  the  United  States 
from  the  British  North  American  colonies  during  the  fiscal 
years  ending  June  30,  1859,  1860,  and  1861,  under  the 
treaty  of  reciprocity.  June  13,  1862.  3  pp.  8°. 
37th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  60.  1122 


54  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1862.     Relations  between  the  United  States  and  northwest  British 

America:  abstract  of  the  reports  of  James  W.  Taylor  and 

of  other  papers  relating  to  the  subject.     July  11,  1862. 

85  pp.     8°. 

37th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  lJf.6.  1138 

1862.     Commercial  intercourse  with  Canada.     Letter  from  the  Secre- 
tary of  the  Treasury  in  relation  to  commercial  intercourse 
with  Canada.     July  12,  1862.     21  pp.     8°. 
37ih  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  149.  1138 

Tabular  statements  showing  "the  amount  and  kinds  of  the  pro- 
ductions of  the  British  colonies  imported  into  the  United  States, 
free  of  duty,  under  the  provisions  of  the  treaty  between  Great 
Britain  and  the  United  States,  signed  June  4,  1854,  known  as 
the  'reciprocity  treaty,'  and  of  the  amount  and  kinds  of  the 
productions  of  the  United  States  exported  to  the  British  colonies 
under  the  stipulations  of  the  said  treaty  from  the  ratification 
thereof  to  the  present  time,"  etc. 

1864.     Reciprocity  treaty.     Letter  from  the  Secretary  of  the  Treas- 
ury in  relation  to  the  operations  of  the  reciprocity   treaty 
[with  Canada].     Feb.  1,  1864.     61  pp.     8°. 
38th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  32.  1189 

1864.     Reciprocity  treaty.     (To  accompany  H.  res.  no.  56.)     Apr.  1, 
1864.     8  pp.     8°. 
38th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  39.  1206 

1864-1865.  Debate  on  termination  of  Canadian  reciprocity  treaty. 
Congressional  globe,  38th  Congress,  1st  session  (May  18, 
1864):  2333-2338;  (May  19,  1864):  2364-2371;  {May  24, 
1864):  2453-2456;  {May  25,  186 4):  2476-2484;  {May  26, 
1864):  2502-2509;  38th  Congress,  2d  session  {Dec.  21, 
1864):  95-97;  {Jan.  11, 1865):  204-213;  {Jan.  12, 1865): 
226-234. 

1866.  Derby,  Elias  Hasket.  A  preliminary  report  on  the  treaty 
of  reciprocity  with  Great  Britain,  to  regulate  the  trade 
between  the  United  States  and  the  provinces  of  British 
North  America.  Prepared  by  E.  H.  Derby,  at  the  re- 
quest of  the  Secretary  of  the  Treasuiy  of  the  United 
States. 
Washington:   Treasury  department,  1866.     84  pp.     8°. 

1866.  Commercial  relations  with  British  America.  Letter  from 
the  Secretary  of  the  Treasury,  in  answer  to  a  resolution 
of  the  House  of  representatives  of  Mar.  28,  1866,  calling 
for  information  in  regard  to  commercial  relations  with 
British  America.  June  14,  1866.  36  pp.  8°. 
39th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  128.  1263 


RECIPROCITY  WITH  CANADA*.   U.   S.   DOCUMENTS  55 

1867  A  report  of  Israel  T.  Hatch,  of  New  York,  upon  our  com- 
mercial relations  with  British  provinces,  and  upon  the 
comparative  importance  of  American  and  Canadian  com- 
mercial channels  of  transportation  of  property  from  the 
West  to  the  seaboard.  Jan.  30,  1867.  41pp.  8°. 
S9th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  7S.  1293 

1867  [A  report  from  the  Secretary  of  state,  W.  H.  Seward]  relative 
to  the  practicabihty  of  estabhshing  equal  reciprocal 
relations  between  the  United  States  and  the  British 
North  American  provinces,  and  the  actual  condition  of 
the  question  of  the  fisheries.  Feb.  19,  1867.  186  pp.  8°^ 
39th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  30.  1277 

Pp  2-28  contain  report  by  E.  H.  Derby;  pp.  29-66,  "A  prelimi- 
nary report  on  the  treaty  of  reciprocity  with  Great  Britain, 
to  regulate  the  trade  between  the  United  States  and  the  prov- 
inces^of  British  North  America,"  by  E.  H.  Derby. 

1868  Trade  with  the  British  provinces.  Letter  from  the  Secretary 
of  the  Treasury,  transmitting  information  as  to  the  trade 
between  the  United  States  and  the  British  North  Ameri- 
can provinces  since  the  abrogation  of  the  reciprocity 
treaty.  Mar.  31,  1868.  18  pp.  8°. 
40tTi  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  2Ifi.  I«i41 

1868      Trade  with  the  British  provinces.     Letter  from  the  Secretary 
of  the  Treasury,  transmitting  a  supplemental  report  on 
trade  with  the  British  North  American  provinces.     May 
15,1868.     11pp.     8°. 
Ifitli  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  2^0,  part  2. 

1868.  Letter  from  the  Secretary  of  state  [Wilham  H.  Seward]  to 
the  Hon.  John  Sherman,  chairman  of  the  Committee  on 
finance,  transmitting  correspondence  with  the  State 
department  in  relation  to  the  injurious  effect  upon  the 
Nova  Scotia  coal  trade,  occasioned  by  the  abrogation  of 
the  reciprocity  treaty.  June  3,  1868.  3  pp.  8°. 
40t]i  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  misc.  doc.  no.  87.        1319 

1869.     Report  of  Israel  T.  Hatch  upon  the  commercial  relations  of 
the  United  States  with  the  Dominion  of  Canada.     Jan. 
12,1869.     26  pp.     8°. 
JtOih  Congress,  3d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  36.  137^ 


56  LIBEAEY   OF   CONGRESS 

1869.     Colonial  trade  and  fisheries.     Report  of  E.  H.  Derby.     Feb. 

8,  1869.     54  pp.     8°. 
Jfith  Congress,  3d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  75.  1374 

In  regard  to  reciprocity  with  Canada. 

1871.  State  of  trade  with  British  North  American  provinces.  Let- 
ter from  the  Secretary  of  the  Treasury,  transmitting  a 
report  on  the  state  of  trade  between  the  United  States 
and  the  British  North  American  possessions.  Feb.  3, 
1871.  .39  pp.  8°. 
4.1st  Congress,  3d  session.     House  exec.  doc.  no.  94-  1454 

Report  of  J.  N.  Larned,  special  agent. 

1874.  Confidential  memorandum  for  the  use  of  the  Commissioners  on 
the  part  of  the  United  States  in  the  American-British 
joint  high  commission,  Washington,  1871. 

(In  U.  S.  Dept.  of  state.     Papers  relating  to  the  foreign  relations 
of  the  United  States,  1873,  vol.  3,  pp.  265-268,  277-370.     Wash- 
ington, 1874.     8°.) 
"Reciprocal  trade  between  the  United  States  and  the  Dominion 
of  Canada":  pp.  292-305. 

1876.     Commercial  relations  with  Canada.     Report  from  the  Sub- 
committee on  commerce.     Jan.  18,  1876.     9  pp.     8°. 
44th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  9.  1708 

Favoring  appointment  of  commissioners  "to  investigate  and 
ascertain  on  what  basis  a  treaty  of  reciprocal  trade  for  the 
mutual  benefit  of  the  people  of  the  United  States  and  the 
Dominion  of  Canada  can  be  negotiated." 
Also  printed  as  House  report  389,  part  2,  44th  Congress,  1st  session 
(serial  no.  1709). 

1876.     Commercial  relations  with  Canada.     Views  of  the  minority 
[of  the  Committee  on  commerce].     Apr.  11,  1876.     9  pp. 
8°. 
44th'  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  389,  part  2. 

1709 

Also  printed  as  House  report  9,  44th  Congress,  1st  session  (serial 
no.  1708). 

1880.     Reciprocity  treaty  between  United  States  and  British  prov- 
inces.    Report   from  the  Committee  on  foreign  affairs. 
Apr.  23,  1880.     5  pp.     8°. 
46th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  report  no.  1127,  part  1. 

1937 

1880.     Same.     Views  of  the  minority.     June  7,  1880.     20  pp.     8°. 
46tli  Congress,  2d  session.     House  report  no.  1127,  part  2. 

1937 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA:   U.   S.   DOCUMENTS  57 

1884,     Commercial  relations  with  Canada  and  other  states  on  the 
American    continent.     Report   from    the   Committee    on 
foreign  affairs.     July  5,  1884.     3  pp.     8°. 
IfSth  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  2149.  2259 

Report  on  a  joint  resolution  requesting  the  President  to  negotiate 
with  the  government  of  Great  Britain  for  the  renewal  of  the 
reciprocity  treaty  of  1854. 
"  The  committee  .  .  .  in  recognition  of  the  fact  that  the  Constitu- 
tion has  prescribed  that  all  measures  affecting  the  revenues  of 
the  Government  should  originate  in  the  House,  consider  it  emi- 
nently fit  that  the  House  should  give  expression  to  its  opinion 
regarding  international  agreements  which  may  affect  such 
revenues." 
Resolution  recommended,  "That  in  opinion  of  the  House,  closer 
commercial  relations  with  the  other  states  on  the  American  conti- 
nent would  be  of  mutual  advantage,  and  that,  should  the  Execu- 
tive see  fit  to  consider  propositions  for  freer  commerce  with  the 
Dominion  of  Canada,  such  negotiations  would  be  viewed  with 
favor." 

1888.     Report  of  the  Committee  on  foreign  affairs,  to  promote  com- 
mercial union  with  Canada.     Mar.  16,  1888.     2  pp.     8°. 
50th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1183.  2601 

1890.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Resolution  from  the  Committee 
on  foreign  affairs.     May  2,  1890.     1  page.     8°. 
51st  Congress,  1st  session.     House  misc.  doc.  no.  195.      2775 

1890.     Commercial    union    with    Canada.     [Report    of    the    Com- 
mittee on  foreign  affairs.]     May  2,  1890.     2  pp.     8°. 
51st  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1870.  2812 

1890.     Relations  with  Canada.     Testimony  taken  b}^  the  Select  com- 
mittee on  relations  with  Canada.     July  21,  1890.     1298 
pp.     8°. 
51st  Congress,  1st  session.    Senxite  report  no.  1530,  pts.  1,  2. 

2712 

1892.     Message  from  the  President,  relative  to  negotiations  for  recip- 
rocal trade  with  Canada.     June  20,  July  1,   1892.     47, 
11pp.     8°. 
52d  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  11 4,  parts  1,2. 

2901 

Contains  report  of  Secretary  Blaine  on  negotiations  recently  held 
with  representatives  of  the  Dominion  of  Canada  and  the  British 
government  as  to  arrangements  for  reciprocal  trade  between 
Canada  and  the  United  States,  with  correspondence  relating  to 
trade  regulations. 

Pt.  2,  reports  conferences  with  Canadian  commissioners  in  regard 
to  Canadian  ^anal  tolls. 


58  LIBEAEY   OF   CONGEESS 

1892.  Reciprocal  commercial  relations  with  Canada.  Report  from 
the  Committee  on  foreign  affairs.  July  20,  1892. 
8  pp.     8°. 

1st  session.     House  report  no.  1957.  3051 


1894.     Statements  prepared  in  the  Bureau  of  statistics,  showing  the 

commercial  relations  betweto  the  United  States  and  the 

Dominion  of  Canada  since  the  year  1821.     May  31,  1894. 

97  pp.     2  folded  diagrams.     8°. 

53d  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  106.  3163 

1897.  Memorial  from  the  coal  producers,  miners,  and  carriers,  pro- 
testing against  the  increase  in  the  tariff  rate  on  coal,  and 
favoring  a  reciprocal  clause  in  the  tariff  bill  relating  to 
coal  as  to  the  Dominion  of  Canada.  June  25,  1897. 
3  pp.  8°. 
55ih  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  158.  3563 

1902.  Papers  and  statistics  in  regard  to  Gloucester  and  New  Eng- 
land fisheries  [and  effect  thereon  of  proposed  convention 
with  Great  Britain  for  improvement  of  commercial  rela- 
tions with  Newfoundland];  presented  by  Mr.  Lodge. 
Dec.  4,  1902.  27  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  14-  4417 

1902.  Improvement  of  commercial  relations  with  Newfoundland. 
Message  from  the  President,  transmitting  a  convention 
with  Great  Britain,  signed  at  Washington  on  November 
8,  1902,  for  the  improvement  of  commercial  relations  with 
Newfoundland.  December  17,  1902.  5  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  ^9.  4420 

1902.  Commercial   relations  with  Newfoundland.     Resolutions  of 

the  Central  labor  union  of  Gloucester,  Mass.,  and  protest 
of  the  Gloucester  master  mariners'  association  against  the 
ratification  of  the  proposed  treat}^  with  Great  Britain  with 
respect  to  commercial  relations  with  Newfoundland.  De- 
cember 17,  1902.  2  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  50.  4420 

1903.  Articles  published  in  the  Boston  herald  and  the  New  York 

tribune  relating  to  the  Hay-Bond  treaty.     C.  W.  Fair- 
banks.    January  5,  1903.     25  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  65.  4420 


EECIPROCITY   WITH    CANADA:    U.    S.   DOCUMENTS  59 

1903.     Memorial  and  letters  from  citizens  of  Massachusetts  engaged 
in  the  fish  business  or  owners  of  fishing  vessels  remonstrat- 
ing against  the  ratification  of  the  Hay-Bond  treaty.     Jan- 
uary 6,  1903.     5  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  78.  4422 

1903.     Protest  of  the  Fisheries  company  against  the  ratification  of 

the  Hay-Bond  treaty  for  the  improvement  of  commercial 

relations  with  Newfoundland.     January  19,  1903.     4  pp. 

8°. 

57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  94.  4422 

1905.     Reciprocity   and   preferential   tariff   discussions   in  Canada. 
Vice-Consul-General  George  Hill. 

{In  United  States.  Bureau  of  statistics  (Dept.  of  commerce  and 
labor).  Monthly  consular  repiorts,  no.  292,  Jan.  1905,  pp. 
128-129.    Washington,  1905.    8°.) 


*p:BR^^ 


OF 


THE 


OF 


CANADIAN  AND  BRITISH   DOCUMENTS 

1854.  Great  Britain.      Treaties,  etc.     Treaty  between  Her  Majesty 

and  the  United  States  of  America,  relative  to  fisheries, 
commerce,  and  navigation.  Signed  at  Washington,  June 
5,  1854.  Presented  to  both  Houses  of  Parliament,  1854. 
(2),  4  pp.     F°. 

(In    Great     Britain.     Parliament.     Sessional     papers,     1854-55, 
vol.  55.) 

1855.  Canada.     Parliament.     Legislative   assemhly.     Committee   to 

inquire  into  commercial  intercourse  between  Canada  and 
Great  Britain,  British  North  American  colonies,  West  India 
possessions,    United  States,   and   other  foreign   countries, 

Report  on  trade  and  commerce.     Printed  by  order  of  the 
Legislative  assembly. 

Quebec:  Printed   by   Lovell    cfc    Lamoureux,    1855.     4^    PP- 
Frontispiece  (map).     8°. 

Wm.  Hamilton  Merritt,  chairman. 

1855.  Great  Britain.  Foreign  office.  North  American  colonies. 
Copiesof  acts  recently  passed  by  the  legislatures  of  Canada, 
Nova  Scotia,  New  Brunswick,  and  Prince  Edward  Island 
for  giving  effect  on  the  part  of  those  provinces  to  the  recent 
reciprocity  treaty  with  the  United  States.  Presented  to 
both  Houses  of  Parliament,  2d  February,  1855.  8  pp.  F°. 
(In  Great  Britain.     Parliament.     Sessional  papers,  1855,  vol.  36.) 

1860.  Canada.  Parliament.  Sessional  papers  (no.  30),  1860. 
Return  to  an  address  of  the  Legislative  assembly,  dated 
28th  March,  1860;  for  copy  of  correspondence  which  may 
have  taken  place  in  reference  to  the  working  of,  or  the 
repealing  of,  the  reciprocity  treaty.  Apr.  3,  1860.  14 
pp.     8°. 

{In  Canada.     Sessional  papers,  vol.  4.     Third  session  of  the  sixth 
Parliament.     Session,  1860.) 

1862.  Great  Britain.  Foreign  office.  North  America,  no.  10, 
1862.  Despatch  from  Lord  Lyons  respecting  the  reci- 
procity treaty.  Presented  to  both  Houses  of  Parliament, 
1862.     25  pp.     F°. 

(In  Great  Britain.     Parliament.     Sessional  papers,  1862,  vol.  62.) 


EECIPROCITY    WITH    CANADA:    CANADIAN    DOCUMENTS  61 

1862.  Canada.  Parliament.  Sessional  papers  (no.  23),  1862.  Re- 
port of  the  Minister  of  finance  on  tlie  reciprocity  treaty 
with  the  United  States;  also,  the  Memorial  of  the  Chamher 
of  commerce  of  St.  Paul,  Minnesota,  and  Report  of  Con- 
gress (U.  S.)  thereon.     Mar.  28,  1862.     45  pp.     8°. 

{In  Canada.     Sessional  papers,  vol.  4.     First  session  of  the  seventh 

Parliament.     Session,  1862.) 
Prepared  by  Sir  Alexander  T.  Gait. 

1865.  Great  Britain.  Foreign  office.  North  America,  no.  2 
(1S65).  Papers  respecting  the  termination  of  the  reci- 
procity treaty  of  June  5,  1854,  between  Great  Britain 
and  the  United  States.  Presented  to  both  Houses  of  Par- 
hament,  1865.     (2),  2  pp.     F°. 

{In  Great  Britain.     Parliament.     Sessional  papers,  1865,  vol.  57.) 

1865.  Canada.     Parliament.     Sessional    papers     (no.    26),    1865. 

Return  to  an  address  of  the  Legislative  assembly,  dated 
15th  February,  1865,  for  copy  of  all  correspondence  be- 
tween the  government  of  Canada  and  the  United  States 
or  the  British  ambassador  at  Washington,  and  of  all 
despatches  from  the  Home  government,  and  orders  in 
council,  on  the  subject  of  the  reciprocity  treaty.  Feb. 
17,  1865.     4  pp.     8°. 

{In  Canada.     Sessional  papers,  vol.  3.     Third  session  of  the  eighth 
Parliament.     Ses.sion,  1865.) 

1866.  Great     Britain.     Foreign    office.     Correspondence    respect- 

ing the  termination  of  the  reciprocity  treaty  of  June  5, 
1854,  between  the  United  States  and  (jrreat  Britain.  Pre- 
sented to  both  Houses  of  Parliament,  1866.  (2),  17  pp. 
F°. 

{In  Great  Britain.     Parliament.     Sessional  papers,  1866,  vol.  76.) 

1869.  Canada.  Parliament.  Sessional  papers  (no.  47),  1869. 
Return  to  two  addresses  of  the  House  of  commons,  dated 
22d  and  29th  April,  1869;  for  copies  of  all  corresj)ondence 
which  has  passed  since  the  1st  May  last  between  the  Impe- 
rial government,  the  cabinet  at  Washington,  and  the  gov- 
ernment of  the  Dominion  of  Canada  on  the  subject  of  the 
renewal  of  the  reciprocity  treaty  with  the  United  States, 
and  of  all  negotiations  entered  upon  in  consequence  of  the 
abrogation  of  that  treaty;  and  for  copies  of  all  corre- 
spondence and  despatches  between  the  government  of 
Canada  and  that  of  Great  Britain,  or  with  the  British 
ambassador  at  Washington,  or  other  parties  in  the  United 
States,  since  the  1st  day  of  January,  1867,  in  reference  to 
a  renewal  of  the  reciprocity  treaty;  and  for  copies  of  all 
orders  in  council  on  the  same  subject.  May  14,  1869. 
18  pp.     8°. 

{In  Canada.     Sessional  papers,  vol.  5.     Second  session  of  the  first 
Parliament.     Session,  1869.) 
27.306°— 10 5 


62  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1873.  Canada.     Parliament.     Sessional    papers    (no.    40),    1873. 

Return  to  an  address  of  the  House  of  commons,  dated  3rd 
April,  1873;  for  copies  of  all  correspondence  between  the 
government  of  the  Dominion  and  the  government  of  the 
United  States,  on  the  subject  of  reciprocal  trade  between 
the  two  countries,  or  any  other  documents  on  that  sub- 
ject.    Apr.  8,  1873.     5  pp..    8°. 

{Li  Canada.     Sessional  papers,  vol.  6.     First  session  of  the  second 
Parliament.     Session,  1873.) 

1874.  Great  Britain.     Foreign    office.     North    America.     No.     4 

(1874).  Correspondence  relating  to  the  negotiations  for 
a  reciprocity  treaty  between  Canada  and  the  United 
States.  Presented  to  both  Houses  of  Parliament,  1874. 
(2),  24  pp.     F°.     (C.-1060.) 

(In  Great  Britain.     Parliament.     Sessional  papers,  1874,  vol.  75.) 

1875.  Canada.     Parliament.     Sessional    papers    (No.    51),    1875. 

Supplementary  return  to  an  address  of  the  Senate,  dated 
25th  February,  1875;  for  such  papers  in  connection  with 
the  negotiations  with  the  government  of  the  United  States 
for  a  treaty  of  commercial  reciprocity  as  may  be  com- 
patible with  the  public  interest  to  submit.  March  19, 
1875.     12  pp.     8°. 

(In  Canada.     Sessional  papers,  vol.  8.     Second  session  of  the  third 
Parliament.     Session,  1875.) 

1875.     Debate  on  reciprocity  with  the  United  States.     March  22, 

1875. 

(In  Canada.     Parliament.     House  of  commons.     Debates,  session 
1875,  vol.  1,  pp.  835-842.) 

1883.     Debate  on  reciprocity  with  the  United  States.     March  19, 

1883. 

(In  Canada.     Parliament.     House  of  commons.     Official  reports 
of  the  debates,  5th  Parliament,  1st  session,  vol.  13,  pp.  267-272.) 

1883.  Canada.     Parliament.     Sessional    papers     (no.    55),     1883. 

Return  to  an  address  of  the  House  of  commons,  dated 
19th  March,  1883;  for  copies  of  all  correspondence  be- 
tween the  government  of  Canada  and  the  government  of 
the  United  States,  [etc.]  upon  the  question  of  reciprocal 
trade  relations  between  the  two  countries,  on  the  general 
basis  of  the  reciprocity  treaty  of  1854,  since  1878.  Mar. 
29,  1883.     3  pp.     8°. 

(In  Canada.     Sessional  papers,  vol.  16,  no.  11.     Session,  1883.) 

1884.  Debate  on  reciprocity  with  the  United  States.     March  28, 

1884. 

(In  Canada.     Parliament.     House  of  commons.     Official  report  of 
the  debates,  5th  Parliament,  2d  session,  vol.  16,  pp.  1176-1190.) 


EECIPROCITY    WITH    CANADA:    CANADIAN    DOCUMENTS  63 

1885.  Debate  on  reciprocity  with  the  United  States.  April  10, 
1885. 

{In  Canada.  Parliament.  House  of  commons.  Official  report  of 
the  debates,  5th  Parliament,  3d  session,  vol.  18,  pp.  995-1022.) 

1888.  Debate  on  reciprocity  with  the  United  States. 

{In  Canada.  Parliament.  House  of  commons.  Official  report  of 
the  debates,  6th  Parliament,  2d  session,  vol.  25-26,  pp.  161-646.) 

A  resume  of  the  debate  is  printed  in  Appleton's  annual  cyclopaedia, 
for  1888,  vol.  28,  pp.  278-283. 

1889.  Debate  on  reciprocity  with  the  United  States. 

{In  Canada.  Parliament.  House  of  commons.  Official  report  of 
the  debates,  6th  Parliament,  3d  session,  vol.  27-28,  pp.  472-735.) 

1892.  Canada.     Parliament.     Sessional    papers     (No.    37),   1892. 

Copies  of  documents  relating  to  the  negotiations  at  the 
conference  recently  held  at  Washington  between  the  dele- 
gates from  the  Canadian  government  and  the  Secretary 
of  state  of  the  United  States  respecting  the  extension  and 
development  of  trade  between  the  United  States  and  the 
Dominion  of  Canada.     Mar.  16,  1892.     6  pp.     8°. 

{In  Canada.  Sessional  papers,  vol.  12.  Second  session  of  the 
seventh  Parliament.     Session,  1892.) 

1893.  Canada.     Parliament.     Sessional    papers    (No.    52),    1893. 

Papers  relating  to  the  conference  held  at  Washington  in 
Februar}^,  1892,  between  the  delegates  of  the  Canadian 
government,  and  the  Secretary  of  state  of  the  United 
States  upon  the  several  subjects  therein  mentioned.  Mar. 
7,  1893.     8  pp.     8°. 

{In  Canada.     Sessional  papers,  vol.  26.     Third  session  of  the  sev- 
enth Parliament.     Session  1893.) 
The  question  of  a  new  treaty  of  reciprocity  was  discu.ssed  in  the 
conference. 

1894.  Debate  on  reciprocity  with  the  United  States.     April  17,  1894. 

{In  Canada.  Parliament.  House  of  commons.  Official  report  of 
the  debates,  7th  Parliament,  4th  session,  vol.  37,  col.  1505-1563.) 

1899.  Canada.  Parliament.  Sessional  papers  (no.  5A),  1899. 
Special  report  on  trade  between  Canada  and  the  United 
States  for  use  of  the  International  commission,  Quebec, 
August  1898.     259  pp.     8°. 

(/n  Canada.  Sessional  papers,  vol.  4.  Fourth  session  of  the  eighth 
Parliament.     Session,  1899.) 

1902.     Debate  on  reciprocity  with  the  United  States.     Feb.  24,  1902. 
{In  Canada.     Parliament.     House  of  commons.     Official  report  of 
the  debates,  9thNParliament,  2d  session,  vol.  56,  col.  247-316.) 


BOOK? 

American   iron   and    steel   association.     Canadian   reciprocity. 
Why  some  Canadians  want  reciprocity.     Why  Enghsh- 
men  want  it.     Why  we  don't  want  it. 
Philadelphia:      The    American   iron   and    steel   association., 
[1877].     16  pp.     8°. 

Andrews,  Israel  DeWolf.  Communication  from  the  Secretary  of 
the  Treasury  transmitting  .  .  .  the  report  of  Israel  D. 
Andrews  ...  on  the  trade  and  commerce  of  the  British 
North  American  colonies,  and  upon  the  trade  of  the 
great  lakes  and  rivers ;  also,  notices  of  the  internal  improve- 
ments in  each  state,  of  the  Gulf  of  Mexico  and  straits  of 
Florida,  and  a  paper  on  the  cotton  crop  of  the  United 
States. 
Washington:  B.  Tucker,  1854-  viii,  851  pp.  and  atlas  of  4 
fold.  maps.     8°. 

Reprint  of  Senate  ex.  doc.  112  and  House  ex.  doc.  136,  32d  Con- 
gress, 1st  session. 

* •—    The  reciprocity  and  fishery  treaty:  history  of  negotiations 

and  statements  of  commercial  results;  address  to  Hon. 
Wm.  H.  Seward,  Secretary  of  state. 
Washington:  Printed  hy  L.  Towers  cfc  co.,  1862.     {2),  v,  (1), 
[3],  272  pp.     8°. 

Imperfect.  All  after  p.  272  missing.  State  department  library. 
"It  will  be  understood  that  the  author  has  prepared  this  paper  in 
justification  of  the  treaty,  without  aid  or  compensation  of  any 
kind,  from  any  source  whatever,  and  no  one  but  himself  is 
accountable  or  responsible  for  the  views,  opinions,  and  state- 
ments therein  contained." 

Barker,  Wharton.     Our  Canadian  relations.     A  letter  to  Hon.  James 
A.  Garfield. 
[Philadelphia:  Press  of  E.  Stern  c&  co.,  1880].     8  pp.     8°. 

[Letter  to  George  Brown,  esq.,  on  the  commercial  relations 

between  Canada  and  the  United  States.] 
Philadelphia,  1880.     4  jyp.     8°. 


*  Not  in  Library  of  Congr 
64 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA:    BOOKS  65 

Blackwell,  Henry  B.  Reciprocity,  a  Republican  issue.  Reciprocity 
with  Canada  and  Newfoundland.  1.  Is  it  desirable  ?  2. 
Is  it  practicable ?  3.  Is  it  timely?  4.  Is  it  Republican? 
Addresses  upon  this  topic  by  Henry  B.  Blackwell  and 
Eugene  N.  Foss  before  the  Massachusetts  club,  Boston, 
June  11,  1904. 
Boston:  Issued  by  the  New  England  reciprociti/  league  [1904  ?]. 
[16]  pp.     5°. 

Blaine,  James  G.     Twenty  years  of  Congress  from  Lincoln  to  Gar- 
field.    With   a  review  of  the  events  which  led   to   the 
political  revolution  of  1860. 
NorwicJi,  Conn.:  Henry  Bill  publishing  company,  1884~86. 
2  vols.     Plates  (portraits).     8°. 

Reciprocity  treaties  of  1782,  1818,  1854:  vol.  2,  pp.  615-637. 

Blake,  John  X.     The  true  commercial  policy  for.._GreSter  Britain. 

An  address,  delivered  before  the  CcM^ntWfcial  union  club, 

Toronto,  April  5th,  1888. 

Toronto:  Hunter, Rose  <&  company,  1888.     4^  pp.     Map.    8°. 

"Canadian  mines  and  reciprocity.     Being  a  paper  read  before  the 

Commercial  union  club,  by  T.  D.  Ledyard":  pp.  31-43. 

Boston.     Board   oflbrade.     Special  committee.     The  reciprocity 
treaty,  between  the  United  States  and  Great  Britain,  of 
June  5,  1854.     Report. 
Boston:  Press  of  T.  R.  Marvin  &  son,  1865.     23  pp.     8°. 
Also  printed  in  11th  annual  report  of  the  Boston  Board  of  trade. 

Chamber  of  commerce.     Argument  of  the  Committee 

on  reciprocity  with  Canada  and   Newfoundland  of  the 
Boston  Chamber  of  commerce  in  favor  of  the  ratification 
of  the  Hay-Bond  treaty  before  the  Senate  Committee  on 
foreign  relations  at  Washington,  March  11,  1903. 
[  Washington?  1903.]     7  pp.     8°. 

Bourinot,  Sir  John  George.     Canada  under  British  rule,  1760-1900. 
Cambridge:    University  j^ress,  1900.     xi,  {1),346  pp.     Maps. 
12°.     (Cambridge  historical  series.) 
"Bibliographical  note":  pp.  327-330. 
Reciprocity:  pp.  269,  304-310,  376. 

Lord  Elgin,     fid.  de  luxe. 

Toronto:  G.  N.  Morang  and  company,  limited,  1908.  (12), 
276  pp.  Frontispiece  (portrait).  8°.  (The  makers  of 
Canada.) 

"Bibliographical  note":  pp.  269-270. 

Reciprocity  treaty  with  United  States  argued  by  Lord  Elgin,  p.  82 
treaty  ratified,  p.  142;  signed,  p.  198;  its  provisions,  pp.  198-200 
beneficial  results,  p.  201;  repealed  by  the  United  States,  p.  201 
result  of  the  repeal,  p.  202. 


66  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Brown,  George.     The  reciprocity  negotiations. 

{In  Mackenzie,  Alexander.  The  life  and  speeches  of  Hon.  George 
Brown,  pp.  348-374.     Toronto,  1882.     8°.) 

Buchanan,  Isaac.  The  relations  of  the  industry  of  Canada,  with 
the  mother  country  and  the  United  States,  being  a 
speech  by  Isaac  Buchanan,  together  with  a  series  of 
articles  in  defence  of  the  national  sentiments  contained 
therein.  Ed.  by  Henry  J.  Morgan. 
Montreal:  Printed  hy  J.  Lovell,  1864-  551  fp.  Frontis- 
piece {portrait).     Illustrations.     8°. 

Butterworth,  Benjamin.     Commercial  union  between  Canada  and 
the  United  States. 

(In  Canadian  club  of  New  York.  Canadian  leaves,  pp.  175-216. 
New  York,  1887.     8°.) 

The  Canadian  annual  review  of  public  affairs.     1901-date. 

Toronto:   The  Annual  review  publishing  company,   limited, 
1903-date.     8°. 

1901-date,  by  J.  Castell  Hopkins. 

Includes  an  annual  review  of  the  movement  for  reciprocity 
between  Canada  and  the  United  States. 

Carey,  H.  C.     The  British  treaties  of  1871  &  1874.     Letters  to  the 
President  of  the  United  States. 
Philadelphia:   Collins,  printer,  1874-     38  pp.     8°. 

Discusses  the  commercial  relations  of  the  United  States  and 
Canada.     Opposed  to  reciprocity. 

Charlton,  John.     The  budget:   preferential  trade  with  Great  Brit- 
ain— reciprocity  with  the  United  States.     House  of  com- 
mons, April  21,  1903. 
Ottawa:  Government  printing  bureau,  1903.     16  pp.     8°. 
Cover-title. 

Canadian  trade  relations  with  the  United  States. 

(In  Hopkins,  John  C,  ed.  Canada:  an  encyclopsedia  of  the 
country,  vol.  1,  pp.  371-378.     Toronto,  [1898].     4°.) 

Speech  on  trade  relations,  reciprocity  in  trade  conditions. 

Ottawa,  Monday,  February  24,  1902. 
Ottawa:  Government  printing  bureau,  1902.     13  pp.     8°. 
Cover- title. 

Chomley,  C.  H.     Protection  in  Canada  and  Australasia. 

London:  P.  S.  King  cfc  son,  1904.     xiii,  (3),  195  pp.     12°. 

Contents  include:  Canada:  Early  tariff  history;  The  provincial 
tariffs;  Tariffs  in  the  Dominion;  Effects  of  the  national  policy; 
The  tariff  reductions  of  1897;  The  preferential  tariff;  The 
strength  of  protectionist  feeling;  Imperial  preferential  trade. 


EECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA:   BOOKS  67 

Clarke,   Albert.     Reciprocity  with  Canada;  status  of  negotiations 
and    trade    relations;   speech    before    the    Massachusetts 
state  board  of  trade,  January  21,  1902. 
Boston:  Pub.  hy  the  Home  marJcet  dub,  [1902].     13  pp.     8°. 

Cominercial  convention,  Detroit,  1865.     Proceedings  of  the  com- 
mercial convention,  held  in  Detroit,  July  11th,  12th,  13th 
and  14th,  1865.     Pub.  by  order  of  the  Convention. 
Detroit:  Advertiser    and     Tribune    company    print,     1865. 
276  pp.     8°. 

The  subjects  discussed  by  the  convention  were  those  of  commerce, 
finance,  transportation  from  the  West  to  the  seaboard,  and 
reciprocal  trade  between  the  United  States  and  the  British  North 
American  provinces. 

Commercial  union  club  of  Toronto.  Handbook  of  commercial 
union:  a  collection  of  papers  read  before  the  Commercial 
union  club,  Toronto,  with  speeches,  letters  and  other 
documents  in  favour  of  unrestricted  reciprocity  with  the 
United  States.  Preceded  by  an  introduction,  by  Mr. 
Goldwin  Smith.  Ed.  by  G.  Mercer  Adam. 
Toronto:  Hunter,  Rose  &  company,  1888.  xxxvi,  294,  (^)  PP- 
Map.     12°. 

Contents. — Reciprocity  with  the  United  States,  speecli  by  the 
Hon.  Sir  Richard  Cartwright,  delivered  in  the  House  of  com- 
mons, Ottawa,  14th  March,  1888;  A  farmer's  view  of  com- 
mercial union,  by  Thomas  Shaw;  Commercial  union  and  the 
mining  interests  of  Canada,  by  T.  D.  Ledyard;  How  unre- 
stricted reciprocity  with  the  United  States  would  affect  the 
prosperity  of  Toronto,  by  S.  H.  Janes;  The  effect  of  commercial 
union  on  our  relations  with  Great  Britain,  by  W.  H.  Lockhart 
Gordon;  Current  objections  to  commercial  union  considered, 
by  the  Hon.  J.  W.  Longley;  Address  on  commercial  union,  by 
James  Pearson;  Address  to  the  farmers  of  Ilaldimand,  by  John 
Charlton;  How  commercial  union  would  affect  the  labour 
market,  by  Alfred  F.  Jury;  Address  before  the  West  Peterboro' 
farmers'  institute,  by  Wm.  Cluxton;  Reciprocity  in  the  North- 
west, by  F.  C.  Wade;  The  Ontario  farmers'  institutes  and  com- 
mercial union;  Speech  on  commercial  union  at  the  Toronto 
Board  of  trade,  by  Henry  W.  Darling;  The  manufacturing 
interests  in  relation  to  commercial  union  (A  reply  to  the  Hon. 
James  Young),  with  an  article  contributed  to  the  press  on  a 
policy  that  would  benefit  Canada,  by  J.  Dryden;  A  series  of 
letters  addressed  by  Mr.  Goldwin  Smith  to  the  Toronto  Mail, 
on  the  subject  of  commercial  union,  dealing  with  the  discussif)n 
in  its  various  phases,  and  meeting  the  arguments  successively 
advanced  against  the  measure;  A  letter  addressed  from  Wash- 
ington by  Mr.  Goldwin  Smith  to  the  secretary  of  the  Commercial 
union  club,  Toronto,  on  the  progress  of  the  movement  in  the 
United  States;  A  letter  addressed  by  Mr.  Goldwin  Smith  to  the 


68  LIBRAEY   OF   CONGEESS 

Toronto  Mail  on  imperial  federation  as  an  alternative  to  com- 
mercial union;  A  letter  addressed  by  Mr.  Goldwin  Smith  to  the 
New  York  "Independent"  on  commercial  union,  and  treating 
the  subject  in  its  relation  to  the  Americans;  A  letter  addressed 
by  Mr.  Goldwin  Smith  to  the  New  York  Chamber  of  commerce, 
from  the  New  York  "Times;"  Speech  in  the  House  of  com- 
mons, Ottawa,  on  the  reciprocity  debate,  by  Wm.  Mulock;  The 
effect  of  reciprocity  with  the  United  States  on  the  lumber  trade, 
by  A.  H.  Campbell;  A  series  of  articles  on  commercial  union 
from  the  Toronto  "Mail,"  by  Edward  Farrer;  Constitution  (with 
list  of  executive  officers)  of  the  Commercial  union  club,  Toronto. 

Derby,  Elias  Hasket.  Letter  to  the  Hon.  William  H.  Seward, 
Secretary  of  state,  in  answer  to  one  from  him  on  the  reso- 
lution of  the  Senate  as  to  the  relations  of  the  United  States 
wdth  the  British  provinces,  and  the  actual  condition  of  the 
fisheries.  January,  1867. 
Washington,  D.  C,  1867.     {8),  50,  {2),  2^5  pp.     8°. 

A  reprint  of  Senate  executive  document  no.  30,  39th  Congress,  2d 
session,  issued  in  1867,  under  title:  Message  from  the  President 
.  .  .  communicating  .  .  .  information  relative  to  the  practica- 
bility of  establishing  equal  reciprocal  relations  between  the 
United  States  and  the  British  North  American  provinces.  .  . 
Includes  (pp.  1-84)  a  reprint  of  "A  preliminary  report  on  the 
treaty  of  reciprocity  with  Great  Britain  .  .  .  Prepared  by  E.  H. 
Derby  .  .  .  Washington,  D.  C:  Treasury  department,  1866." 

Detroit  board  of  commerce.  International  commerce  of  North 
America,  Statement  showing  correlation  and  mutuality 
of  interest  between  Canada  and  the  United  States,  and 
considerations  in  advocacy  of  a  new  commercial  treaty. 
Submitted  by  the  committee  on  international  commerce. 
[Detroit]:  Detroit  hoard  of  commerce,  190 4.    15,  (1)  pp-     8°. 

E!dm.unds,   George  F.     Canadian  reciprocity  treaty.     Remarks  in 
the  Senate  of  the  United  States,  January  22,  1875. 
Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1875.     6  pp.     8°. 

Elgin,  James  Bruce,  8tTi  earl   of.      Letters   and  journals.     Ed.  by 
Theodore  Walrond. 
London:  J.  Murray,  1872.     xii,  467  pp.     8°. 
"Reciprocity":  pp.  102-109. 

Hy,  Alfred.    The  reciprocity  treaty.    Speech  delivered  in  the  House 
of  representatives,  June  15,  1860. 
Washington:  Printed  hy  L.  Towers,  1860.     16  pp.     8°. 

Foss,  Eugene  Noble.     Trade  relations  between  the  LTnited  States  and 
Canada,  with  some  words  of  recognition  also  of  the  value 
of  our  trade  with  the  British  empire. 
Boston:  Issued  hy  the  New  England  reciprocity  league,  [1904]. 
[15]  pp.     8°.     (Bulletin  no.  2.     1904.) 

From  a  series  of  addresses  before  the  Canadian  club  of  Boston. 


EECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA:    BOOKS  69 

Foster,  G.  E.     Preferential  tariffs  and  reciprocity. 

{In  American  economic  association.    Publications,  3d  ser.,  vol.  6, 

May,  1905,  pp.  323-335.     New  York,  1905.     8°.) 
From  a  Canadian  standpoint. 

Foster,  John  W.     A  century  of  American  diplomacy;  being  a  brief 
review  of  the  foreign  rehitions  of  the  United  States,  1776- 
1876. 
Boston  and   New    York:  Houghton,    Mifflin  and  company, 
1900.     xiii,  {2),  497  pp.     8°. 

Canadian  reciprocity  treaty  of  1854:  pp.  337-339. 

Grant,  George.     Canada  first. 

(/n  Canadian  Club  of  New  York.      Canadian  leaves,  pp.  247-267. 
New  York,  1887.     8°.) 

Gray,  John   Hamilton.     Confederation;  or,  The  political  and   par- 
liamentary history  of  Canada,  from  the  conference   at 
Quebec,  in  October,   1864,   to  the  admission  of  British 
Columbia,  in  July,  1871. 
Toronto:  Copp,  Clarl  &  co.,  1872.     2  vols.     8°. 
Renewal  of  reciprocity  treaty:  vol.  1,  pp.  294-304. 

Grey,  Henry  George  Grey,  3d  earl.     The  commercial  polic}^  of  the 
British  colonies  and  the  McKinley  tariff. 
London  and  New  York:   Macmillan  and  co.,  1892.     79  pp. 

8°. 

Opposed  to  Canadian  reciprocity  with  the  United  States. 

Haliburton,   Robert   Grant.     American   protection    and   Canadian 
reciprocity. 

(In  Royal   colonial  institute.     Proceedings,  vol.  6,  pp.  205-227. 
London,  1875.     8°.) 

Harvey,  Arthur.     The    reciprocity    treaty:  its    advantages    to    the 
United  States  and  to  Canada. 
Quebec:  Printed  hy  Hunter,  Rose  d:  co.,  1865.     20  pp.     8°. 

Hatch,  Israel  T.     Reciprocity.     Speech  in  the  convention  at  Detroit, 
July  14,  1865. 
Buffalo:  Matthews  &  Warren,  1865. 

{In  Hayes,  J.  D.     "The  Niagara  ship  canal,"  pp.  47-58.     Buf- 
falo, 1865.     8°.) 

Hay,  Eugene  Gano.  Reciprocity  with  Canada;  report  of  Eugene  G. 
Hay,  to  the  advisory  board  of  the  Minnesota  branch  of  the 
National  reciprocity  league,  upon  the  present  attitude  of 
the  United  States  and  Canada  and  the  prospects  for  reci- 
procity between  the  two  countries. 
Minneapolis,  Minn.:  The  Minnesota  branch  of  the  National 
reciprocity  league^  \1903].     20  pp.     8°. 

Printed  also  in  National  reciprocity,  vol.  1,  Apr.  1903,  pp.  3-16. 


70  LIBRAEY   OF   COXGEESS 

Hayes,  Jolin  D.  "The  Niagara  ship  canal":  and  "Reciprocity": 
papers  wTitten  for  the  "Buffalo  commercial  advertiser;" 
together  with  the  speech  of  Hon.  Israel  T.  Hatch,  in  the 
convention  at  Detroit,  July  14,  1865. 

Matthews  cfc   Warren,  1865.     (£),  [5]-58  pp.     8°. 


Haynes,  Frederick  Emory.     The  reciprocity  treaty  with  Canada  of 
1854. 
[Baltimore]:  American  economic  association,  1892.     70   pp. 
8°.     {Publications  of  the  American  economic  association. 
[Monographs],     v.  7,  no.  6.) 

"  Principal  references  " :  pp.  69-70. 

Hill,  James  J.     Speech  [on  reciprocity  with  Canada]. 

( In  New  York.     Chamber  of  commerce.     Fifty-first  annual  report, 
for  the  year  1908-1909,  pp.  67-72.     New  York,  1909.     8°.) 

Hodgins,  Thomas.     British  and  American  diplomacy  affecting  Can- 
ada.    1782-1899.     A  chapter  of  Canadian  history. 
Toronto:  The  Publishers'  syndicate,  limited,  1900.     102,  (2)  pp. 
Maps.     8°. 

Home  market  club,  Boston.     The  revision  of  the  tariff.     By  Hon. 
Elihu  Root.     Reciprocity  with  Canada  and  affairs  in  the 
Philippines.     By  Hon.   Henry  Cabot  Lodge.     Speeches 
before  the  Home  market  club,  April  2,  1903. 
Boston:  Home  marlet  club,  1903.     28  pp.     8°. 

Hopkins,  John  Castell,  ed.  Canada:  an  encyclopaedia  of  tbe  coun- 
try; the  Canadian  dominion  considered  in  its  historic  re- 
lations, its  natural  resources,  its  material  progress  and 
its  national  development,  by  a  corps  of  eminent  writers 
and  specialists. 
Toronto:  Linscott  pub.  co.,  [1898-99].  5  vols.  Illustrations. 
Maps.     Plans.     4°- 

"The  reciprocity  treaty  of  1854,  by  the  editor  ":  vol.  1,  pp.  336-368; 
Editor's  notes  on  reciprocity  and  trade  relations:  pp.  379-426. 

Howe,  Joseph.     The  reciprocity  treaty,  its  history,  general  features, 
and  commercial  results;  a  speech  delivered  at  the  great 
International  commercial  convention,  Detroit. 
Hamilton:  Pnnted  by  T.  &  R.  White,  1865.     15  pp.     8°. 

Howes,  Osborne.     Reciprocity  w4th  Canada. 

(In  U.  S.  Industrial  commission.     Report,  vol.  9,  pp.  712-718. 
Washington,  1901.     8°.) 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA:    BOOKS  71 

Jeans,  James  Stephen.     Canada's  resources  and  possibilities.     With 
special  reference  to  the  iron  and  allied  industries,  and  the 
increase  of  trade  with  the  mother  country. 
London:  Offices  of  the  British  iron  trade  association,  190 4. 
XV,  298  pp.     Frontispiece.     Illustrations.     Maps.     4°- 
"The  reciprocity  movement":   pp.  43-47. 

[Johnson,  Edwin  F.  ?]     The  reciprocity  treaty  with  England.     Its 
character,  and  our  duty  in  regard  to  it. 
[Washington,  1866.]     17  pp.     8°.  ^ 

Kelley,  "William  Darrah.     The  proposed  reciprocity  treaty:  an  ad- 
dress delivered  by  request  of  representatives  of  the  leading 
manufacturing  industries  of  the  United  States,   at  the 
Academy  of  music,  Philadelphia,  October  28,  1874. 
Philadelphia:  Collins,  printer,  1874-     35  pp.     8°. 

Lewis,  John.     George  Brown.     £d.  de  luxe. 

Toronto:  Morang  tfe  co.,  limited,  1906.     xv,  281  pp.     Frontis- 
piece (portrait).     8°.     {The  makers  of  Canada.) 
The  reciprocity  treaty  of  1874:  pp.  223-233. 

Moffett,  Samuel  Erasmus.     The  Americanization  of  Canada. 
[New  Yorl]  1907.     126  pp.     8°.    ~ 

Thesis  (ph.  d.) — Columbia  university. 
Bibliography:  pp.  120-124. 
"Trade  relations":  pp.  78-90. 

National  board  of  trade.     Action  in  favor  of  the  renewal  of  recip- 
rocal trade  with  Canada.     Milwaukee,  August,  1877. 
Boston:  J.  F.  Cotter  <&  co.,  printers,  1877.     11  pp.     8°. 

New  England  free  trade  league.  Reciprocity  with  Canada  a  mu- 
tual benefit  as  shown  from  both  American  and  Canadian 
standpoints  at  a  dinner  given  by  the  New  England  free 
trade  league,  March  16,  1901.     37  pp. 

{In  New  England  free  trade  league.     Tariff-trust  articles,  1900- 
1901.     Boston,  1901.     8°.)  . 

New  York.     Chamber  of  commerce  of  the  state  of  New  York. 
Report  of  the  select  committee  on  the  reciprocity  treaty, 
as  to  trade  between  the  British  North  American  prov- 
inces and  the  United  States  of  America. 
New  York:  J.   W.  Amerman,  printer,  1865.     72  pp.     8°. 

Oliphant,  Laurence.     Episodes  in  a  life  of  adventure,  or.  Moss  from 
a  rolling  stone. 
New  York:  Harper  cfc  brothers,  1887.     343  pp.     12°. 

Reciprocity  treaty  between  United  States  and  Canada:  pp.  36-47. 


72  LIBEAEY   OF   CONGEESS 

Oliphant,  Mrs.  Margaret  Oliphant  (Wilson).     Memoir  of  the  life  of 
Laurence  Oliphant  and  of  Alice  Oliphant,  his  wife. 
New  York:  Harper  d-  hrothers,  1891.     2  vols.     8°. 

Treaty  between  Canada  and  Tnited  States:  vol.  1,  pp.  106-132. 

Porritt,  Edward.     Sixty  years  of  protection  in  Canada,  1846-1907, 

where  industry  leans  on  the  politician. 

London:  MacmUlan  and  co.,  limited,  1908.    xii,  Jf.78  pp.     12°. 

"Reciprocity:  The  movement  for  the  Elgin-Marcy  treaty,  1846- 

1854  " :  pp.  79-118 ;  ' '  Reciprocity :  The  abrogation  of  the  treaty — 

1854-1866":  pp.  119-158;  "Reciprocity:  Overtures  by  Canada 

since  1866":  pp.  159-186. 

Robinson,  Chalfant.  A  history  of  two  reciprocity  treaties;  the 
treaty  with  Canada  in  1854,  the  treaty  with  the  Hawaiian 
Islands  in  1876,  with  a  chapter  on  the  treaty-making 
power  of  the  House  of  representatives. 
New  Haven:  The  Tuttle,  Morehouse  c&  Taylor  press,  1904- 
220  pp.  Map.  Table.  Diagrams.  8°. 
Each  treaty  is  followed  by  a  bibliography. 

Smith,  Gerrit.  Letter  to  Senator  Hamlin,  on  the  reciprocity  treaty. 
July  17,  1854. 

{In  Smith,   Gerrit.     Speeches   in   Congress,  pp.   315-334.     New 
York,  1855.     12°.) 

Smith,  Goldwin.     Canada  and  the  Canadian  question. 

London  &  New  York:  MacmUlan  and  co.,  1891 .     325  pp.     8°. 
Reciprocity:  pp.  281-301. 

Review,  by  Robert  Brown,  in  Academy,  vol.  39,  Apr.  11,  1891, 
pp.  339-340. 

Sumner,  Charles.  Termination  of  the  Canadian  reciprocity  treaty. 
Speeches  in  the  Senate  on  the  joint  resolution  for  the  ter- 
mination of  the  Canadian  reciprocity  treaty. 

{In  Ms  Works,  vol.  12,  pp.  46-59.     Boston,  1900.     8°.) 

Tuck,  Amos.     Speech  on  the  New  England  fisheries,  reciprocal  trade 
with  the  British  North  American  provinces,  and  the  free 
navigation  of  the  St.  Lawrence,  delivered  in  the  House  of 
representatives,  August  27,  1852. 
Washington:  Printed  hy  L.  Towers,  1852.     2 4  pp.     8°. 

Ward,  Elijah.     Speeches  on  commercial,  financial,  and  other  sub- 
jects. 
NewYorJc:  G.W.Carletondb  co.,1877.    320  pp.    PoHrait.    8°. 
Our  commercial  relations  with  the  British  North  American  prov- 
inces.    Speeches  in  the  House  of  representatives.  May  18,  1864, 
and  May  26,  1864,  May  18,  1876,  and  Feb.  1,  1877:  pp.  59-99, 
124-182. 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   CANADA:    BOOKS  73 

Watkin,  Sir  Edward  W.     Canada  and  the  States.     Recollections, 
1851  to  1SS6. 
London,  New  Yorlc:    Ward,  Lock  and  co.,  [18S7].     xvi,     524 
pp.     Portrait.     Folded  maps.     12°. 

"The  reciprocity  treaty  with  the  United  States":  pp.  374^30. 

Willison,  John  Stephen.     Sir  Wilfrid  Laurier  and  the  Liberal  party; 
a  political  history. 
London:  J  .Murray,  1903.   2vols.    Frontispiece  {portrait).    8°. 
Commercial  relations:  vol.  2:  pp.  119-150;  The  reciprocity  cam- 
paign: pp.  151-185. 

Wiman,  Erastus.     The  advantages  of  commercial  union  to  Canada 
and  the  United  States. 

{In  Canadian  club  oi  New  York.     Canadian  leaves,  pp.  269-281. 
New  York,  1887.     8°.) 


ARTICLES   IN    PERIODICALS 

1852.  Commercial  intercourse  with  British  America. 

North  American  review,  vol.  7 4  {Jan.,  1852):  168-197. 

1853.  Reciprocity  with  the  British  provinces. 

Hunt's  merchants'  magazine,  vol.  28  {Mar.,  1853):  275-288. 

1853.  What  is  fair  and  equal  reciprocity?     J.  McCord. 

De  Bow's  review,  vol.  15  {Nov.,  1853):  433-U7. 

1854.  The  reciprocity  treaty. 

North  American  review,  vol.  79  {Oct.,  185 If):  1^61^-1^85. 

1861.     Reciprocity:  United  States  and  Canada. 

Hunt's  merchants'  magazine,  vol.  J^lf.  {Feh.,  1861):  160-173. 
A  report  from  the  Committee  of  the  Oswego  Board  of  trade  in  favor 
of  the  reciprocity  treaty 

1873.  A  North  American  zoUverein.     Charles  Lindsey. 

Canadian  monthly  and  national  review,  vol.  1   {Feb.,  1872): 
132-136. 

1872.     Our  commercial  relations  with  the  United  States.     J.  McL. 

Canadian  monthly  and  national  review,  vol.  1  {Mar.,  1872): 
214-218. 

1874.  Reciprocity  with  Canada.     R.  E.  T. 

Penn  monthly,  vol.  5  {July,  1874):  529-534. 

1874.     The  reciprocity  treaty  [of  1854] — how  it  was  annulled. 
Republic,  vol.  3  {Sept.,  1874):  158-160. 

1880.     Relations  of  Canada  with  the  United  States.     F.  Hincks. 
North  American  review,  vol.  130  {Apr.,  1880):  338-355. 

1880.     Commercial  union  with  the  United  States.     Arch.  McGoun. 
Canadian  monthly  and  national  review,  vol.  18  {July,  1880): 
1-11. 

1880.     Canada  and  the  United  States.     Goldwin  Smith. 

North  American  review,  vol.  131  {July,  1880):  14-25. 
74 


EECTPROCITV    Willi    CANADA:   PERIODICALS  75 

1880.  The  future  of  the  Canadian  Dominion.     George  Anderson. 

Contemporary  review,  vol.  38  {Sept.,  1880):  396-411. 

1881.  Commercial  union  from  a  Canadian  point  of  view.     F.  Ilincks. 

Fortni(jUlij  review,  n.  s.  vol.  29  {May,  1881):  618-633. 

1887.  Commercial  union  between  the  United  States  and  Canada:  a 

discussion. 
American  {Philadelphia),  vol.  13  {Apr.  9,  1887):  393-394; 
{Apr.  16,  1887):  407-409;  {May  14,  1887):  56-57;  {May 
21,  1887):  74-75. 

Letters  from  Goldvrin  Smith,  J.  W.  Longley,  Robert  R.  Ilitt, 
R.  W.  Townshend,  and  Addison  F.  Browne. 

1888.  Canada.     Reciprocity,  or  commercial  union.    Prosper  Bender. 

Magazine  of  American  history,  vol.  19  {Jan.,  1888):  21-27. 

1888.     Commercial  union  between  the  United  States  and  Canada. 
John  Hamilton  Gray. 
Overland  monthly,  2d  ser.,  vol.  11  {Feb.,  1888):  186-159. 

1888.  Commercial  union.     Goldwin  Smith. 

Independent,  vol.  40  {July  12,  1888):  874-875. 

Reprinted  in  Our  day,  vol.  2,  Aug.,  1888,  pp.  111-115. 

1889.  The  relations  of  the  United  States  and  Canada.     A  Canadian 

view.     Charles  H.  Lugrin.  ■ 
Century  magazine,  n.  s.,  vol.  16  {June,  1889):  236-244- 

1889.  What  is  the  destiny  of  Canada?     Erastus  Wiman. 

North  American  review,  vol.  I48  {June,  1889):  665-675. 

An  argument  for  the  commercial  union  of  Canada  and  the  United 

States. 

1890.  A  commercial  union  with  Canada.     L.  E.  Munson. 

New  Englander,  vol.  53  {July,  1890):  1-13. 

1891.  Canadian   reciprocity  within   the  Union — not   "free   trade" 

and  false  pretences.     Joseph  Sheldon. 
New  Englander,  vol.  54  {June,  1891):  543-559. 

1891.  "Reciprocity"  and  Canada.     William  H.  Hurlbert. 

North  American  review,  vol.  153  {Oct.,  1891):  468-48O. 

1892,  Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Erastus  Wiman. 

Engineering  magazine,  vol.  4  {Oct.,  1892):  109-114- 

1892.     Benefits  of  Canadian  reciprocity.     Erastus  Wiman. 
Engineering  magazine,  vol.  4  {Dec,  1892):  337-344- 


76  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

1893.     Canada  and  our  new  tariff.     Erastus  Wiman. 

Engineering  magazine ,  vol.  6  {Nov.,  1893):  125-133. 

1897.     Reciprocity    trips    to    Washington.     A   page    from    political 
history.     Arthur  H.  U.  Colquhoun. 
Canadian  magazine,  vol.  8  {Mar.,  1897):  423-^29. 

1897.     Our  trade  relations  with  Canada.     John  W.  Russell. 

Nortli  American  review,  vol.  164  {June,  1897):  710-718. 

1897.     American  trade  relations.     John  Charlton. 

Canadian  magazine,  vol.  9  {Oct.,  1897):  602-506. 

1897.  Canada  and  the  Dingley  bill,     John  Charlton. 

North  American  review,  vol.  165  {Oct.,  1897):  4I 8-430. 

1898.  British  and  American  diplomacy  affecting  Canada.     Thomas 

Hodgins. 
Canadian  magazine,  vol.  10  {Mar.,  1898):  379-389. 

1899.  Commercial  relations  between  Canada  and  the  United  States. 

Robert  McConnell. 
Canadian  magazine,  vol.  12  {Jan.,  1899):  198-201. 

1899.     An  open  door  with  Canada.     Erastus  Wiman. 

Anglo-American  magazine,  vol.  1  {Apr.,  1899):  292-297. 

1899.     Is  the  United  States  a  good  neighbor  to  Canada?     Edward 
Porritt. 
New  England  magazine,  n.  s.,  vol.  20  {Aug.  1899):   731-736. 

1899.  The  United  States  and  Canada.     L.  E.  Munson. 

Arena,  vol.  22  {Bee,  1899):  667-682. 

1900.  American  and  Canadian  trade  relations.     John  Charlton. 

Eorum,,  vol.  29  {June,  1900):  47I-48O. 

1901.  Reciprocity    and    the    British    North    American    fisheries. 

D.  W.  Prowse. 

Nation,  vol.  72  {Jan.  10,  1901):  29-30. 

1901.     Our  relations  with  Canada.     J.  D.  Whelpley. 
World's  worl,  vol.  2  {July,  1901):  942-944. 

1901.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     [Philadelphia  Press,  Sept.  2.] 
Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Oct.,  1901):  340-342. 

1901.     Trade  relations  between  Canada  and  the  United  States. 
Economist  {London),  vol.  59  {Nov.  9,  1901):  1654-1655. 


EECIPROCITY    WTTII    CANADA:   PERIODICALS  77 

1901.     Commercial  reciprocity  with  Camula.     John  W.  Foster. 
Independent,  vol.  53  {Dec.  5,  1901):  287^-2877. 

1901.  Canadian  reciprocity. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Dec,  1901):  U9-450. 

1902      The  reciprocity  of  to-day.     Arthur  11.  U.  Colquhoim. 

Canadian  magazine,  vol.  18  {Jan.,  1902):  226-228. 

1902.  Reciprocity  with  Canada.     John  Charlton. 

Forum,  vol.  32  {Jan.,  1902):  582-593. 

1902      Recii)rocity  with  Canada.     Albert  Clarke. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Feb.,  1902):  553-563. 

1902      Reciprocity  of  trade  with  Canada.     John  Charlton. 
Independent,  vol.  54  {Mar.  20,  1902):  667-671. 

1902.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Albert  Clarke. 
Protectionist,  vol.  H  {May,  1902):  27-28. 

1902      The  United  States  and  Canada.     John  Charlton. 

Independent,  vol.  5J,  {July  17,  1902):  1711-1715. 

1902      Reciprocity  with  Canada.     John  Charlton. 

Outlool:,  vol.  72  {Sept.  27,  1902):  209-212. 

1902.     Reciprocity  in  general;  reciprocity  with  Newfoundland;  and 
then  with  the  Dominion! 
American  monthlij  review  of  reviews,  vol.  26   {Oct.,  1902): 
392-394. 

1902.     Reciprocity  versus  repression.     John  Charlton. 
National  reciprocity,  vol.  1  {Oct.,  1902):  3-14- 

1902.     [Canadian  reciprocity  from  the  New  England  point  of  view.] 

E.  N.  Foss. 
National  reciprocity,  vol.  1  {Dec,  1902):  32-38. 

1902.  [Canadian  reciprocity.]     John  Lind. 

National  reciprocity ,  vol.  1  {Dec,  1902):  42-48. 

1903.  The  growth  of  reciprocity  sentiment.     John  Charlton. 

OutlooTc,  vol.  73  {Feb.  28,  1903):  483-488. 

Reprinted  in  National  reciprocity,  vol.  1,  Mar.,  1903,  pp.  9-15. 

1903.     Reciprocity  between  the  United  States  and  Canada.     J.  W. 
Longley. 
North  American  review,  vol.  176  {Mar.,  1903):  4O 1-409. 

Reprinted  in  National  reciprocity,  vol.  1,  Mar.,  1903,  pp.  23-29. 

2730G°— 10 6  \ 


78  LIBRAEY   OF    CONGRESS 

1903.     Canada's  growing  commercial  indepenctence.    Erastus  Wiman. 
North  American  review,  vol.  176  {April,  1903):  602-609. 

1903.     Speech  of  William  E.  Brigham,  secretary  of  the  New  England 
reciprocity  league,  at  Boston,  Mass.,  April  29,  1903. 
National  reciprocity ,  vol.  1  {May,  1903):  1-8. 

1903.     Speech  of  John  Charlton.     Preferential  trade  with  Great  Brit- 
ain— reciprocity  with  the  United  States. 
National  reciprocity ,  vol.  1  {May,  1903):  9-36. 

1903.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Albert  Clarke. 

Protectionist,  vol.  15  {July,  1903):  827-828. 

1903.     The  future  of  Canada  and  reciprocity  with  the  United  States. 
Eugene  G.  Hay. 
American  montTily  review  of  reviews,  vol.  28   {Oct.,  1903^: 
462-466. 

1903.  Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Foss  and  Clarke  before  the  Maine 

state  board  of  trade. 
Protectionist,  vol.  15  {Oct.,  1903):  1013-1029. 

1904.  The    Canadian    reciprocity    question:    and    incidentally    the 

future  of  Canada.     Albert  Clarke. 
Protectionist,  vol.  15  {Jan.,  1904):  1174-1176. 

1904.     The  tariff  as  an  issue:  Secretary  Shaw  opposes  reciprocity 
with  Canada  in  competitive  products. 
American  economist,  vol.  33  {Feb.  26,  1904):  98-99. 

1904.     Strong  light  on  the  question  of  Canadian  reciprocity. 
American  economist,  vol.  33  {Feb.  26,  1904):  100-101. 

1904.     In  natural  products  only:  how  that  kind  of  reciprocity  with 
Canada  would  affect  our  farmers.     A.  J.  Volstead. 
American  economist,  vol.  33  {Feb.  26,  1904):  IO4-IO6. 

1904.     Canada  and  reciprocity.     John  Charlton. 

North  American  review,  vol.  178  {Feb.,  1904):  205-215. 

1904.     Canadian  reciprocity. 

Protectionist,  vol.  15  {Feb.,  1904):  1217-1223. 

1904.     Republican  reciprocity  defined  from  the  speech  of  John  Dal- 
zell,  Feb.  29,  1904. 
American  economist,  vol.  33  {Mar.  11,  1904):  121,128-132. 

1904.     Commercial  reciprocity  with  Canada.     Charles  A.  Moore. 
American  economist,  vol.  33  {Apr.  29,  1904):  212-213. 


EECIPROCITY   WITH    CANADA  :   PERIODICALS  79 

1904.     Keciprocity  in  Canada.     Joseph  Howe  Dickson. 

National  magazine  {Boston),  vol.  20  {Apr.,  1904):  49-51. 

1904.     Trading  with  CanacUi. 

Nation,  vol.  78  {May  5,  1904):  345-346. 

1904.     Some  aspects  of  the  trade  with  Canada.     Edward  Stanwood. 
National  association  of  wool  naanufacturers.     Bulletin,  vol.  34 
{June,  1904):  109-115. 

1904.     It  is  not  needed.     How  our  trade  with  Canada  has  increased 
without  the  aid  of  reciprocity.     Walter  J.  Ballard. 
American  economist,  vol.  34  {July  1,  1904):  11-12. 

1904.     Lodge  on  reciprocity:  convincing  reasons  for  opposition  to 
the  proposed  Newfoundland  treaty. 
American  economist,  vol.  34  {Aug.  19,  1904):  92-94- 

1904.     Massachusetts  and  Canadian  reciprocity. 

American  economist,  vol.  34  {Aug.  26,  1904):  101-102. 

1904.     Reciprocity  with  Canada:  its  impossibilit}^  demonstrated  by 
past  experiences  and  also  by  existing  conditions.     John 
Bruce  McPherson. 
American  economist,  vol.  34  {Aug.  26,  1904):  IO4-IO8,  Hi. 

1904.     Reciprocity  with  the  United  States:  a  symposium.     Camp- 
bell Shaw,  Theo.  M.  Knappen,  Nathaniel  French,  E,  N. 
Foss,  Solomon  Bulkley  Griffin,  Eugene  G.  Hay. 
Canadian  magazine,  vol.  23  {Sept.,  1904):  407-415. 

1904.     United   States  ideas   of  reciprocity   with   references   to   the 
recently  adopted  platforms  of  the  two  parties.     Charles  H. 
Mclntyre. 
Canadian  magazine,  vol.  23  {SejJt.,  1904):  4^(^-4^^- 

1904.     Reciprocity  with  Canada  as  suggested  by  the  Boston  com- 
mittee of  one  hundred.     J.  B.  McPherson. 
National  association  of  wool  manufacturers.     Bulletin,  vol. 
34  {Sept.,  1904):  227-251. 

1904.     Looks  to  British  market:  Canada  opposed  to  reciprocity  with 
the  United  States.     Sir  Howard  Vincent. 
American  economist,  vol.  34  {Oct.  I4,  1904):  182-183. 

1904.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     [Editorial.] 

Independent,  vol.  57  {Dec.  1,  1904):  1278-1282. 

"Neither  the  commercial  nor  the  political  relations  of  the  two 
countries  can  ever  be  too  intimate  for  the  good  of  both." 


80  LIBRAEY   OF   CONGRESS 

1904.  La  politique  fiscale  de  M.  Chamberlain  au  Canada  et  aux 

Etats-Unis.     Sir  Howard  Vincent. 
Revue  economique  intemationale,  vol.  3  (Dec,  1904):  813-820. 

1905.  Future  relations  with  Canada.     W.  L.  R.  Emmett. 

Harper's  weeJcly,  vol.  49  (Jan.  21,  1906):  84. 

1905.     Canada  and  the  United  States:  ftdvantages  of  reciprocity. 

American  monthly  review  of  reviews,  vol.  31    (Feb.,   1905): 
134-136. 

1905.     Commercial  union  with  Canada. 

Protectionist,  vol.  17  {May,  1905):  1-6. 

1905.  Reciprocity  with  Canada  is  a  dead  question  and  does  not  now 

interest  the  Canadian  people.     A.  T.  Freed. 
American  economist,  vol.  36  {Oct.  6,  1905):  164-165. 

1906.  Canada's  trade  policy;  a  free  trader's  view.     James  A.  Hob- 

son. 
Canadian  magazine,  vol.  26  {Mar.,  1906):  423-425. 

1906.     Canadian  reciprocit}^.     James  J.  Hill. 

Inter-nation,  n.  s.  vol.  1  {Aj^r.,  1906):  39-40. 

1906.     Canada's  tariff  mood  towards  the  United   States.     Edward 
Porritt. 
North  American  review,  vol.  182  {A2)r.,  1906):  565-578. 

1906.     Reciprocity  renascent.     M.  H.  Nickerson. 

Inter-nation,  n.  s.,  vol.  1  {May,  1906):  88-90. 

1906.  Reciprocity  with  the  Dominion.     James  J.  Hill's  remarkable 

plea  for  the  open  door  with  Canada,  delivered  before  the 
Merchants'  club,  of  Chicago,  November  10. 
The  Commercial  West,  vol.  10  {Nov.  17,  1906):  38-39. 

1907.  The    new    Canadian    tariff.     Analysis    by    the    Chamberlain 

commission. 
Canadian  gazette,  vol.  48  {Jan.  24,  1907):  397-399. 

1907.     Leslie  M.  Shaw  on  reciprocity. 

American  economist,  vol.  39  {May  24,  1907):  242-243. 

"Address  [in  part]  before  the  Canadian  society  in  New  York." 

1907.     The  two  great  American  issues.     Henry  M.  Whitney. 
Inter-nation,  n.  s.,  vol.  1  {May,  1907):  40-50. 

On  reciprocity  with  Canada  and  jailroad  legislation. 


RECIPROCITY  WITH    CANADA:  PERIODICALS  81 

1907.     The   relations    of   Canada    and    the   United    States.     P.    T. 
M'Grath. 

American  montJily  review  of  reviews,  vol.  35  {June,  1907): 
717-724. 

1907.     The  Canadian  tariff  revision.     A.  W.  Fhix. 

Economic  journal,  vol.  17  {June,  1907):  276-283. 

"As  to  the  prospect  of  reciprocity  between  Canada  and  the  United 
States,  the  immediate  future  seems  to  promise  little  definite 
movement." 

1909.     How    Canada    looks    at    American    tariff-making.     Andrew 
Macphail. 
American  review  of  reviews,  vol.  39  {Jan.,  1909):  86-87. 

1909.     Between  Ottawa  and  Washington. 

Canadian  gazette,  vol.  53  {May  6,  1909):  132-133. 

On  reciprocal  tariff  arrangements  between  Canada  and  the  United 

States. 

1909.     Canada  and  the  Payne  bill.     Edward  Porritt. 

North  American  review,  vol.  189  {May,  1909):  688-694. 

1909.  Give  and  take  with  Canada.     Arthur  Hawkes. 

Pearson's  magazine,  vol.  22  {Sejd.,  1909):  361-368. 

1910.  The  Washington  wooing ;  [effort  to  obtain  a  general  reciprocity 

treaty  between  the  United  States  and  Canada]. 
Canadian  gazette,  vol.  55  {Apr.  7,  1910):  12-13. 

1910.     The  tariff  negotiations.     Statement  by  Mr.  Fielding  in  [the 
Canadian]  Parliament. 
Canadian  gazette,  vol.  55  {Apr.  14,  1910):  38-39. 

1910.     Thoughts  from  New  York  [on  reciprocity  between  the  United 
States  and  Canada]. 
Canadian  gazette,  vol.  55  {June  2,  1910):  264-265. 

1910.     Great  Britain,  Canada,  and  the  United  States.     Compatriot. 
National  review,  vol.  55  {July,  1910):  786-795. 

Regarding  the  movement  for  a  new  treaty  of  reciprocity  between 

Canada  and  the  United  States. 
Reprinted  in  Living  age,  Aug.  6,  1910,  vol.  2G6,  pp.  323-329. 

1910.     Reciprocity  with  Canada.     Henry  M.  Whitney. 
Atlantic  monthly,  vol.  106  {Oct.  1910):  46I-468. 


RECIPROCITY  WITH    HAWAII 

UNITED  STATES   DOCUMENTS 

1867.     Message  of  the  President,  communicating  a  report  from  the 
Secretary  of  the  Treasury  in  relation  to  a  treaty  of  com- 
mercial reciprocity  with  the  Hawaiian  Islands.     Feb.  6, 
1867.     5  pp.     8°. 
S9th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  20.  1277 

1867.  [Report  by  Mr.  Sumner  from]  the  Committee  on  foreign  rela- 
tions, to  whom  was  referred  the  convention  for  commercial 
reciprocity  between  the  United  States  and  His  Majesty 
the  King  of  the  Hawaiian  Islands,  concluded  at  the  city 
of  San  Francisco  the  21st  of  May,  1867.  Dec.  17,  1867. 
j^Oth  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  executive  F.  4054 

{In  U.  S.  Senate.  Compilation  of  reports  of  the  Committee  on  for- 
eign relations,  vol.  8,  pp.  145-160.  Washington,  1901.  8°. 
56th  Congress,  2d  session,  Senate  doc.  no.  231,  part  8.) 

1875.  United  States.     Treaties,  etc.,  1869-1877  {Grant).    Hawaiian 

islands  —  commercial  reciprocity.  Convention  between 
the  United  States  of  America  and  His  Majesty  the  King 
of  the  Hawaiian  Islands.  Commercial  reciprocity.  Con- 
cluded January  30,  1875.  Proclaimed  June  3,  1875. 
[Washington:  Government  printing  office,  1875.]  4  pp. 
8°. 

1876,  Hawaiian  treaty.     Report  from  the  Committee  on  wa3's  and 

means.     Feb.  24,  1876.     12  pp.     8°. 
Jj-Jfth  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  116.  1708 

1876.     Same.     The  views  of  the  minority.     6  pp.     8°. 

44th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  116,  part  2. 

1708 

1876.     Debates  in  the  House  and  Senate  on  the  Hawaiian  reciprocity 
treaty. 

Congressional  record,  44th  Congress,  1st  session,  vol.  4,  1876 
{March  2):  1 419-1 426;  {March  4):  I46O-I465;  {March 
6):  1488-1498;  {March  9):  1596-1604;  {Apr.  6):  2270- 
2281;  {Maxj8):  3031-3037;  {Aug.  12):  5485-5491,5522- 
5524,  5533-5535^  {Aug.  I4):  5563-5572. 

83 


84  LIBRARY   OF    CONGRESS 

1876.  By  the  President  of  the  United  States,  a  proclamation  [pro- 
mulgating the  reciprocity  treaty  between  the  United 
States  and  Hawaii].     Sept.  9,  1876. 

{In  United  States.  Statutes  at  large,  vol.  19,  pp.  666-667.  Wash- 
ington, 1877.     4°.) 

1878.  *United  States.  Treasury  dspartment.  Report  of  James 
Scott,  United  States  consul  at  Honolulu,  relating  to  the 
effect  of  the  reciprocity  treaty  between  Hawaii  and  the 
United  States,  made  under  instruction  from  the  Treasury 
department,  [n.  p.,  1878]  12  pp.  8°. 
In  Library  of  Department  of  state. 

1883.     Treaty  with  Hawaiian  Islands.     Report  from  the  Committee 
on  foreign  affairs.     Jan.  16,  1883.     2  pp.     8°. 
47th  Congress,  Sd  session.     House  report  no.  1860,  pt.  1.    2159 

1883.     Hawaiian  treaty.     Report  from  the  Committee  on  foreign 
affairs.     Views  of  the  minority.     Jan.  29,  1883.     10  pp. 
8°. 
JfJih  Congress,  2d  session.    House  report  no.  1860,  pt.  2.     2159 

1883.  Report  from  the  Committee  on  finance,  to  whom  was  referred 

the  joint  resolution  (S.  res.  122)  providing  for  the  termina- 
tion of  the  reciprocity  treaty  of  January  30,  1875,  between 
the  United  States  of  America  and  His  IMajesty  the  King 
of  the  Hawaiian  Islands.     Feb.  27,  1883.     8  pp.     8°. 
47 th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  report  no.  1013.  2008 

Views  of  the  minority:  pp.  7-8. 

1884.  Report  from  the  Committee  on  foreign  relations  [on  the  ter- 

mination of  the  Hawaiian  treaty].     Jan.  24,  1884.     9  pp. 
8°. 
48th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  report  no.  76.  2173 

Report  presented  by  Senator  Morgan. 

"Whatever  objections  have  so  far  been  found  to  the  workings  or 
the  results  of  this  treaty  are  greatly  overbalanced  by  the  advan- 
tages we  have  acquired  in  a  national  sense;  and  by  the  benefits 
to  our  people  of  a  profitable  trade  with  the  Hawaiian  people;  and 
by  the  duty  we  owe  the  people  of  both  countries  to  give  certainty 
and  permanence  to  the  gratifying  prosperity  which  this  treaty 
has  created." 

1884.     Views  of  the  minority  [of  the  Committee  on  foreign  relations 
on  the  termination  of  the  Hawaiian  treaty].     Jan  24, 
1884.     5  pp.     8°. 
48th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  report  no.  76,  part  2.     2173 
Report  presented  by  Senator  Sherman  and  includes  the  majority 
report  of  the  Committee  on  finance,  Feb.  27,  1883.     (47th  Con- 
gress, 2d  session.     Senate  report  no.  1013.) 

*  Not  in  Library  of  Congress. 


RECIPROCITY    WITH    HAWAII:    U.    S.   DOCUMENTS  85 

1884.  Report  by  Mr.  Miller,  of  California,  from  the  Committee  on 
foreign  relations,  to  whom  was  referred  the  report  of  the 
Secretary  of  state  communicating  the  proposal  of  the  King 
of  Hawaii  for  the  extension  of  the  duration  of  the  existing 
reciprocity  treaty  with  the  United  States.  June  19,  1884. 
/i.8th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  executive  M.  4054 

(/n  U.  S.  Senate.  Compilation  of  reports  of  the  Committee  on  for- 
eign relations,  vol.  8,  pp.  242-243.  Washington,  1901.  8°. 
56th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  231,  part  8.) 

1886.  Notice  to  terminate  the  convention  of  June  3,  1875,  with  the 

King  of  the  Hawaiian  Islands.     Report  from  the  Com- 
mittee on  ways  and  means.     Apr.  20,  1886.     36,  (1)  pp. 
8°. 
49th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1759.  2440 

Includes  tables  of  statistics  of  commerce  with  the  Hawaiian  Islands, 
1871-1885. 

1887.  Hawaiian  treaty.     Message  from  the  President,  transmitting 

a  report  from  the  Secretary  of  state,  with  accompanying 
resolutions,   relating  to  the  treaty  between  the  United 
States    and    the   government   of   the   Hawaiian  Islands. 
Feb.  1,  1887.     4  pp.     8°. 
49th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  130.  2482 

1887.     Treaty  with  the  Hawaiian  Islands.     Report  from  the  Com- 
mittee on  the  judiciary.     Mar.  3,  1887.     23  pp.     8°. 
49th  Congress,  2d  session.     House  report  no.  4177.  2501 

This  report  was  drawn  up  by  John  Randolph  Tucker  and  Ls  an  ex- 
position of  the  treaty-making  power  as  established  by  the  Con- 
stitution and  by  precedent. 

1887.  Report  of  the  Committee  on  foreign  relations  on  resolution 
submitted  in  executive  session,  December  19,  1887,  calling 
for  copies  of  ofHcial  correspondence  concerning  the  ratifi- 
cation of  the  treaty  between  the  United  States  and  the 
Hawaiian  Islands,  from  which  the  injunction  of  secrecy 
was  removed.  Feb.  24,  1888.  5  pp.  8°. 
60th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  misc.  doc.  no.  64.         2516 

1891.     Reciprocity  with  the  Hawaiian  Islands.     Report  from  the 
Committee  on  ways  and  means.     Jan.  13,  1891.     1  page. 
8°. 
61st  Congress,  2d  session.     House  report  no.  3422.         2885 

1891.     Debate  in  the  House  and  Senate  on  Bill  (H.  R.  12333),  pro- 
viding that  no  sections  of  the  McKinley  act  of  1890  should 
be  construed  as  abrogating  the  treaty  with  Hawaii. 
Congressional  records,  61st  Congress,  2d  session,  vol.  22  {Feb. 
6,  1891):  2262-2263;  {Feb.  28,  1891):  3616-3621. 


86  LIBEAEY   OF    CONGRESS 

1893.     Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  in  response 

to  Senate  resolution  of  February  4,  1893,  relative  to  the 

draft  of  an  uncompleted  treaty  with  Hawaii.     Feb.   6, 

1893.     14  pp.     8°. 

52d  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  Jf5.  3056 

1893.  Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States,  transmit- 

ting   correspondence    respecting    relations    between    the 

United  States,  and  the  Hawaiian  Islands  from  Sept.  1820, 

to  Jan.  1893.     Feb.  17,  1893.     192  pp.     8°. 

52d  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  77.  3062 

For  papers  relating  to  reciprocity  with  Hawaii  see  subject  index, 

p.  29. 
Reprinted  in  House  ex.  doc.  48,  53d  Congress,  2d  session. 

1894.  Report  from  the  [Senate]  Committee  on  foreign  relations  [on 

Hawaiian  affairs].     Feb.  26,  1894.     809  pp.     Maps.     8°. 
63d  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  report  no.  227.  3180. 

"The  Hawaiian  treaty.     A  review  of  its  commercial  results" 
pp.  103-113. 

1897.     Memorial  of  the  California  state  grange,  requesting  abroga- 
tion of  reciprocity  treaty  with  Hawaii.     Apr.  21,  1897. 
3  pp.     8°. 
55th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  4-8.  3561 

1897.     Petition  against  abrogation  of  treaty  between  United  States 
and  Hawaii.     Apr.  21,  1897.     4  pp.     8°. 
55th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  49.  3561 

"Signed  by  260  bankers,  merchants,  and  other  business  men." 

1897.  Importations  of  rice,  sugar,  and  molasses  from  Hawaiian 
Islands.  Table  showing  the  quantities  and  values  of  rice, 
sugar,  and  molasses  imported  into  the  United  States  from 
the  Hawaiian  Islands  since  the  reciprocity  treaty  went 
into  effect.  May  28,  1897.  2  pp.  8°. 
55th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  124.  3562 

1900.  Progress  of  the  beet-sugar  industr}^  in  the  United  States  in 

1899,  with   a  supplementary  report  on   the  cane-sugar 

industry  of  the  Hawaiian  Islands.     200  pp.     Maps.     8°. 

56th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc.  no.  699.  3985 

1901 .  Duty  on  coffee.    Letter  from  the  Secretary  of  the  interior  trans- 

mitting a  memorial  of  the  Legislature  of  Hawaii  relating 
to  a  duty  on  coffee.     Dec.  2,  1901.     2  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc.  no.  27.  4322 


RECIPEOCITY    WITH    HAWAII:   U.   S.   DOCUMENTS  87 

1903.     The    Hawaiian    labor    question — Reciprocit}^    with    Hawaii. 
Letter  from  Truman  G.  Palmer  to  Hon.  Henry  M.  Teller, 
chairman  of  the  Committee  on  private  land  claims.     Feb- 
ruary 25,  1903.     10  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  176.  4428 

1903.  History  of  Hawaiian  treaty  and  Cuban  reciprocity.  His- 
tory of  the  Hawaiian  treaty;  with  a  report  to  terminate 
the  treaty,  signed  by  Justin  S.  Morrill,  Daniel  Voorhees, 
and  Nelson  W.  Aldrich ;  also  a  history  of  the  agitation  for 
Cuban  reciprocity  with  the  United  States,  and  opinions 
as  to  the  probable  results  of  Cuban  reciprocit}^,  by  Charles 
H.  Dietrich.  Data  and  tables  compiled  by  Truman  G. 
Palmer.  March  2,  1903.  27  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  206.  4430 


BOOKS 

[Brown,    Henry    Alvin].     Revised    analyses    of    Hawaiian    treaty 
blunders.     And  the  profound  foreign  policy  humbug. 
[  Washington,  D.  C,  1887f]    8  pp.    8°. 

Addendum  no.  2  to  Analyses  of  Hawaiian  reciprocity  treaty 

blunders  (Depicted  to  Congress  Jan.  31,  Feb.  7,  1887). 
[Washington]:  J udd  &  Detweiler,  printers,  [1887].     8pp.    8°. 
Dated  Feb.  17,  1887. 

Callahan,  James  Morton.    American  relations  in  the  Pacific  and  the 
Far  East,  1781-1900. 
Baltimore:   The  Johns  HopJcins  press,  1901.     177  pp.     8°. 
(Johns    Hophins    university    studies    in    historical    and 
political  science,  series  19,  nos.  1-3.) 

"Americanization  of  Hawaii":  pp.  114-134. 

Carpenter,  Edmund  Janes.    America  in  Hawaii;  a  history  of  United 
States  influence  in  the  Hawaiian  Islands. 
Boston:  Small,    Maynard   &   company,   1899.     xi,  275  pp. 
Portraits.     12°. 

Hawaiian  almanac  and  annual. — The  reference  book  of  information 
and  statistics  relating  to  the  Hawaiian  Islands.     Thos.  G. 
Thrum,  comp.  and  pub. 
Honolulu:    T.  G.  Thrum,  1875-date.    8°. 

Heazelton,  George.    Review   of   the   objections    to    the   Hawaiian 
reciprocity  treaty. 
Washington,  D.  C:  Gibson  hros.,  printers,  1897.     7  pp.     8°. 

International  bureau  of  the  American  republics,  Washington, 
D.  C.     Hawaii. 

[Washington:    Government   printing   office,    1897.]      184   VV- 
Folded  map.     8°.     (Its  [Bulletin]  no.  85.    August,  1897.) 
"Historical   sketch.     Discovery  and  settlement  .  .  .     Relations 
with  the  United  United  States— annexation  treaties":   pp.  9-63. 
"Tariff  and  customs  regulations":  pp.  130-168. 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   HAWAII:    BOOKS 


89 


Robinson,  Chalfant.  A  history  of  two  reciprocity  treaties;  the 
treaty  with  Canada  in  1854,  the  treaty  with  the  Hawaiian 
Islands  in  1876,  with  a  chapter  on  the  treaty-making 
power  of  the  House  of  representatives. 
New  Haven:  The  Tuttle,  Morehouse  &  Taylor  press,  1904- 
220  pp.  Map.  Table.  Diagrams.  8°. 
Each  treaty  is  followed  by  a  bibliography. 

Searles,  John  Ennis,  jr.  A  few  facts  concerning  the  Hawaiian 
reciprocity  treaty,  by  John  E.  Searles,  jr.,  one  of  the 
commissioners  to  the  Sandwich  Islands  by  appointment 
of  the  Secretary  of  the  Treasury. 
WasUngton,  D.  C:  T.  McGill  &  co.,  law  printers,  [1886]. 
21,4  pp.  8°. 
Cover-title. 

Submitted  to  Hon.  Roger  Q.  Mills,  chairman  of  Subcommittee  on 
Hawaiian  treaty,  House  of  representatives,  ^^'ashington,  D.  C, 
Feb.  16,  1886. 
"Hawaiian  reciprocity  treaty":  pp.  1-3  at  end. 

Snow,  Freeman.    Treaties  and  topics  in  American  diplomacy. 

Boston:  Boston  hooJc  comp>any,  1894-     515  pp.     8°. 
The  Hawaiian  Islands:  pp.  361-397. 

Spalding,  Rufus  Paine.     A  bird's-eye  view  of  the  Hawaiian  Islands, 
with  some  reflections  upon  the  reciprocity  treaty  with 
the  United  States. 
Cleveland,  0.:  Leader  printing  company,  1882.     I4  pp.     8°. 

United  States.  Supreme  court.  Bartram  v.  Robertson.  Error 
to  the  Circuit  court  of  the  United  States  for  the  Southern 
district  of  New  York.  Argued  Apr.  29,  1887.— Decided 
May  23,  1887. 

(In  its  United  States  reports,  vol.  122,  pp.  116-121.     New  York, 

1887.  8°.) 
"The  provisions  in  the  treaty  of  friendship,  commerce,  and  navi- 
-gation  with  the  King  of  Denmark,  concluded  April  26,  1826, 
and  revived  by  the  convention  of  April  11,  1857,  do  not,  by 
their  own  operation,  authorize  the  importation,  duty  free  from 
Danish  dominions,  of  articles  made  duty  free  by  the  convention 
of  January  30,  1875,  with  the  King  of  the  Hawaiian  Islands,  but 
otherwise  subject  to  duty  by  a  law  of  Congress,  the  King  of  Den- 
mark not  having  allowed  to  the  United  States  the  compensation 
for  the  concession  which  was  allowed  by  the  King  of  the 
Hawaiian  Islands." 


90  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

United  States.  Supreme  court.  Wliitney  v.  Robertson.  Error 
to  the  Circuit  court  of  the  United  States  for  the  Southern 
district  of  New  York.  Argued  Dec.  13,  14,  1887.— 
Decided  Jan.  9,  1888. 

(In  its  United  States  reports,  vol.  124,  pp.  190-195.     New  York, 

1888.  8°.) 
"The  treaty  of  February  8,  1867,  with  the  Dominican  Republic 
(art.  9)  provides  that  'no  higher  or  other  duty  shall  be  imposed 
on  the  importation  into  the  United  States  of  any  article  the 
growth,  produce,  or  manufacture  of  the  Dominican  Republic 
.  .  .  than  are  or  shall  be  payable  on  the  like  articles  ...  of 
any  other  foreign  country'  .  .  .  The  convention  of  January 
30,  1875,  with  the  King  of  the  Hawaiian  Islands  provides  for 
the  importation  into  the  United  States,  free  of  duty,  of  various 
articles  .  .  .  (among  which  were  sugars,)  in  consideration  of 
certain  concessions  made  by  the  King  of  the  Hawaiian  Islands 
to  the  United  States.  Ileld,  that  this  provision  in  the  treaty 
with  the  Dominican  Republic  did  not  authorize  the  admission 
into  the  United  States,  duty  free,  of  similar  sugars,  the  growth, 
produce,  or  manufacture  of  that  republic,  as  a  consequence  of 
the  agreement  made  with  the  King  of  the  Hawaiian  Islands, 
and  that  there  was  no  distinction  in  principle  between  this 
case  and  Bartram  v.  Robertson,  122  U.  S.,  116." 


ARTICLES   IN   PERIODICALS 

1875.     Hawaiian  reciprocity  treaty. 

Penn  monthly ,  vol.  6  {June,  1S75):  1^25-1^27. 

1893.     Our  commercial  relations  with  the  Hawaiian  Islands.     Fred- 
erick R.  Clow. 
Journal  of  'political  economy,  vol.  1  {Mar.,  1893):  280-28 J^. 

1893.     The    Sandwich    Islands.     The    advantages    of    annexation. 
Lorrin  A.  Thurston. 
North  American  review,  vol.  156  {Mar.,  1893):  265-281. 

1893.     America  in  Hawaii.     The  strategic  position  of  the  islands, 
and  the  history  of  American  diplomacy  and  influence  in 
Hawaiian  affairs.     Sereno  Bishop. 
Review  of  reviews  {New  Yoric),  vol.  7  {Mar.,  1893):  180-185. 

1895.     Commercial  development  [of  the  Hawaiian  Islands].    Thomas 
G.  Thrum. 
Overland  monthly,  2d  ser.,  vol.  25  {June,  1895):  613-627. 

1898.     Hawaiian  annexation.     G.  E.  Belknap. 

Independent,  vol.  50  {Jan.  20,  1898):  7^-75. 

1898.     [Opposition  of  the  Sugar  trust  to  the  annexation  of  Hawaii.] 
Janet  Jennings. 
Independent,  vol.  50  {Jan.  20,  1898):  78-79. 

1902.     Our  trade  with  Hawaii  and  Porto  Rico.     O.  P.  Austin. 

American  academy  of  political  and  social  science.     Annals, 
vol.  19  {May,  1902):  377-382. 

1902.     Reciprocity  with  Hawaii.     Truman  G.  Palmer. 

American  economist,  vol.  30  {Nov.  28,  1902):  254- 

1902.     The  sugar  question  in  the  United  States.     Frank  R.  Rutter. 

Quarterly  journal  of  economics,  vol.  17  {Nov.,  1902):  44-^^- 
"  Hawaiian  sugar  " :  pp.  61-65. 

91 


RECIPROCITY   UNDER  THE   McKINLEY  ACT,  1890-1894 

UNITED  STATES  DOCUMENTS 

1890.     Reciprocity   treaties.     Resolution   from    the   Committee   on 
foreign  affairs.     April  12,  1890.     1  page.     8°. 
61st  Congress,  1st  session.     House  misc.  doc.  no.  193.         2776 

1890.     Reciprocity  treaties.     Report  from  the  Committee  on  foreign 
affairs.     May  1,  1890.     1  page.     8°. 
51st  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1827.  2812 

1890.  Reciprocity  treaties   with  Latin   America.     Message  of   the 

President  and  letter  of  the  Secretary  of  state  [J.  G.  Blaine], 
submitting   the   recommendations    of    the   International 
American  conference.     June  19,  1890.     13  pp.    8°. 
51st  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  158.  2688 

1891.  Letter  of  Secretary  of  state  [J.  G.  Blaine],  and  papers  relative 

to   the   commercial  arrangement  with  Brazil.     Feb.  27, 
1891.     9  pp.     8°. 
51st  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  66.  2818 

Consists  of  proclamation  on  reciprocity  with  Brazil,  with  preceding 
diplomatic  correspondence. 

1891.  Reciprocity  with  Spain.  By  the  President  of  the  United 
States. — A  proclamation.  July  31,  1891.  Preceding  cor- 
respondence [of  Secretary  Blaine  with  Senor  Suarez 
Guanes,  Spanish  minister.     Jan.  3-June  16,  1891]. 

{In  U.  S.  Bureau  of  foreign  commerce.  Reports  from  the  consuls 
of  the  United  States,  vol.  36,  July,  1891,  pp.  481-504.  Wash- 
ington, 1891.     8°.) 

1891.  United  States.     Department  of  state.    Papers  relating  to  the 

commercial  arrangement  between  the  United  States  of 
America  and  Salvador.  Concluded  December  30, 1891. — 
Proclaimed  December  31,  1891.     12  pp.     8°. 

1892.  Trade  between  United  States  and  the  Dominican  Republic 

and  Puerto  Rico.     Letter  from  the  Acting  Secretary  of  the 
Treasury.     Jan.  29,  1892.     2  pp.     8°. 
52d  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  106.  2954 

Statistics  of  trade  with  reciprocity  countries,  Brazil,  Cuba,  Porto 
Rico,  Santo  Domingo,  1890-1891. 

1892.     Trade  with  reciprocity  countries.     Letter  from  the  Acting 
Secretary  of  the  Treasury.     Jan.  29,  1892.     2  pp.     8°. 
52d  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  107.  2954 

Statistics  of  exports  and  imports  to  and  from  Santo  Domingo  and 
Porto  Rico,  18^2-189 1. 
27306°— 10 7  93 


94  LIBRAE Y   OF    COXGRESS 

1892.     Report  from  the  Secretary  of  state  [James  G.  Blaine]  in  answer 
to  a  resolution  of  the  House  of  representatives  of  Jan.  13, 
1892.     Feb.  9,  1892.     1  page.     8°. 
52d  Congress,  1st  session.     House  ex.  doc.  no.  123.  2954 

Answer  to  request  for  communications,  etc.,  in  relation  to  the  reci- 
procity treaties  with  Spain  for  Cuba  and  Porto  Rico,  the  Do- 
minican Republic,  San  Salvador,  and  the  United  States  of  Brazil. 

1892.  Message  from  the  President,  relative  to  commercial  agree- 

ments made  with  other  countries.     June  27,  1892.     151 
pp.     8°. 
52d  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  119.  2901 

Appendix  contains  reciprocity  arrangements  with  Brazil,  Cuba 
and  Porto  Rico,  Santo  Domingo,  British  colonies,  Salvador, 
Nicaragua,  Guatemala,  Honduras,  German  Empire,  Austria- 
Hungary. 
"Copies  of  all  commercial  agreements  made  with  other  countries 
and  also  report  [on]  what  steps  have  been  taken  to  negotiate  a 
reciprocal  commercial  treaty  with  Mexico." 

1893.  To  reduce  taxation,  to  provide  revenue  for  the  goverment, 

and  for  other  purposes.     [Report.]     Dec.   19,   1893.     61 
pp.     8°. 
63d  Congress,  2d  session.     House  report  no.  234-  3269 

To  accompany  H.  R.  4864. 
Mews  on  the  reciprocity  provision  of  the  McKinley  tariff  act. 

1894.  Report  by  the  Secretary  of  state  inclosing  correspondence 

between  the  governments  of  the  United  States  and  Co- 
lombia, Venezuela,  and  Haiti,  in  reference  to  the  Presi- 
dent's proclamation  of  March  15,  1892,  levying  import 
duties  on  certain  products  under  the  McKinley  law. 
March  7,  1894.  55  pp.  8°. 
53d  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  56.  3160 

This  correspondence  is  also  printed  in  the  following:  United  States. 
Department  of  state.  Papers  relating  to  the  foreign  relations  of 
the  United  States,  1894,  Appendix  I,  pp.  451-503.  Washing- 
ton, 1895.     8°. 

1894.  Message  from  the  President,  communicating  information  in 
relation  to  the  probable  action  of  foreign  governments 
by  way  of  retaliation  for  the  propvosed  imposition,  by  the 
United  States,  of  a  duty  on  sugar.  June  29,  1894.  4  pp. 
8°. 
53d  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  126.  3163 

1896.  United  States.  Bureau  of  statistics  {Treasury  dept.) .  Com- 
merce of  the  United  States  and  Europe  with  American 
countries,  1851-1895,  with  trade  under  reciprocity  agree- 
ments of  1890.     84  pp.     Frontispiece.     Tables.     8°. 


EECIPROCTTY,  1890-1894:  IT.    S.   DOCUMENTS  95 

1897.  Commercial  arrangements  concliuletl  with  foreign  countries. 
Report  from  the  Secretary  of  state  [John  Sherman]  rela- 
tive to  the  commercial  arrangements  concluded  with  for- 
eign countries  pursuant  to  section  3,  of  the  act  approved 
October  1,  1890,  providing  for  reciprocity  of  trade  be- 
tween the  United  States  and  foreign  countries.  Apr.  22, 
1897.  150  pp.  8°. 
65ih  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  52.  3561 

Arrangements  concluded  with  the  United  States  of  Brazil,  the 
Dominican  Republic,  Spain  for  Cuba  and  Porto  Rico,  Guate- 
mala, the  German  Empire,  Great  Britain  for  her  West  India  colo- 
nies (including  Trinidad,  Barbados,  the  Leeward  Islands,  the 
Windward  Islands,  British  Guiana,  Jamaica,  and  other  depen- 
dencies), Nicaragua,  Honduras,  Austria-Hungary,  and  Salvador. 
A  reprint  of  Senate  executive  document  no.  119,  52d  Congress,  Ist 
session. 


FOREIGN    DOCUMENTS 

1892.     Argentine  Republic.      Ministerio    de    relaciones    exteriores. 
Reciprocidad  comercial:  negociaciones  entre  Estados  Uni- 
dos  y  la  Republica  Argentina.     Abril,  1892. 
[Buenos  Aires:  Imjyr.  J.  Peuser,  1892.]     57,  (2)  x>p.     8°. 

1892.  Great  Britain.     Foreign  office.     Brazil.     Report  for  the  years 

1889-92  on  the  trade  of  Brazil.     32  pp.     Folded  map.    8°. 
(In   Great   Britain.     Foreign   office.     Diplomatic   and   consular 

reports.     1892.     Annual  series,  no.  1136.) 
"Customs  convention  between  Brazil  and  the  United  States  of 
America":  pp.  8-10. 

1893.  Great  Britain.      Foreign  office.     United  States.     Report  on 

the  effect,  on  the  foreign  commerce  of  the  United  States, 
of  the  agreements  concluded  under  section  3  (reciprocity 
clause)  of  the  McKinley  act  of  October  1,  1890.  16 
pp.     8°. 

(In    Great    Britain.     Foreign    office.     Diplomatic    and    consular 
reports.     1893.     Miscellaneous  series,  no.  277.) 
96 


BOOKS 


Appleton's  annual  cyclopeedia.     18«0.    New    series,    vol.     15. 

Whole  series,  vol.  30.  ,.i   (2-)  S77  PV- 

New  York:  D.Appleionandcomi,a7iy  IS91.    rr,  i^h^J'Pl- 


:  :,  oTs;     ^y'B  aine,  jJce  4,  1890,  submitting  reportupon 
the  American  republicB,  witl>  favorable  comments. 

Cudmore,  Patrick.     Buchanan's  conspiracy,  the  Nicaragua   canal, 

and  reciprocity.  ,nry    fi\     >.      19° 

New  Yorh  P.  J-  Kenedy,  1892.     127,  U)  PP-     12  • 

New  York  ■  Pan-AmsHcan  jmblishng  company,  1896.    xxm, 

''^i;rcipr£ttT*;tKfMcKin>eyact:pp.6«-e5U 

1891.     8°.) 

.     1       Ti        J  TTorirv  Farauhar.     Economic  and  indus- 
— -t^rf a:iLt  ris^L  o.  ;He;ase  .or  prote.^^^^^^^^ 
New  York:  G.  P.  Putnam's  sons,  1891.    m%,  (1),^^*  11 

"Jodty:  pp.  Wl-135.  290-294,  332. 

'tistical  institute,  at  Chicago,  September,  1893. 
Washington,  1893.    iO  pp-    8  . 

Hale.  Eugene.  ^^-^'^  ::^-^J:::^7^r:l^'^^:^^■ 
lT:::.^^z%::^::f  r^nltetl  states,  September  2, 

WaTington:  [Government  printing  office,  1890].    23  pp^     8". 


98  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Hale,  Eugene.     Reciprocity.     It   means  more   products  and   more 
manufactures  here  and  more  sales  abroad.     Speech  in  the 
Senate  of  the  United  States,  January  28,  1892. 
WasJiington,  1892.     24  pp.     S°. 

Hewes,  Fletcher  W.,  and  Wilham  McKinley,  jr.  What  are  the 
facts?  Protection  and  reciprocity  ilkistrated.  Ques- 
tions of  to-day  answered  in  one  hundred  graphic  studies, 
embracing  a  century  of  American  politics,  industries,  and 
finance. 
New  Yorl:  Henry  F.  Clarl,  [1892].  126  pp.  Charts.  8°. 
Reciprocity:  pp.  77-82. 

International  bureau  of  the  American  republics.     Hand  book 
of  the  American  republics,  1893. 
Washington:  Bureau  of  the  American  republics,  1893.  604  PP- 
Plates.     Maps.     8°.     {Bulletin  no.  50,  January,  1893.) 

"Reciprocal  commercial  arrangements  of  the  United    States": 

pp.  352-428. 
"List  of  articles  affected  by  reciprocity  arrangements":  pp.  413- 
428. 

How  the  Latin-American  markets  may  be  reached  by  the 

manufacturers  of  the  United  States. 
Washington:  [Government  printing  office,  1893.]   ix,  (i),  505  pp. 
Map.     8°.     {Bulletin  no.  63.) 

Reciprocity  and  trade. 

[  Washington:  Government    printing    office,    1897.]     29    p>P- 
8°.     {Bulletin  no.  87.) 

Also  printed  as  Senate  doc.  no.  178,  pt.  15,  55th  Congress,  2d  session. 

MacVeagh,  Frankhn.     Foreign  trade  and  reciprocity. 

(In   Sunset   club    of   Chicago.     Echoes,    pp.    195-199.     Chicago, 
1891.     8°.) 

Merrill,  Nelson.     Reciprocity  and  tariffs. 

New   York:  Printed  by  E.  0.  JenMns'  son,  1891.     32  pp. 

8°. 

Rice,  David  Hall.     Protective  philosophy.     A  discussion  of  the  prin- 
ciples of  the  American  protective  system  as  embodied  in 
the  McKinley  bill. 
Boston:  G.  B.  Reed,  1890.     viii,  237,  xvi  pp.     Illustrations. 
8°. 

"Concerning  reciprocity  by  treaty":  pp.  193-200. 

Springer,  William  M.     Tariff  reform,  the  paramount  issue.  Speeches 
and  writings  on  the  questions  involved  in  the  Presidential 
contest  of  1892. 
New  Yorlc:   C.  L.   Webster  &  company,    1892.     {2),  420  pp. 
Portraits.     8°. 


ARTICLES   IN    PERIODICALS 

1890      Mr.  Blaine  and  reciprocity.     The  Secretary  writes  again  to 
Senator  Frye.     He  recalls  two   treaties  for  reciprocity 
which  failed  to  get  the  approval  of  Congress  because  they 
proposed  free  sugar. 
XfiD  York  daily  tribune  {July  22,  1890):  1,  col.  5. 

1890.     Blaine  on  reciprocity.     His  speech  at  Waterville.     An  en 

thusiastic   reception.     Explaining  his  views   as  regards 

American  republics  to  his  former  constituents.     Speeches 

by  Congressmen  Mason  and  Lodge  and  Governor  Burleigh. 

New  Yorl  daily  tribune  {Aug.  30,  1890):  1,  col  6;  2,  col.  1. 

1890      Mr.  Blaine's  plea  for  reciprocal  trade. 

American,  vol.  20  {Sept.  6,  1890):  flG-J^n. 

1890.  Benefits  of  reciprocity.     Mr.  Blaine  discusses  the  policy  to  be 

pursued.     The  Secretary  of  state  writes  to  Colonel  W.  W. 
Clapp   of  Boston,  and  answers  some  criticisms. 
New  Yorl  daily  tribune  {Sept.  17,  1890):  1,  col.  6. 

1891.  Reciprocity-Why  southward  only?     Roger  Q.  Mills. 

Forum,  vol.  11  {May,  1891):  268-275. 
1892      The  constitutionality  of  the  reciprocity  clause  of  the  McKin.ey 
tariff  act.     C.  Stuart  Patterson. 
American  law  register  and  review,  vol.  31   {2d  ser.,  vol.  5), 
{Feh.,  1892):  65-75. 
1892.     The  reciprocity  acts  of  1890-Are  they  constitutional?     Ed- 
ward B.  Whitnev.  ^ 
Amencan  law  register  and  review,  vol.  31   {2d  ser.,  vol.  o), 
{Mar.,  1892):  173-188. 
1892.     A  bungling  attempt  to  patch  up  protection.     E.  V.  Brook- 
shire.                                                           ^^ 
Tanff  reform,  vol.  5  {Mar.  30,  1892):  18-26. 
Speech  delivered  in  Congress,  Mar.  11,  1892. 

1892.     Reciprocity  foolish  and  unfair.     J.  DeW.  Warner. 

Tariff  reform,  vol.  5  {Mar.  30,  1892):  28-31. 


100  LIBRAKY   OF   CONGRESS 

1892.  Reciprocity  and  the  farmer.     Hilary  A.  Herbert. 

North  American  review,  vol.  154  i^pr.,  1892):  4^4-4^3. 

Reprinted  in  part  in  Tariff  reform,  vol.  5,  Mar.  30, 1892,  pp.  26-28. 

1893.  The  Republican  policy  of  reciprocity.     William  L.  Wilson. 

Forum,  vol  I4  {Oct.,  1892):  256-264. 

1892.  Reciprocity.     F.  W.  Taussig.      ' 

Quarterly  journal  of  economics,  vol.  7    {Oct.,  1892):  26-39. 

"My  object  is  chiefly  to  discuss  the  mode  in  which  reciprocity 
treaties  usually  operate,  to  point  out  the  peculiarities  of  the 
form  of  reciprocity  which  this  country  is  now  applying,  and  to 
say  something  of  the  general  bearing  of  such  arrangements  on 
the  problems  of  international  trade." 

1893.  American  reciprocity  and  what  it  means.     Samuel  M.  Davis. 

American  journal  of  politics,  vol.  2  {Feb.,  1893):  113-120. 

1893.     Reciprocity  and  South  America.     M.  M.  Trumbull. 
Open  court,  vol.  7  {Feb.  2,  1893):  3543-3544- 

1893.  Reciprocity. 

Public  opinion,   vol.    15    {Apr.   29,    1893):  97-98;  {May  6, 
1893):  121. 

Newspaper  extracts. 

1894.  Reciprocity  treaties  and  trade. 

International   bureau  of  the   American   republics.     Monthly 
bulletin,  vol.  1  {Mar.,  1894):  9-21. 

1894.     The    reciprocal    commercial    arrangements    of    the    United 
States  under  section  third  of  the  tariff  act  of  1890.     [Eng- 
lish and  Spanish.] 
International  bureau   of  the  American  republics.     Monthly 
bulletin,  vol  2  {August,  1894):  185-187. 


RECIPROCITY  WITH   CUBA 

UNITED  STATES  DOCUMENTS 

1884.     Communication  from  the  Secretary  of  state  [F.  T.  Frelinghuy- 
sen],  relative  to  the  reciprocity  treaty  between  the  United 
States  and  Spain.     Dec.  15,  1884.     6  pp.     8°. 
48th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  ex.  doc.  no.  10.  2261 

Treaty  concerning  Cuba  and  Porto  Rico. 

1901.  Commercial  reciprocity  between  the  United  States  and  Cuba. 

Petition  addressed  to  the  Senate  by  Senor  Don  F.  Gamba 
and  others  urging  the  enactment  of  a  law  for  commercial 
reciprocity  between  the  United  States  and  Cuba.     Dec. 
16,  1901.  "^  2  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  73.  4226 

1902.  Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Hearings  before  Committee  on  ways 

and  means,  January  15,  16,  21,  22,  23,  24,  25,  28,  29,  1902. 
vii,  (1),  766  pp.     Illustrations.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc.  no.  535.  4375 

1902.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Report  from  Mr.  Payne  [to  accom- 
pany H.  R.  12765].     Mar.  31,  1902.     4  pp!^     8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1276.  4403 

1902.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Views  of  the  minority  submitted  by 
Mr.  McClellan.     [To  accompany  H.  R.  12765.]     Apr.  3, 
1902.     8  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.    House  report  no.  1276,  part  2.     4403 

1902.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Minority  views  submitted  by  Mr. 
Newlands.     [To  accompany  H.  R.  12765.]     Apr.  4,  1902. 
11  pp.     8°. 
57ih  Congress,  1st  session.    House  report  no.  1276,  part  3.    4403 

1902.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Minority  views  submitted  by  Mr. 
Robertson.     [To  accompany  H.  R.  12765.]     Apr.  5,  1902. 
4  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.    House  report  no.  1276,  part  4-    4403 

1902.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Minority  views  submitted  by  Mr. 
Cooper.     [To  accompany  II.   R.   12765.]     Apr.  5,   1902. 
3  pp.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.    House  report  no.  1276,  part  5.    4403 

101 


102  LIBEARY   OF    CONGRESS 

1902.     Debate  on.  reciprocity  with  Cuba. 

Congressional  record,  vol.  35,  57th  Congress,  1st  session,  1902 
{Ayr.  8):  381^7-3866;  {Apr.  9):  3898-3920;  {Apr.  10): 
3948-3968;  {Apr.  11):  3993-4025;  {Apr.  14):  4116-4134; 
{Apr.  15):  4177-4205;  {Apr.  16):  4255-4279;  {Apr.  17): 
4310-4346;  {Apr.  18):  4375-4418. 

1902.  Communication  regarding  our  commercial  relations  with  Cuba 
and  Philippine  Islands,  to  accompany  S.  6052  [to  amend 
act  to  provide  revenue  for  government,  approved  July  24, 
1897,  as  to  tariff  on  sugar,  and  to  provide  reciprocal  trade 
relations  with  Cuba];  presented  by  Mr.  Dietrich.  June  3, 
1902.  3  pp.  8°. 
57tli  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  388.  4245 

1902.     Message  from  the  President  of  the  United  States  in  reference 
to  reciprocity  with  Cuba.     June  13,  1902.     3  pp. 
57tli  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  405.  4245 

1902.  United  States.  Congress.  Senate.  Committee  on  relations 
with  Cuba.  Cuban  sugar  sales.  Testimony  taken  b}"  the 
Committee  on  relations  with  Cuba  [May  1-June  16,  1902] 
under  authority  of  Senate  resolution  of  April  26,  1902. 
(1),  492  pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session. 

1902.     The  ethics  of  the  fight  for  Cuban  reciprocity.     Letter  from 

Truman  G.  Palmer  to  Hon.   Henry  M.  Teller,  member 

Senate  Committee  on  relations  with  Cuba.     June  27,  1902. 

28  pp.     8°. 

57th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  434-  4247 

1902.     The  ''deadly  parallel"  on  Cuban  tariff  reduction,  compiled  by 
Truman  G.  Palmer.     June  27,   1902.     186  pp.     Folded 
table.     8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  439.  4249 

1902.  Payments  of  F.  B.  Thurber  out  of  Cuban  funds.  Letter  from 
the  Acting  Secretary  of  war,  transmitting  a  copy  of  a  let- 
ter from  Brig.  Gen.  Leonard  Wood,  relating  to  payments 
to  F.  B.  Thurber  out  of  Cuban  funds.  Julv  1,  1902.  24 
pp.  8°. 
57th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc.  no.  679.  4377 

"A  statement  of  the  expenses  incurred  in  the  cause  of  reciprocity 
between  Cuba  and  the  United  States." 


BECIPBOCITY    WITH   CUBA:   U.  S.   DOCUMENTS  103 

1902     Messac-c  from  the  President  of  the  Unite,!  St»tf •  '""f  f^" 

1902.  Mess    c  ^^^.^^  convention  bet^v^en  the  Un>te,l  Sta    s 

and  Cuba,  signed  at  the  city  of  Habana  on  December  11, 
1902      Dee.  [17)  1902.     7  pp.     8°. 
S7tk  Congress,   2d   session-     Cmfdmtial.     Senate.     Execu- 

live  I. 
MOS      Supplementary    conTention    [signe.l    Washington,   Jan.    26 

1903.  Supple.  y^^^  ^^^^  ^^.^^^^  States  and  Cuba    extendmg 

time  within  which  may  be  exchanged  ™t>fi—  "J 
commercial  convention^signed  December  11,  1902.     Jan. 

57Af<}^r^X  ZdZsil'  C»nfiientua.     [SenaU}  femfe 

7,  ft.  i 

MOS      History  of  Hawaiian  treaty  and  Cuban  reciprocity.     History 
1903.     History  ^,^^  ^  ^^^^^  to  terminate  the 

treaty  signed  by  Justin  S.  Morrill,  Daniel  W.  \oorhees, 
and  Ndson  W.  Aldrieh;  also  a  history  of  the  agitation  tor 
Cuban  reciprocity  with  the  United  States,  and  opinions 
as  to  the  pr'obable  results  of  Cuban  reciproeay  by  Charles 
H  Dietrich.  Data  and  tables  compiled  by  Truman  G. 
Palmer.  March  2,  190.3.  27  pp.  8°. 
B7th  Congress,  2d  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  206.  44JU 

mercial  reciprocity  between  the  two  countries.     March  5, 

SsTconyrel^Xpeeiol  session.     Semite  doc.  no.  1.  4556 

,,03.     The  su^;^.st.  ^^>P;S^  -t^MarK^ 

Ssl^Con^ess,  Speciul  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  7.        4556 

eighUr  Congress.     November  10,  1903.     (1),  2  PP-     8^ 
68th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc   no.  /. 
Regarding  ihc  commercial  treaty  with  (  uba. 

vember  10,  1903s    5  pp.     8°. 
58th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  doc.  no.  ^. 


104  LIBRARY    OF    CONGRESS 

1903.  Hearings  on  Cuban  reciprocity.  Statements  of  Gen.  T.  11. 
Bliss,  A.  Bijur,  and  Richard  A.  Bachia  before  the  Com- 
mittee on  foreign  relations  on  the  reciprocity  treaty 
with  Cuba.  November  11,  1903.  Injunction  of  secrecy 
removed  and  ordered  to  be  printed  as  a  document.  44 
pp.  8°. 
bSth  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  2.  4563 

1903.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Report  from  the  Committee  on  wa^^s 
and  means.     November  13,  1903.     4  pp.     8°. 
SStJi  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1.  4577 

1903.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Report  from  the  Committee  on  ways 
and  means.     Views  of  the  minority.     November  16,  1903. 
3  pp.     8°. 
BSth  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1,  pt.  2.     4577 

1903.     Reciprocity   with   Cuba.     Views   of   Mr.    Cooper,    of   Texas. 
November  16,   1903.     5  pp.     8°. 
58th  Congress,  1st  session.     House  report  no.  1,  pt.  3.         4577 

1903.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Report  from  the  Committee  on  for- 
eign relations.     November  23,    1903.     1   page.     8°. 
58t7i  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  report  no.  2.  4570 

1903.  Debate  in  House  and  Senate  on  reciprocity  with  Cuba. 

Congressional  record,  vol.  37,  58th  Congress,  1st  session,  1903 
(Nov.  16):  259-265;  273-276;  (Nov.  17):  293-313;  (Nov. 
18):  323-349;  (Nov.  19):  361-389;  (Nov.  25):  479-^86; 
(Bee.  7):  13-15;  (Dec.  8):  37-^7;  (Dec.  9):  65-82;  (Dec. 
11):  116-126;  (Dec.  12):  153-172;  (Dec.  14):  178-194; 
(Dec.  15):  239-257;  (Dec.  16):  277-286. 

1904.  United  States.     Treaties,  etc.     Commercial  convention  be- 

tween the  United  States  and  Cuba.    Proclaimed,  December 
17,  1903. 

(In  U.  S.  Dept.  of  state.  Papers  relating  to  the  foreign  relations  of 
the  United  States,  1903,  pp.  375-382.     Washington,  1904.     8°.) 

Same. 

(In  International  bureau  of  the  American  republics.  Monthly 
bulletin,  vol.  16,  Jan.,  1904,  pp.  104-111.  Washington,  1904. 
8°.) 

1909.  Free  trade  with  Cuba.  I^etter  and  speech  of  Gen.  James  H. 
Wilson,  advocating  the  establishment  of  a  commercial 
union,  under  which  free  trade  should  exist  between  Cuba 
and  the  United  States  in  natural  and  manufactured  prod- 
ucts, subject  to  an  agreed  tariff  as  between  them  and  other 
foreign  nations.  Apr.  22,  1909.  19  pp.  8°. 
61st  Congress,  1st  session.     Senate  doc.  no.  17. 


BOOKS 

Bass,  William  Louis.     Reci})r()(i(la(l  cubana-americana,  septiembre 
15,  1902. 
WasMngto7i,  D.  C.,U902].     (3),  69  pp.     Plate.     16°. 

Keciprocidad     cubana-americana,     septiembre     20,     1902. 

Carta  cubana,  espanol,  Cuban  letter,  English. 
[Washington?  1902 f]     33,  (1)  pp.     Illustrations.     8°. 
Spanish  and  English. 

Reciprocidad  cubana-americana,  octobre  6,  1902.     Section 

4  American  tariff  law  of  1897,  seccion  4a  ley  arancilaria 
americana  de  1897.     Espanol,  English,  French,  German. 
[Washington?  19029]     42,  (1)  pp.     Illustrations.     8°. 

Cuba.      Treaties,    etc.,     1902.      The     Cuban-American     reciprocity 
protocol.     El  protocolo  del  tratado  cubano-americano  de 
reciprocidad  comercial. 
Washington,    D.    C:    Cuban- American    reciprocity    bureau, 
1903.     16  pp.     8°. 
Spanish  and  English. 

Reprinted  from  La  Discusion,  Havana,  Dec.  19,  1902;  and  from 
the  Washington  post,  Dec.  26,  1902. 

Comite   central   de   propaganda  economica.     Comite 

central  de  propaganda  economica;  dictamen  de  la  Co- 
mision  encargada  del  estudio  y  critica  del  convenio  de 
reciprocidad  comercial  con  los  Estados  Unidos  segun  fue 
aprobada  por  unanimidad  en  la  sesion  extraordinaria 
celebrada  el  dia  11  de  febrero  de  1892. 
Habana:  Imprenta  ''La  Razon,"  1892.  68,  (2),  8,  (83)  pp. 
Tables.     16°. 

Cuban-American  reciprocity  bureau,  Washington,  D.  C. 

Carta  de  Washington  sobre  reciprocidad.     Nos.  1,  4,  8. 
Washington,  D.  C,  1902.     3  nos.     Illustrations.     8°. 

* Comments    on    the    Bliss-Pal  ma    protocol    for    a    Cuban- 
American  reciprocity  treaty. 
Washington,  D.  C,  1903.     52  pp.     Illustrations.     8°. 


*  Not  in  Library  of  Congress 


105 


106  LIBRARY   OF    CONGRESS 

[Ham,  E.]     The  case  of  Cuba. 

[  Washington,  D.  C,  1902.]     21^.  pp.     5°. 

New  York  free-trade  club.  The  Spanish  treaty  opposed  to 
tariff  reform.  Report  of  a  committee  of  enquiry  appointed 
by  the  New  York  free-trade  club. 
New  Yorli:  Puh.for  the  New  Y ork  free-trade  club,  by  G.  P. 
Putnam's  sons,  1885.  31  pp.  Folded  diagram.  12°. 
(Questions  of  the  day. — xvin.) 

Palraer,  Truman  G.,  comp.  The  story  of  Cuban  distress  as  presented 
by  witnesses  favoring  tariff  reductions  to  Cuba,  at  the 
hearings  before  Committee  on  ways  and  means,  Fifty- 
seventh  Congress,  1st  session,  January  15th  to  29th,  1902. 
A  careful  digest  of  the  testimony  of  witnesses  favoring 
Cuban  tariff  concessions. 
[  Washington]  1902.     42  pp.     8°. 

Robinson,  Albert  Gardner.     Cuba  and  the  intervention. 

New   Yorlc   [etc.]:  Longmans,   Green,   and  co.,   1905.     (10), 
359  pp.     8°. 

The  question  of  relations:  pp.  224-242;  Effect  of  the  Piatt  amend- 
ment: pp.  243-257;  Acceptance  of  the  Piatt  amendment:  pp. 
258-277;  Struggle  for  tariff  concessions:  pp.  278-293;  Industry 
and  commerce:  pp.  294-303. 

Facts  and  figures  on  the  Cuban  situation.     Prepared  at  the 

request  of  the  Cuban  planters'  association  by  Albert  G. 
Robinson,  Washington,  January,  1902. 
[  Washington:  Press  of  Byron  S.  Adams,  1902.]     27  pp.     12°. 

United  States.  Circuit  court  (2d  circuit.)  Faber  v.  United  States. 
(Circuit  court,  S.  D.  New  York.  Nov.  14,  1907.)  No. 
4,812. 

(In  Federal  reporter,  vol.  157,  pp.  140-142.  St.  Paul,  1908.  8°.) 
"1.  Customs  duties — Cuban  treaty — preferential  duty.  Cuban 
commercial  convention,  art.  2,  33  Stat.  2137,  prescribes  that 
Cuban  products  'shall  be  admitted '  at  a  reduction  from  the  duty 
provided  by  the  tariff  act  of  1897,  'or  as  may  be  provided  by  any 
tariff  law  of  the  United  States  subsequently  enacted;'  and 
article  8,  33  Stat.  2140,  prescribes  that  'the  rates  of  duty  herein 
granted  *  *  *  are  and  shall  continue  *  *  *  prefer- 
ential in  respect  to  all  like  imports  from  other  countries.'  Held, 
that  the  reduction  contemplated  was  from  the  rates  provided  in 
any  general  tariff  law,  and  not  from  those  in  special  laws,  like  the 
Philippine  tariff  act,  or  reciprocal  commercial  agreements." 
"2.  Same — 'other  countries' — Philippines.  The  Philippines  are 
not  another  country,  within  the  meaning  of  Cuban  commercial 
convention,  art.  8,  33  Stat.  2140,  prescribing  on  importations 
from  Cuba  treatment  preferential  in  respect  to  like  imports 
from  'other  countries.' " 


RECIPROCITY   WITH   CUBA:  BOOKS  107 

United  States.  Supreme  court.  United  States  v.  American  sugar 
refining  company.  Appeal  from  the  Circuit  court  of  the 
Unitecf  States  for  the  Southern  district  of  New  York.  No. 
269.     Argued  Apr.  27,  1906.— Decided  May  28,  1906. 

(In  its  United  States  reports,  vol.  202,  pp.  563-580.     New  York, 
-     1906.     8°.) 

"Under  the  treaty  between  the  United  States  and  Cuba  of  Decem- 
ber 11,  1902,  and  the  act  of  Congress  of  December  17,  1903, 
imports  from  Cuba  were  not  entitled  to  reduction  of  duties 
imposed  by  the  tariff  act  of  July  24,  1897,  until  December  27, 
1903,  the  date  proclaimed  by  the  President  of  the  United  States 
and  the  President  of  Cuba  for  the  commencement  of  the  opera- 
tion of  the  treaty." 


ARTICLES   IN    PERIODICALS 

1901.     Cuba  demands  reciprocity.     Emilio  Nunez. 

IndejMndent,  vol.  53  {Oct.  31,  1901):  2579-2581. 

1901.     The  Cuban  problem.     L.  V.  De  Abad. 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  21  {Dec,  1901):  515-525. 

1901.  The  need  for  reciprocity  with  Cuba.     Leonard  "Wood. 

IndepeTident,  vol.  53  (Dec.  12,  1901):  2927-2929. 

1902.  Our  honor  and  Cuba's  need.     Marrion  Wilcox. 

Forum,  vol.  32  {Jan.,  1902):  623-628. 

1902.     The  outlook  for  Cuba.     A.  G.  Robinson. 

Independent,  vol.  5^  {Jan.  16,  1902):  135-138. 

1902.     The  future  of  Cuba.     Leonard  Wood. 

Independent,  vol.  54  {Jan.  23,  1902):  193-194. 

1902.     Political  aspect  of  Cuba's  economic  distress.     Josiah  Quincy. 
North  American  review,  vol.  174  {Jan.,  1902):  12-19. 

1902.     Reasons  for  reciprocity  between  the  L"'nited  States  and  Cuba. 
Leonard  Wood. 
OutlooTc,  vol.  70  {Jan.  18,  1902):  169-171. 

1902.     The  conflict  of  sugar  interests.     George  Kennan. 
Outlool,  vol.  70  {Feb.  8,  1902):  367-370. 

1902.     Sugar  production,  tariff  and  revenue. 

Protectionist,  vol.  13  {Feb.,  1902):  573-580. 

1902.     Cuba  vs.  the  United  States.     I.  The  question  of  reciprocity. 
F.  B.  Thurber. 

Arena,  vol.  27  {Mar.,  1902):  234-238. 

1902.     The  Cuban  complication.     A.  G.  Robinson. 

Independent,  vol.  54  {Mar.  6,  1902):  556-558. 

1902.     Tariff  and  Cuban  reciprocity.     William  Alden  Smith. 

A7nerican  economist,  vol  29  {Apr.  25,  1902):  194-195,  200- 
205. 

Speech  in  the  House  of  representatives,  Apr.  9,  1902. 
108 


RECIPROCITY   WITH    CUBA:   PERIODICALS  109 

1902     The  sugar  pautlomoniuni. 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  22  {Apr.,  1902):  316-325. 

Against  the  proposed  reduction  of  the  tariff  on  Cuban  sugar. 

1902.     The  future  of  Cuba.     Tomas  Estrada  Pahna. 
Independent,  vol.  5 4  {JLpr.  3,  1902):  789-791. 

1902.     Takmg  hberties  with  prosperity.     T.  Z.  Cowles. 

American  economist,  vol.  29  {Apr.  18,  1902):  181-183,  188- 
191. 

1902.     Warning  from  the  census.     George  Gunton. 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  22  {June,  1902):  511-526. 

Argues  that  a  protective  tariff  is  indispensable  to  prosperity  and 
that  reciprocity  with  Cuba  is  a  step  toward  free  trade. 

1902.     ''Let  US  face  the  truth." 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  23  {Aug.,  1902):  132-140. 

Reply  to  the  Chicago  Inter-ocean's  criticism  of  the  attitude  of 
Gunton's  magazine  in  opposing  reciprocity  with  Cuba. 

1902.     Cuba's  claim  upon  the  United  States.     O.  H.  Piatt. 

North  American  review,  vol.  175  {Aug.,  1902):  145-151. 

1902.     Cuba  and  the  Brussels  sugar  conference. 

Yale  review,  vol.  11  {Aug.,  1902):  120-122. 

1902.     Cuban  reciprocity — a  moral  issue.     William  Allen  White. 
McClure's  magazine,  vol.  19  {Sept.,  1902):  387-394. 

1902.     [The  Cuban  question.]     Address  delivered  at  the  first  annual 
meeting  of  the  National  reciprocity  league.     F.  D.  Pavey. 
National  reciprocity ,  vol.  1  {Sept.,  1902):  11-15. 

1902.     "Cuban  reciprocity:  a  moral  issue." 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  23  {Oct.,  1902):  286-296. 

Reply  to  an  article  by  \V.  A.  White  in  McClure's  magazine  for 
Sept.,  1902. 

1902.     Where  Cuba  stands.     Emilio  Nunez. 

Independent,  vol.  54  {Dec.  4,  1902):  2877-2880. 

1902.     [Reciprocity  with  Cuba.]     F.  D.  Pavey. 

National  reciprocity,  vol.  1  {Dec,  1902):  38-42. 

1902.  The  situation  in  Cuba.     Marrion  Wilcox. 

North  American  review,  vol.  175  {Dec,  1902):  819-828. 

1903.  Latest  aspects  of  the  Cuban  treaty. 

Nation,  vol.  76  {Jan.  29,  1903):  84-85. 

27306°— 10 8  "^ 


110  LIBRARY   OF    CONGRESS 

1903.     Reciprocity:  Cuban  and  otherwise. 

Gunton's  magazine,  vol.  2^  {Feb.,  1903):  169-172. 

1903.  The  proposed  Cuban  treaty.     J.  S.  Crawford. 

American  economist,  vol.  31  {Apr.  24,  1903):  193,  201-203. 

'  1903.     Reciprocity  with  Cuba.     H.  P.  Wilhs. 

American  academy  of  political  and  social  science.     Annals, 
vol.  22  {July,  1903):  129-147. 

1904.  Le  traite  de  reciprocite  entre  Cuba  et  les  !Cltats-Unis.     Un 

depute. 
La  Reforme  economique,  vol.  13  {Jan.  17,  1904):  4^^^^  • 

1908.     Tariff  relations  with  Cuba — actual  and  desirable.     Edwin  F. 
Atkins. 
American  academy  of  political  and  social  science.     Annals, 
vol.  32  {Sept.,  1908):  321-329. 


RECIPROCITY  IN  GREAT  BRITAIN  AND  OTHER  COUNTRIES 

BOOKS 

Augier,  Charles.     La  France  et  les  traites  de  commerce ;  etude  sur  les 
tarifs  des  douanes  de  la  France  et  de  I'etranger.     Pub. 
sous  le  patronage  de  la  Chambre  de  commerce  de  Nice. 
Paris:  Chevalier  &  Riviere,  1906.     U),  [7]-269,  5  pp.     8°. 

Bateman,  William  Bateman  Bateman-Hanbury,  2d  haron.  Lord 
Bateman's  plea  for  limited  protection  or  for  reciprocity  in 
free  trade.  A  letter  reprinted  from  "The  Times"  of 
Nov.  12th,  1877,  with  a  preface  by  the  author.  4th 
thousand. 
London:    W.  Ridgway,  1S78.     v,  {7]-13  pp.     8°. 

[Boutarel,  Aime.]     Le  traite  de  commerce  et  le  libre-echange. 
Paris:  Guillaumin  et  c'S  1862.     30  pp.     8°. 

Byng,  G.     Protection;  the  views  of  a  manufacturer. 

London:  Eyre  and  S pottiswoode ,  1901.     xi,  255  pp.     8°. 
"Retaliation  and  reciprocity":  pp.  198-205. 

Chamberlain,  Joseph.      The   French   treaty   and   reciprocity.     A 
speech  delivered  in  the  House  of  commons,  August  12th, 
1881.     Revised. 
London,  Paris  d)  New  Yorl-:  Published  for  the  Cohden  club 
by  Cassell,  Petter,  Galpin  &  co.  [1881].'  38  pp.     12°. 

Cobden  club.     Commercial   policy  of  France,  and  the  treaty  with 

.  England  of  1860. 

London:  Printed  for  the  Cobden  club,  by  Cassell,  Petter  and 
Galpin,  1871.     24  pp.     8°. 

Free  trade  and  the  European  treaties  of  commerce;  being 

1.  Report  of  proceedings  at  the  dinner  of  the  Cobden 
club,  July  17,  1875  ...  2.  Correspondence  on  the 
prospects  of  free  trade  ...  3.  Discussion  on  the  treaties 
of  commerce. 
London,  Paris,  <&  New  YorJc:  Cassell,  Petter  <£•  Galpin, 
1875.     175,  U)  pp.     12°. 

Ill 


112  LIBEAKY   OF    CONGRESS 

Cross,  John  Kynaston.     Imports,  exports,  and  the  French  treaty. 
A  speech  in  the  House  of  commons,  12th  August,  1881. 
London,  Paris,  &  New  York:  Cassell,  Petter,  Galpin  &  co. 
[1881].     12  pp.     12°. 

Dawson,   William  Harbutt.     Protection  in  Germany;  a  history  of 
German  fiscal  poHcy  duringHhe  nineteenth  century. 
London:  P.  8.  King  &  son,  1904.     {8),  259  pp.     12°.     {Pro- 
tection in  various  countries;  ed.  by  W.  H.  Dawson.) 
"The  commercial  treaty  era":  pp.  98-127. 

Farrer,  [Thomas  Henry  Farrer]  1st  baron.  Free  trade  versus  fair 
trade.  By  the  late  Lord  Farrer.  New  ed.  with  notes  and 
latest  statistics  by  C.  H.  Chomley. 

[London]:  The  Free  trade  union,  1904-     xx,  465  pp.     12°. 

Fuchs,  Karl  Johannes.     The  trade  policy  of  Great  Britain  and  her 
colonies  since  1860.     Tr.  by  Constance  H.  M.  Archibald. 
London,    New    York:   Macmillan    and    co.,    limited,    1905. 
xxxviii,  413  2)p.     8°. 

"Movements  in  the  direction  of  reciprocity,  protection,  and  fair 
trade":  pp.  188-210. 

[Garvin,  J.  L.]     Imperial  reciprocity,  a  study  of  fiscal  policy;  in  a 
series  of  articles  revised  and  reprinted  from  the  Daily 
telegraph. 
London:  Office  of  the  'Daily  telegraph'  [1902].     xx,  115  pp. 

— New  ed.,  with  a  letter  by  the  Right  Hon.  J.  Cham- 
berlain. 
London:  Office  of  'the  Daily  telegraph'  [1903?].     xii,  200  pp. 
8°. 

Great  Britain.  Colonial  office.  Return  of  most-favoured-nation 
clauses  in  existing  treaties  of  commerce  and  navigation 
between  Great  Britain  and  foreign  powers,  stating  the 
period  when  terminable;  and  showing  whether  they 
apply  to  the  British  colonies:  in  force  on  the  1st  January, 
1907. 
London:  Printed  for  H.  M.  Stationery  off.,  by  Harrison  and 
sons,  [1907].  Hi,  70,  70,  (1)  pp.  F°.  {[Gt.  Brit.  Par- 
liament.    Papers  by  co7nmand].     Cd.  3395.) 


FOREIGN   COUNTRIES:   BOOKS  113 

Great  Britain.  Colonial  office.  Return  of  national  treatment  clauses 
in  existing  treaties  of  commerce  and  navigation  between 
Great  Britain  and  foreign  powers,  stating  the  period  when 
terminable;  and  showing  whether  they  ai)pl3^  to  the  British 
colonies:  in  force  on  the  1st  Januar\^,  1907. 
London:  Printed  for  H.  M.  Stationery  off.,  hy  Harrison  and 
sons,  [1907].  (2),  (1),  71,  71,  (1)  pp.  F°.  {[Gt.  Brit. 
Parliament.     Papers  hy  command].     Cd.  3396.) 

Foreign    office.      Return    showing  the    countries    between 

which  commercial  treaties  were  in  force  on  January  1, 
1908.  Presented  to  the  House  of  commons,  by  com- 
mand of  His  Majesty,  in  pursuance  of  their  address  dated 
March  19,  1906. 
London:  Printed  for  H.  M.  Stationery  off'.,  hy  Harrison  and 
sons,  [1908].  (2),  51,  (1)  pp.  F°.  {Commercial  no.  4, 
1908.) 

Parliament.     Papers  by  command.     Cd.  4080. 

Herkless,  William  Robertson.     The  economics  of  fair  trade. 
Glasgow:    Wilson  &    McCormiclc,  1882.     J^O  pp.     8°. 

Knight,  William  Angus.     Reciprocity  in  trade  the  empire's  safe- 
guard, No.  1, 
London:    W.  Heinemann,  1903.     58  pp.     8°. 
Contents. — no.  1.     Preferential  colonial  tariffs. 

Lang,  Lajos.     Hundert  Jalire  Zollpolitik.     Autorisierte  Ubersetzung 
aus  dem  ungarischen  von  Alexander  Rosen. 
Wien  und  Leipzig:  C.  Fromme,  1906.     xv,  620  pp.     Tahles. 
Map.     4°- 

Contents. — England. — Amerika. — Frankreich. — DerZollverein. — 
Osterreich  und  Ungam  vor  1848. — Das  gemeinsame  Zollgebiet 
zur  Zeit  des  Absolutismus. — Die  osterreichisch-ungarische  Zoll- 
politik in  der  liberalen  Ara. — Die  Wendung  zum  Schutzzolle. — 
Derautonome  ZoUtarif. — Die  schutzzoUnerische  Flat. — Das  Re- 
sultat  der  autonomen  Zollpolitik. — Die  Riickkehr  zur  Yertrags- 
politik. — DieVertragemitdenwestlichenLiindem. — DieVertrag 
mit  den  ostlichen  Liindern. — Das  dcut.sche  Zollgesetz  vom  Jahre 
1902. — Das  osterreichisch-ungarische  ZoU-  und  Handelsbundnis 
und  der  ZoUtarif. — Chamberlain.— Statistische  Tabellen  und 
sonstige  Beilagen. — Verzeichnis  der  derzeit  in  Geltungstehenden 
Vertrage  der  Osterreichisch-ungarischen  Monarchie  mit  dem 
Auslande. — Alphabetisches  Namen-  und  Sachregister. 

Medley,  George  W.     Fair  trade  unmasked;  or,  Notes  on  the  minor- 
ity report  of  the  royal  commission  on  the  depression  of 
trade  and  industry. 
London,  New  York  [etc.]:   Cassell  db  company,  limited,  [1887] 
95  pp.     12°. 


114  LIBRARY   OF   CONGRESS 

Medley,  George  W.     The  reciprocity  craze.     A  tract  for  the  times. 
London:  Cassell,  Petter,Galpin  <&  co.,  1881.     36  pp.     12°. 

Ricardo,  John  Lewis.     The  anatomy  of  the  navigation  laws. 

London:  Charles  Gilpin,  18J+7 .     vi,  (2),  336  pp.     8°. 

"Launch  of  reciprocity":  pp.  38-39;  "The  reciprocity  acts  and 
the  prophecies  of  the  ship  "owners  " :  pp.  39-48. 

Senex,  a  true  Conservative,  [pseud.]     The  British  empire:  can  it  be 

long  maintained  in  all  its  integrity,  under  the  unrestricted 

and    unreciprocated    free-trade    (rather,    free    imports) 

pohcy  ? 

London:    W.  Ridgway,  1878.     (8),  xv,  (1),  369,  (1)  pp.     8° 

Smith,  George  Armitage-     The  free-trade  movement  and  its  results 
2d  ed. 
London,  Glasgow  and  Dublin:  Blackie  cfc  son,  limited,  1903 
{2),  via,  [9]-276  pp.     12°.     ( The  Victorian  era  series) 

"Arguments  for  protection,  reciprocity,  bounties,  &c.":  pp 
110-130. 

Trumbull,  M.  M.     The  free  trade  struggle  in  England.     2d  ed.,  re^ 
vised  and  enlarged. 
Chicago:  The  Open  court  publishing  company,  1892.     (8), 
288  pp.     12°. 

"Reciprocity":  pp.  150-165. 

Wilson,  Alexander  Johnstone.     Reciprocity,  bi-metallism,  and  land- 
tenure  reform, 
London:  Macmillan  and  co.,  1880.     viii,  256  pp.     8°. 

Contents. — Pages  1-50:  Can  reciprocity  help  us? — The  general 
answer  to  the  question;  pp.  51-77:  The  futility  of  the  reciproci- 
tarian  proposals. 

Wolowski,  Louis  Francois  Michel  Raymond.    La  liberte  commerciale 
et  les  resultats  du  traite  de  commerce  de  1860. 
Paris:  Guillaumin  et  c*«,  1869.     viii,  472  pp.     8°. 


ARTICLES  IN   PERIODICALS 

1827.     Complaints  of  the  ship  owners— Reciprocity  system. 

Edinburgli  review,  vol.  J^5  {Mar.,  1827):  ^6-^58. 

1832.     The  reciprocity  system. 

Foreign  quarterly  review,  vol.  9  {May,  1832):  261-289. 

1838.     The  reciprocity  and  colonial  systems. 

Blachwood's  Edinburgh  magazine,  vol.  44  {Sept.,  1838):  317- 
334. 

1870.     Free  trade  and  reciprocity.     Bonamy  Price. 

Contemporary  review,  vol.  13  {Mar.,  1870):  321-345. 

1878.  Free  trade  or  reciprocity?     C.  Halford  Thompson. 

Eraser's  magazine,  vol.  97  {Jan.,  1878):  89-92. 

1879.  Reciprocity.     C.  Halford  Thompson. 

Eraser's  magazine,  vol.  99  {Eeb.,  1879):  197-210. 

1879.     Can  reciprocity  help  us  ?    A.  J.  Wilson. 

Macmillan's  magazine,  vol.  39  {Feb.,  1879):  357-368. 

1879.     Free  trade  and  reciprocity.     Arthur  Arnold. 

Gentleman's  magazine,  n.  s.,  vol.  22  {Mar.,  1879):  310-329. 

1879.     Reciprocity  the  true  free  trade.     Alfred  R.  Wallace. 
Nineteenth  century,  vol.  5  {Apr.,  1879):  638-649. 

Reprinted  in  his  "Studies,  scientific  and  social,"  London,  1900, 
V.  2,  pp.  167-183. 

1879.     Commercial  depression  and  reciprocity.     Bonamy  Price. 

Contemporary  review,  vol.  35  {May,  1879):  269-288. 

1879.     Reciprocity  and  free  trade.     Robert  Lowe. 

Nineteenth  century,  vol.  5  {June,  1879):  992-1002. 

A  reply  to  A.  R.  Wallace's  article  "Reciprocity  the  true  free 
trade"  in  the  Nineteenth  century  for  April,  1879. 

1879.     A  few  words  in  reply  to  Mr.  Lowe.     Alfred  R.  Wallace. 

Nineteenth  century,  vol.  6  {July,  1879):  179-181. 

Reprinted  in  Wallace's  "Studies,  scientific  and  social,"  London, 
1900,  V.  2,  pp.  183-187. 

115 


116  LIBRAEY   OF   CONGRESS 

1879.     Free  trade,  reciprocity,  and  foreign  competition. 

Westminster  review,  vol.  112  {July,  1879):  1-^6 . 

1892.     Protection — free     trade — fair    trade — colonial     trade.     Earl 
Grey. 
Nineteenth  century,  vol  31  (Jan.,  1892):  38-60. 

1892.  Fair  trade  and  authority.     M.  S.  Constable. 

National  review,  vol.  19  (Aj^r.,  1892):  293-296. 

1893.  British  trade  and  imperial  reciprocity.     Alexander  McNeill. 

Canadian  magazine,  vol.  1  (Apr.,  1893):  118-125. 

1902.     Free  trade  or  protection  for  England?     A  plea  for  recon- 
sideration.    John  Beattie  Crozier. 
Fortnightly  review,  n.  s.,  vol.  71  {Mar.,  1902):  427-433. 

1902.     The  approaching  abandonment  of  free  trade.     J.  A.  Hobson. 

Fortnightly  review,  n.  s.,  vol.  71  {Mar.,  1902):  434-U4- 

1902.     The  promotion  of  trade  within  the  Empire.     John  B.  C.  Ker- 
shaw. 
Monthly  review,  vol.  7  {June,  1902):  59-78. 

1902.  The  promotion  of  trade  within  the  Empire.     A  reply  to  Mr. 

Kershaw.     R.  H.  Brand. 
Monthly  review,  vol.  8  {Aug.,  1902):  56-72. 

"I  propose  to  offer  some  criticisms  on  an  article  from  the  pen  of 
Mr.  Kershaw  in  the  Monthly  review  for  June  on  'the  promotion 
of  trade  within  the  Empire.'  This  will  most  conveniently  bo 
done  by  adopting  Mr.  Kershaw's  own  arrangement  of  the  sub- 
ject, and  by  considering  in  turn  the  three  subjects  firstly,  of  the 
Present  position  of  England  as  an  exporting  country,  secondly, 
of  the  Preferential  tariff  system,  and  thirdly,  of  a  Reciprocity 
system." 

1903.  Imperial  reciprocity.     Herbert  Maxwell,  Sir  Gilbert  Parker, 

Benjamin  Taylor. 
Nineteenth  century  and  after,  vol.  53  {June,  1903):  897-917. 
Reprinted  in  Living  age,  vol.  238  (July  4,  1903):  1-16. 

1903.     Die  Zukunft  der  Meistbegiinstigung  imd  der  englisch-canad- 
ische  Streitfall.     Max  Schippel. 
Sozialistische  Monatshefte,  vol.  9  {Sept.,  1903):  675-683. 

1903.     Shipping  and  reciprocity:  a  point  in  the  fiscal  controversy. 
Economist  {London),  vol.  61  {Oct.  24,  1903):  1796-1797. 


FOREIGN    countries:  PERIODICALS  117 

1903.     Retaliation  and  reciprocity. 

Quarfo'hj  review,  vol.  198  {Oct.,  1903):  613-648. 

1903.     The  retaliation  fallacy.     Franklin  Thomasson. 

New  Liberal  review,  vol.  6  {Dec,  1903):  612-621. 

1905.     L'Allemagne  et  la  "clause  de  la  nation  la  plus  favorisee." 
Jules  Domergue. 
Reforme  economique,  vol.  18  {June  25,  1905):  879-881. 

1909.     Die  deutsch-franzosischen  Handelsbeziehungen  und  die  Meist- 
begiinstigungsklausel.     W.  Borgius. 
Deutsche    WirtscJiafts-Zeitung,  vol.  5,   1909    {June  1):  col. 
490-m;  {June  15):  col.  532-538. 


AUTHOR  INDEX 


Page 

Adam,  G.  Mercer 67 

Adams,  Brooks 23,  40 

Aldrich,  Nelson  W 87, 103 

AUfree,  J.  W 45 

American  academy  of  political  and 

social  science 23 

American  chamber  of  commerce, 

Paris 24 

American  iron  and  steel  association        64 

Anderson,  A.  D 39 

Anderson,  George 75 

Andrews,  Israel  De  Wolf 51,52,64 

Appleton's  annual  cyclopaedia 97 

Archibald,  Constance  II.  M 112 

Argentine  Republic.    Minislerio  de 

reladones  exterior es 96 

Armour,  J.  O 24 

Arndt,  Paul 43 

Arnold,  Arthur 115 

Asbury,  C.  W 23 

Ashley,  Percy  Walter  Llewellyn. .         24 

Atkins,  Edwin  F 23, 110 

Atkinson,  Edward 24 

Aubry,  D 42 

Augier,  Charles Ill 

Austin,  O.  P 43,  91 

Bachia,  Richard  A 104 

Ballard,  Walter  J 79 

Barclay,  Sir  Thomas 24,  48 

Barker,  Wharton 46,  64 

Bass,  William  Louis 24,  105 

Bastable,  Charles  Francis 24,  25 

Bastiat,  Frederic 25 

Bateman,  William  Bateman  Bate- 

man-IIanbury ,  2d  baron Ill 

Bates,  William  W 25 

Beaujon,  Anthony 25 

Belknap,  G.  E 91 

Bender,  Prosper 75 

Beveridge,  A.  J 23 

Bijur,  A 104 


Page 

Bird,  Johns 46 

Bishop,  Sereno 91 

Blackwell,  Henry  B 65 

Blaine,  James  G. .  14,  57,  65,  93,  94,  97,  99 

Blake,  John  N 65 

Bliss,  T.  II 104 

Boenigk,  Otto,  freihcrr  von 40 

Bolce,  Harold 25,  46 

Bolen,  George  Lewis 25 

Borchardt,  Felix 26 

Borght,  Richard  van  der 26 

Borgius,  Viktor  Walther  Paul. ...  26, 117 

Bosc,  L 26 

Boston.     Board  of  trade 65 

Chamber  of  commerce 65 

Bourinot,  Sir  John  George 65 

Boutarel,  Aime Ill 

Boutwell,  George  S 11 

Brand,  R.  H 116 

Brazil.     Laivs,  statutes,  etc 20 

Brigham,  William  E 78 

Brigstocke,  W.  Osborne 27 

Brookshire,  E.  V 99 

Brown,  George 66 

See  also 71 

Brown,  Henry  Alvin 88 

Brown,  Robert 72 

Browne,  Addison  F 75 

Buchanan,  Isaac 66 

Burleigh,  Gov 99 

Burwell,  William  M 11 

Busbey,  L.White 47 

Butler,  Charles   U 3 

Butterworth,  lienjamin 66 

Byng.G Ill 

Callahan,  James  Morton 88 

Calwer,  Richard 26 

Campbell,  A.  II 68 

Canada.     Parliament 60,61,62,63 

Cannon,  Joseph  G 47,  48 

Carey,  H.  C 66 

119 


120 


AUTHOR  INDEX 


Page 


Carpenter,  Edmund  Janes 

Cartwright,  Sir  Richard 

Cavarretta,  Giuseppe 

Chamberlain,  Joseph 

Chapman,  Sydney  J 


67 

26 

111,112 

26 


Charlton,  John 66,  67,  76,  77,  78 

Chiozza-Money,  Leone  George 26 

Choate,  Joseph  H 18 

Chomley,  C.  H 66,112 

Chotteau,  Leon 27 

Clark,  John  Bates 48 

Clark,  Peter 11 

Clarke,  Albert.  23,  27, 42,  45,  46,  67,  77,  78 

Clawy,  C 49 

Clow,  Frederick  R 91 

Cluxton,  William 67 

Cobden  club Ill 

Colquhoun,  Arthur  H.  U 76,77 

Commercial    convention,    Cincin- 
nati, 1870 _. 11 

Commercial    convention,    Detroit, 

1865 67 

Commercial  union  club  of  Toronto.        67 

Commons,  J.  R 23 

Constable,  M.  S *  ...       116 

Cooke,  H.  B 27 

Cooper,  S.  B 101,104 

Corwine,  William  R 23,  48 

Coster,  M 24 

Cowles,  T.  Z 109 

Crawford,  J.  S 110 

Crick,  Daniel 26 

Cross,  John  Kynaston 112 

Croswell,  Simon  Greenleaf 38 

Crowell,  J.  F 23 

Crozier,  John  Beattie. 116 

Cuba.     Treaties,  etc 105 

Cuba.     Comite  central  de  propa- 
ganda economica 105 

Cuban-American    reciprocity    bu- 
reau        105 

Cudmore,  Patrick 97 

Cullom,  Shelby  M 46 

Cummins,  Albert  B 27,44,46 

Curtis,  William  Eleroy 14,  23,  27,  44 

Curtiss,  George  Boughton 97 

Cushman,  F.  W 43 

Customs  congress  of  the  American 

republics,  1903 20 

Cutts,  J.  Madison 27 

D.,  A.  J 42 

D.,  D.  W 40 

Dalzell,  John 45,46,78 


Page 

Daniels,  W.  M 31 

Darling,  Henry  W 67 

Davenport,  T.  W 27 

Davis,  Samuel  M 100 

Dawson,  William  Harbutt 112 

De  Abad,  L.  V 108 

Deering,  C 24 

Deering,  James 33, 44 

De  Normandie,  J 41 

Derby,  Elias  Basket 54,  55,  56,  68 

Detroit  board  of  commerce 68 

Dewey,  D.  R 27 

Dewey,  Stoddard 24 

Dickson,  Joseph  Howe 79 

Dietrich,  Charles  H 87, 103 

Dietzel,  Heinrich 27 

Dodge,  Arthur  J 48 

Dodge,  J.  R 42 

Dolliver,  Jonathan  P 44 

Domergue,  Jules 46, 117 

Douglas,  Stephen  Arnold 27 

Douglas,  W.  L 46 

Draper,  George  A 41 

Dreher,  William  C 44 

Dryden,  J 67 

Dunbar,  Edward  E 28 

Dunham,  Ransom  W 97 

Duval,  G.  L 23 

Edmunds,  George  F 68 

Edwards,  C.  R 23 

Elgin,  James  Bruce,  8th  earl  of 68 

See  also 65 

Ely,  Alfred 68 

Emmett,  W.  L.  R 80 

Evans,  William  W 7 

Everett,  Edward 52 

Fairbanks,  C.  W 58 

Fairbanks,  Henry 46 

Farquhar,  Arthur  B 23,  28, 42,  97 

Farquhar,  Henry 97 

Farrer,  Edward 68 

Farrer,  Thomas  Henry  Farrer,  1st 

baron 112 

Fawcett,  Henry 28 

Ferme,  Gabriel 28 

Fielding 81 

Fisk,  George  Mygatt 28,  44 

Fletcher,  Thomas  C 11 

Flux,  A.  W 29,  81 

Ford,  Worthington  C 39,  97 

Foss,  Eugene  Noble. .   24,  29,  65,  68,  77,  79 

Foster,  G.  E 69 

Foster,  John  W 40,  69,  77 


AUTHOR   INDEX 


121 


Page 

Franz,  J.  H 40 

Freed,  A.  T 80 

Frelin^huysen,  F.  T 12, 101 

French,  Nathaniel 44,79 

Fuchs,  Karl  Johannes 112 

Fuld,  Dr ' 39 

Furber,  H.  W 29 

Gait,  Sir  Alexander  T 61 

Gamba,  F 101 

Gardiner,  Charles  A 43 

Garvin,  J.  L 112 

Garvin,  Lucius  F.  C 45 

Gibson,  E.J 41 

Glasson,  W.  H 31 

Glier,  L 29 

Gordon,  W.  H.  Lockhart 67 

Gore,  James  Howard 39 

Gothein,  Georg 44,  46 

Grant,  George 69 

Gray,  John  Hamilton 69,  75 

Great  Britain.    Colonialoffice 112,113 

Foreign  office. .  22, 60, 61, 62, 96, 113 

Treaties,  etc 60 

Grey,  Henry  George  Grey,  3d  earl.  69, 116 

Griffin,  Solomon  Bulkley 79 

Grunzel,  Josef 29 

Gunton,  George 41, 109 

Hadley,  Arthur  T 29 

Haldane,  R.  B 24 

Hale,  Eugene 97,  98 

Haliburton,  Robert  Grant 69 

Ham,  E 106 

Harris,  C.  A 29 

Harris,  Charles  P 43 

Harvey,  Arthur 69 

Hatch,  Israel  T 53,  55,  69,  70 

Haven,  C.  C 38 

Hawaiian  Islands.     Legislature  ...         86 

Hawkes,  Arthur 81 

Hay,  Eugene  Gano 69,  78,  79 

Hayes,  John  D 70 

Ilaynes,  Frederick  Emory 70 

Ilealy,  A.  A 23,  24 

Ileazelton,  George 88 

Herbert,  Hilary  A 100 

Herkless,  William  Robertson 113 

Herod,  Joseph  Rogers 29 

Ilesseltine,  Norman  F 30 

Hewes,  Fletcher  W 98 

Hill,  George 59 

Hill,  James  J 70,  80 

Hincks,  F 74,  75 

Hitt,  Robert  R 75 

Hobson,  James  A ''sO,  116 


PaRO 

Ilodgins,  Thomas 70,  76 

Home  market  club,  Boston 70 

Hopkins,  John  Castell 66,  70 

Hornbeck,  Stanley  K 30, 49 

Howe,  Joseph 70 

Howes,  Osborne 70 

Huebner,  G.  G 24 

Ilurlbert,  William  H 75 

Hutch in.son,  Lincoln 45 

Huvelin,  P 39 

Hyde,  Charles  Cheney 49 

International     American     confer- 
ence   30 

International  bureau  of  American 

republics 88,  98 

Janes,  S.  H 67 

Jeans,  James  Stephen 71 

Jefferson,  Thomas 30 

Jennings,  Janet 91 

Johnson,  Edwin  F 71 

Jones,  C.  L 23 

Jury,  Alfred  F 67 

K.,  I.  L 38 

Kasson,  John  Adam 30, 40,  42 

Katzenstein,  Louis 28 

Kelley,  William  Darrah 71 

Kellogg,  D.  O 39 

Kennan,  George 108 

Kershaw,  John  B.  C 116 

King,  William  F 31 

Knappen,  Theodore  M 79 

Knight,  William  Angus 113 

Lacey,  John  F 45,  46 

Lang,  Lajos 113 

Larned,  J.  N 56 

Lauck,  W.  Jett 46 

Laughlin,  James  Laurence 31 

Ledyard,  T.  D 65,67 

Lehr,  Ernest 39 

Leroy-Beaulieu,  Pierre 45 

Lewis,  John 71 

Lind,  John 77 

Lindsey,  Charles 74 

Lodge,  Henry  Cabot 44,  70,  79,  99 

Longley,  J.  W 67,  75,  77 

Loomis,  F.  B 23 

Lorraine,  C.  L 42 

Lowe,  Francis  J 31 

Lowe,  Robert 115 

Lugrin,  Charles  H 75 

Lyman,  C.  W 23 

Lyman,  Theodore,  jr 31 

McClellan,  George  B 101 

McConnell,  Robert 76 


122 


AUTHOR  INDEX 


Page 

McCord,  J 74 

McGoun,  Arch 74 

M'Grath,  P.  T 81 

Mclntyre,  Charles  H 79 

McKee,  Thomas  Hudson 31 

McKinley,  William.  14, 15, 16,20,32,43,98 

See  also 45 

McL.,  J 74 

McNeill,  Alexander 116 

Macphail,  Andrew 81 

McPherson,  John  Bruce 47,  79 

Mac  Veagh,  Franklin 98 

Mallet,  Sir  Louis 32 

Malloy,  William  M 8 

Mason 52 

Maxey ,  Edwin 43,  45 

Maxwell,  Herbert 116 

Medley,  George  W 113,114 

Menier,  M 27 

Merrill,  Nelson 98 

Merritt,  William  Hamilton 60 

Mershon,  W.  B 24 

Mexico.     Ministerio     de    fomento, 

colonizacion  e  industria 22 

Miles,  H.  E 23 

Miller,  John  F 12,  85 

Mills,  Roger  Q 99 

Moffett,  Samuel  Erasmus 71 

Moore,  Charles  A 78 

Moore,  John  Bassett 32 

Morgan,  Henry  J 66 

Morrill,  Justin  S 38,  87, 103 

Muller,  L 24 

Mulock,  William 68 

Munson,  L.  E 75,  76 

National  association  of  agricultural 
implement  and  vehicle  manu- 
facturers          32 

National  association  of  manufac- 
turers          33 

National  board  of  trade 33,  71 

National  reciprocity  convention.  .         33 

National  reciprocity  league 33 

New  England  free  trade  league 71 

New  York.     Chamber  of  commerce 

of  the  state  of  New  York 71 

New  York  free-trade  club 106 

Newlands,  Francis  G 101 

Nickerson,  M.  H 80 

Nunez,  Emilio 108, 109 

Oliphant,  Laurence 71 

See  also 72 


Page 

Oliphant,  Mrs.  Margaret  O.  W 72 

Oncken,  August 33 

Osborne,  John  Ball.  .   23,  33,  39,  40,  41,  47 

Oxnard,  H.  T 41 

Page,  Thomas  Walker 43 

Palma,  Tomas  Estrada 109 

Palmer,  Truman  G. . .  87,  91, 102, 103, 106 

Parker,  Sir  Gilbert 116 

Parry,  D.  M 23 

Patten,  Simon  N 33 

Patterson,  C.  Stuart 99 

Pavey,  F.  D 109 

Payne,  Sereno  E '. .  48, 101 

Pearson,  James 67 

Philbert,  V 33 

Phillimore,  G.  G 44 

Piatt,  O.  H 109 

Porritt,  Edward 72,  76,  80,  81 

Portland,  Me.     Board  of  trade 53 

Pradier-Fodere,  Paul  Louis  Ernest.        34 

Price,  Bonamy 115 

Proctor,  Robert  G 8 

Prowse,  D.  W 76 

Quincy,  Josiah 108 

R.,  H.  P 48 

Rabbeno,  Ugo 34 

Raunig,  A.  G 34 

Ravaioli,  Antonio 49 

Rhein,  Henri 43 

Ricardo,  John  Lewis 114 

Rice,  David  Hall 98 

Ringwalt,  Ralph  Curtis 34 

Roberts,  George  E 45 

Robertson,  S.  M 101 

Robinson,  Albert  Gardner 106, 108 

Robinson,  Chalfant 72,  89 

Rogers,  James  E .  Thorold 34 

Romero,  Matias 22,  34,  35 

Roosevelt,  Theodore 20,  21 

Root,  Elihu 23,70 

Rosen,  Alexander 113 

Rubinow,  I.  M 31 

Russell,  John  W 76 

Rutter,  Frank  R 91 

St.  Paul,  Minn.     Chamber  of  com- 
merce           61 

Sanders,  A.  II 23 

San  Francisco.     Chamber  of  com- 
merce          35 

Schilder,  Sigmund 26,  29 

Schippel,  Max 35,47,116 

Schoenhof,  J 42 


AUTHOR  INDEX 


123 


Page 

Schraut,  Max  von 35 

Schuyler,  Eugene 35 

Schwerin-Lowitz,  Graf  von 47 

Scott,  James 84 

Seabury,  George  J 35, 46, 47 

Searles,  John  Enni^,  jr 89 

Seligman,  Edwin  R.  A 36 

Senex 114 

Seward,  W.  II 55 

Shaw,  Campbell 79 

Shaw,  Leslie  Mortier 35,  80 

Shaw,  Thomas 67 

Sheldon,  Joseph 75 

Shepheard,  Wallwyn  P.  B 42, 45 

Sherman,  John 95 

Simon,  D.  W 27 

Smalley,  H.  S 28 

Smith,  George  Armitage 114 

Smith,  Gerrit 72 

Smith,  Goldwin 67,  68,  72,  74,  75 

Smith,  Richmond  Mayo- 36 

Smith,  William  Alden 108 

Snow,  Freeman 36,89 

Spalding,  Rufus  Paine 89 

Springer,  William  M 98 

Stanwood,  Edward 79 

Stevens,  Hazard 36 

Stibral,  Franz 48 

Stirling,  Patrick  James 25 

Stone,  N.I 23,24,46,47 

Sudrez  Guanes,  Miguel 93 

Sumner,  Charles 72,  83 

Swank,  James  Moore 36 

T.,  R.  E 74 

Taussig,  F.  W 48, 100 

Taylor,  Benjamin 116 

Taylor,  H.  W 41 

Taylor,  James  W 53,  54 

Tazwell,  L.  W 3 

Thomasson,  Franklin 117 

Thompson,  C.  Halford 115 

Thompson,  R.  W 36 

Thrum,  Thomas  G 88,  91 

Thurber,  F.  B 108 

See  also 102 

Thurston,  Lorrin  A 91 

Tompkins,  D.  A 23 

Townshend,  R.  W 75 

Trumbull,  M.  M 36, 100, 114 

Tuck,  Amos 72 

Tucker,  John  Randolph 85 

United  States.    Bureau  of  statistics 

{Dept.  o/comm.  and  labor) 7 


United  States.     Bureau  of  statistics 

(  Treasury  dept.) 7,  58,  94 

Circuit  court 106 

Commission  to  Central  andSouth 

American  stales,  1884 13 

Congress 7, 8,  9-20, 

36, 51-59,  61,  83-87, 93-95,  102 

Department  of  state 8, 

10, 11,  12,  13.  18,  20,  51, 
52,  55,  57,  85,  93,  94,  95 

Laics,   statutes,    etc 8 

Supreme  court 89,  90,  107 

Tariff  commission,  1882 12 

Treasury  dept 10-12, 

16,  51-56,  83,  84,  93 

Treaties,  etc 8,  20,  21,  83, 104 

Van  Cleave,  J.  W 24 

Viallate,  Achille 42 

Vincent,  Sir  Howard 79,  80 

Visser,  L.  E 42 

Volstead,  A.J 46,  78 

Voorhees,  Daniel 87, 103 

Vosberg-Rekow,  Max 36,  37 

Wade,  F.  C 67 

Waldron,  George  B 41 

Wallace,  Alfred  R 115 

Walrond,  Theodore 68 

Ward,  Elijah 53,  72 

Warner,  J.  De  W 99 

Watkin,  Sir  Edward  W 73 

Webster,  Daniel 37 

Wharton,  Francis 37 

Whelpley,  J.  D 76 

White,  H 41 

White,  William  Allen 109 

Whitman,  William 37 

Whitney,  Edward  B 99 

Whitney,  Henry  M 80,  81 

Wilcox,  Marrion 108,  109 

Willis,  H.  Parker 31,48,110 

Willison,  John  Stephen 73 

Wilson,  Alexander  Johnstone...  114,115 

Wilson,  James  H 37, 104 

Wilson,  William  L 100 

Wilson,  William  P 41 

Wiman,  Erastus 73,  75,  76,  78 

Wise,  Bernard  R 37 

Wolf,  Julius 37 

Wolowski,   Louis  Francois  Michel 

Raymond 1 14 

Wood,  Leonard 102, 108 

Woolsey,  T.  S 37 

Young,  John  P 23,  40 


SUBJECT  INDEX 


Argentine  Republic:  Page 
Argentine  Republic.  Mhiisteno 

de  relaciones  exter  lores 96 

Glier,L -'9 

Congressional  docnmeuts — 

1896 14 

1899 15 

1901 17 

Periodicals — 

1899 39 

Austria-Hungary  : 

Ldng,L 113 

Congressional  documents — 

1892 94 

1897 95 

Barbados: 

Congressional  documents — 

1897 95 

1899 15 

1901 18 

1902 19 

Periodicals — 

1899 39 

Bermuda: 

Congressional  documents — 

1899, 1900 15 

1901 17 

Bibliography: 

Ashley,  P.  W.  L 24 

Borchardt,  F 26 

Bosc,  L 26 

Fisk,  G.  M 28 

Grunzel,  J 29 

Haynes,  F.  E 70 

Hornbeck,  S.  K 30 

Laughiin,  J.  L 31 

Moffett,  S.  E 71 

Ringwalt,  R.  C 34 

Robinson,  C 72,89 

Brazil: 

Brazil.     Laws,  statutes,  etc 20 

Ferme,  G 28 

27306°— 10 9  / 


Brazil:  Page 

Great  Britain.     Foreign  office . .        96 
Congressional  documents — 

1886 13 

1891 93 

1892 93, 94 

1897 95 

Periodicals — 

1903 45 

Breadstuffs: 

Congressional  documents — 

1896 14 

British  America: 

Congressional  documents — 

1818,1819 9 

1839,1842 10 

1851 51 

1862,1866 54 

British  Guiana: 

Congressional  documents — 

1897 95 

1899,1900 15 

1901 17 

1902 18,19 

British  West  Indies: 

See  West  Indies,  British 
Brussels       sugar       conference, 
1901-1902: 
See    International    confer- 
ence on  sugar  bounties 
Caicos  Islands: 

Congressional  documents — 

1899,1900 15 

1901 17 

1902 18,19 

Canada 14, 

23, 32,  34-36, 51-81,  89, 99, 116 
Commerce — 

Canada.     Parliament..  60,62,63 
Great  Britain — 

Jeans,  J.  S 71 

125 


126 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


Canada:  Page 
Commerce — 
United  States- 
American  academy  of  po- 
litical and  social  science.  23 

Andrews,  I.  D 64 

Barker,  W 64 

Canada.     Parliament 60 

Charlton,  J 66 

Commercial     convention, 

Detrait,  1865 67 

Confidential       memoran- 
dum   56 

Derby,  E.  H 68 

Detroit     board     of    com- 
merce    68 

Foss,  E.  N 68 

Hopkins,  J.  C 70 

Moffett,  S.  E 71 

New  York.     Chamber  of 

commerce 71 

U.  S.  Treasury  dept 52 

Ward,  E. 72 

Willison,  J.  S 73 

Congressional  documents — 

1818 9 

1851,1852 51 

1859 53 

1862 53, 54 

1866 54 

1867,1868 55 

1869 55,  56 

1871,1876 56 

1884,1890 57 

1894 58 

Periodicals — 

1852,1872 74 

1897,1899,1900,1901...  76 

1904 79 

Commercial  policy — 

Grant,G 69 

Grey,  H.  G.  G.,  5r?wW..  69 
Periodicals-— 

1906 80 

Commercial  union  with  United 
States- 
Blake,  J.N 65 

Butterworth,  B 66 

Commercial  union  club  of 

Toronto 67 

Wiman,  E 73 

Congressional  documents — 

1888,1890 ..,  57 


Canada:  Page 

Commercial  union  with  United 
States- 
Periodicals — 

1880 74 

1881,1887,1888,1889,1890.         75 

,       1905 80 

See    also     Customs     union, 
American 
Tariff     relations    with    Great 
Britain — 

Charlton,  J 66 

Chomley,  C.  H 66 

Foster,  G.E 69 

Hill,  G 59 

Periodicals  — 

1903 78,116 

1904 79,80 

1910 81 

See  also  Coal;  Fisheries;  Lum- 
ber trade;  Manufactures; 
Mines;  New  Brunswick; 
Newfoundland;  Nova  Sco- 
tia ;  Prince  Edward 
Island 
Central  America: 

Hale.E 97 

U.  S.     Dept.  of  state 12 

Congressional  documents — 

1884 12 

1885,1886 13 

(See aZso  Guatemala;  Hondu- 
ras;  Nicaragua;    Salva- 
dor; Spanish  America 
China: 

Congressional  documents — 

1896 14 

Coal: 

Canada— 

Congressional  documents — 

1868 55 

1897 58 

See  also  Mines:  Canada 
Coffee: 

Congressional  documents — 

1901 86 

Colombia: 

Congressional  docu  m  ents — 

1894 94 

Commercial  union  of  Canada  and 
United  States: 
See  Canada 


SUBJECT  INDEX 


127 


Page 
Commercial  inion  of   Ciba    and 
United  States: 
See  Cuba 

COXSTITUTIONALITY    of    KKIIPKOCITY 

LAWS  and  treaties: 
U.  S.  Supreme 'court — 

Whitman,  W 37 

Period' cols — 

1886 38 

1892 99 

Conventional  tariff: 

See  Tariff,  Conventional 
Cuba  . .  7, 14,  23,  37,  87, 93-95,  97, 101-1 10 
Commercial  union  with  United 
States— 
Congressional  documenis — 

1909 104 

See  also  Sugar 
Customs  union,  American: 

Appleton's  annual  cyclopaedia.        97 

Douglas,  S.  A 27 

Ferine,  G 28 

International   American    con- 
ference, 1st 30 

Congressional  documents — 

1886 13 

Periodiads — 

1872 74 

1904 46 

See  also  Canada:  Commercial 
union   with  United  States; 
Cuba:     Commercial     union 
with  United  States 
Customs  unions: 

Bosc,  L 26 

See  also  Z»llverein,  German, 
1818-1871 
Denmark: 

U.S.  Supreme  court 89 

See  also  Santa  Cruz;  Treaties, 
Unratified:  Santa  Cruz 

DiNGLEY   tariff   ACT: 

See  Tariff  laws 
Dominican  Republic: 

U.  S.  Supreme  court 90 

Congressional  documents — 

1892 93,94 

1897...    95 

1900 16 

1901 18 

Double  tariff: 

See  Tariff,  Double 


Page 


Ecuador: 

Congressional  documents— 

1900 

Elgin-Marcy  treaty,  1854-1866: 
(See  Treaties  and  agreements: 
Canada 
Europe: 

American  a<'ademy  of  political 

and  social  science 

U.  S.  Bureau  of  statistics 

Fair  trade: 

Farrer,  T.  H.  F.,  1st  bar  on.... 

Herkle'ss,  W.  R 

Medley,  G.  W 

Periodicals — 

1892 

Favored-nation  clause: 

See  Most -favored- nation 

CLAUSE 

Fisheries: 

Andrews,  I.  D 

Derby,  E.  H 

Great  Britain.     Treaties,  etc. . . 

Tuck,A 

Woolsey,  T.  S 

Congressional  documents — 

1853 

1867 

1869 

1902 

1903 

PeriodicaU — 

1901 

France: 

Augier,  C 

Chotteau,  L 

Lang,  L 

San   Francisco.     Chamber  of 

commerce 

U.  S.  Congress 

President 

Ireaties,  etc 

Congressional  documents — 

1896 

1899 

1900 

1901 

1902 

Periodicals — 

1899 

1907,1908 


16 


23 
95 

112 
113 
113 


52 
55 
56 
58. 
59 

76 

111 
27 
113 

35 
7 
14 

21 

14 
15 

15, 16 

17 

18,  19 


128 


SUBJECT  INDEX 


France:  Page 

Commerce  with  Germany — 
Periodicals — 

1909 117 

Great  Britain- 
Cross,  J.  K 112 

United  States — 

Congressional  documents — 

1900 16 

Commercial  policy — 

Cobden  club Ill 

Tariff  relations   with    United 
States — 

American  chamber  of  com- 
merce, Paris 24 

Free  Trade  and  reciprocity: 
Periodicals — 

1870,1878 115 

1879 115,116 

1901 40 

See  also  Protection 
Germanic  association  of  customs 
and  commerce: 
See    ZoLLVEREiN,    German, 
1818-1871 
Germany — 

Borgius,  V.  W.  P 26 

Glier,L.. 29 

Shaw,  L.  M 35 

U.  S.  Congress 7 

Treaties,  etc 20 

Wolf,  J 37 

Congressional  documents — 

1892 94 

1896 14 

1897 95 

1908 20 

Periodicals — 

1844,1846 38 

1900 40 

1905 117 

1906 47 

1907,1908 48 

Commerce  with  France — 
Periodicals — 

1909 -. 117 

United  States — 
Periodicals — 

1899 39 

1903 44 

1905 46,47 


Germany:  Page 

Tariff  relations   with    United 
States— 

Fisk,  G.  M 28 

Glier,  L 29 

Periodicals — 

1903 44 

1905,1906 47 

See  also  Prussia;  Zollvereix, 
German,  1818-1871 

Great  Britain 9,10,15,17-19, 

22,  26,  28,  31,  36-38,  52-54,  57,  58, 
60-62,65-71,78,79,81,95,111-117. 
Colonies — 

Grey,  H.  G.  G.,  5(?mr?..         69 

Lyman,  T 31 

Congressional  documents — 

1892 94 

1897 95 

p'eriodicals — 

1845 38 

ASeeaZso Barbados;  Bermuda; 
British  Guiana;  Caicos 
Islands;  Canada;  Ja- 
maica; Leeward  Islands; 
Newfoundland;  Trini- 
dad; Turks  Islands;  West 
Indies,  British;  Wind- 
ward Islands 
Commerce  with  Canada — 

Canada.     Parliament 60 

France — 

Cross,  J.  K 112 

United  States — 

Chapman,  S.  J 26 

Tazewell,  L.  W 3 

Congressional  documents — 

1842 10 

Commercial  policy — 

Blake,  J.  N 65 

Fuchs,  K.  J 112 

See  also  Fair  trade. 
Tariff  relations  with  Canada— 
See  Canada 
Guatemala  : 

Congressional  documents — 

1892 94 

1897 95 

Haiti: 

Congressional  documents — 
1894 94 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


129 


Page 

Hawaii 7,  32,  36,  37,  83-91,  103 

See  also  Sugar 
Hay-Bond  TREATY,  1902: 

See     Treaties,     Uxrai-  kied: 
Newfoundland 
Honduras: 

Congressional  documents — 

1892 94 

1897 95 

International  American  confer- 
ence, 1889-1890: 

Romero,  M •^S 

Smith,  R.  Mayo- 36 

International    conference     on 
sugar  bounties,  1901-1902: 
Periodicals — 

1902 109 

"Iowa  idea:  " 

Periodicals— 

1904 45 

Italy: 

\] .  S.  Congress 7 

President 16 

Jamaica: 

Congressional  documents — 

1897 95 

1899,1900 15 

1901 17 

1902 18,19 

Periodicals — 

1899 39 

Japan: 

Congressional  documents — 

1896 14 

Kasson  treaties: 

Kasson,  J.  A 30 

Periodicals — 

1900,1901 40 

1902 42 

See  also  Treaties,  Unratified 
Latin  America: 

See  Spanish  America 
Laurier,  Sir  Wilfrid: 

Willison,  J.  S 73 

Leeward  Islands: 

Congressional  documents — 

1897 95 

Lumber  trade: 

Commercial    union     club    of 

Toronto 68 

McKinley  tariff  act: 
See  Tariff  laws 


Page 
Manufactures: 
Canada- 
Commercial  union  club  of 

Toronto 67 

United  States— 
Periodicals — 

1902 42 

Maximum  and  minimum  tariff: 

See  Tariff,  Double 
Mexico: 

Dunbar,E.E 28 

Mexico.    Mirdsterio  de fomenlo .         22 

Romero,  M 34,  35 

Congressional  documents — 

1860 11 

1883 12 

1886 13 

1892 94 

Commerce — 

Romero,  M 35 

United  States- 
Romero,  M 34,  35 

Congressional  documents — 

1878 11 

1884 12 

Tariff   relations   with    United 
States- 
American  academy  of  po- 
litical and  social  science.        23 
Mines: 

Canada — 

Blake.J.N 65 

Commercial  union  club  of 

Toronto 67 

See  also  Coal:  Canada 
Molasses: 

Congressional  documents— 

1897 86 

Most-fa vored-nation  clause: 
American  academy  of  political 

and  social  science 23 

Beaujon,  A 25 

Borchardt,  F 26 

Calvver,  R 26 

Cavarretta,  G 26 

Chiozza-Money ,  L.  (} 26 

Fisk,  G.  M 28 

Glier,L 29 

Great  I'.ritain.     Colonial  office .       112 

Grunzel,  J 29 

Herod,  J.  R 29 

Hornbeck,  S.  K 30 


130 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


MOST-FAVORED-NATIOX    CLAUSE:  Page 

Oncken,  A 33 

Pradier-Fodere,  P.  L.  E 34 

Schraut,  M.  von 35 

U.  S.     Pyureau  of  statistics 7 

Vosberg-Rekow,  M 36,37 

Wharton,  F 37 

Periodicals — 

1893, 1896, 1899 39 

1900 40 

1901 42 

1902 42,43,44 

1903 44,45,116 

1905 46,47,117 

1906 47 

1907 48 

1908 48,  49 

1909 49,117 

National     reciprocity     conven- 
tion, Washington,  D.  C,  1901: 
Periodicals — 

1901,1902 42 

National     reciprocity     conven- 
tion, Chicago,  1905: 
Periodicals — 

1905 46 

Netherlands: 

U.  S.  Treaties,  etc 21 

New  Brunswick: 

Great  Britain.    Foreign  office . .        60 
Newfoundland: 

Blackwell,  H.  B 65 

Boston.      Chamber    of    com- 
merce           65 

Congressional  documents — 

1902 58 

1903 58,59 

Periodicals — 

1902 77 

1904 79 

Nicaragua: 

Congressional  documents — 

1892 94 

1897 95 

1900 16 

Nova  Scotia: 

Great  Britain.     Foreign  office.        60 
Congressional  documents — 

1868 55 

Payne  tariff  act: 

See  Tariff  laws 
Philippines: 

American  academy  of  political 
and  social  science 23 


Philippines:  Page 

U.  S.  Circuit  court 106 

Congress 7 

Congressional  documents — 

1902 102 

Porto  Rico: 

Hale,  E 97 

sU.  S.  Congress 7 

Congressional  documents — 

1884 101 

1892 93,94 

1897 95 

Periodicals — 

1902 91 

Portugal: 

U.  S.  Congress 7 

President 15,16 

Prince  Edward  Island: 

Great  Britain.     Foreign  office . .        60 
Protection  and  reciprocity: 

Haliburton,  R.  G 69 

Hewes,  F.  W 98 

Laughlin,  J.  L 31 

Periodicals — 

1844 38 

1892 99 

1901 40,41 

1902 44 

1903 44,45 

See  also  Free  trade 
Prussia  : 

Congressional  documents — 

1844,1845 10 

Retaliation: 

Bastable,  C.  F 24 

Byng,  G Ill 

Dietzel,  H 27 

Periodicals — 

1901 40,41 

1902 43 

1903 117 

1905 47 

Rice: 

Congressional  documents — 

1897 86 

St.  Croix: 

See  Santa  Cruz 
Salvador: 

Congressional  documents — 

1891 93 

1892 94 

1897 95 

Sandwich  Islands: 
See  Hawaii 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


131 


Santa  Criz:  Page 

Congressional  doru ments — 

1900,  1901 17 

1902 19 

Shipping  and  reciprocity : 

Bates,  W.  W 25 

Great  Britain.     Treaties,  etc..        60 

Kicardo,  J.  L 114 

Congressional  dorunie}its — 

1901,1902 18 

Periodicals — 

1827 115 

1890 38 

1903 116 

South  America  : 

Hale,  E 97 

U.  S.     Department  «f  ftate 12 

Congresi<ional  docii menls — 

1825 10 

1884 12 

1885,1886 13 

Period  icalx — 

1893 100 

1900 40 

See  also  Abgentine  Republic; 
Brazil;    Colombia;    Ecua- 
dor; Spanish  America;  Ven- 
ezuela 
Spain  : 

U.  S.  Congress 7 

Treaties,  etc 21 

Congressional  documents — 

1863 11 

1906 20 

See  also  Cuba;    Porto    Rico; 
Treaties,  Unratified:  Cuba 
and  Porto  Rico 
Spanish  America: 

Appleton's  annual  cyclopiedia.        97 
Congress ional  doc u m ents — 

1890 93 


Periodicals — 
1890 38, 99 

See  also  Argentine  Republic; 
Brazil;  Central  America; 
Colombia; Cuba;  Dominican 
Republic;  Ecuador;  Guate- 
mala; Haiti;  Honduras; 
Mexico;  Nicaragua;  Sal- 
vador; South  America; 
Venezuela 

Commerce — 

Congressional  documents — 
1870 11 


Spanish  America:  page 
Coniiiicrce — 
Europe — 

U.  S.  Ihtreau  f)f  statistics..  95 
United  States- 
Curtis,  W.  E 27 

Hale,  E 97 

International     bureau    of 

the  American  republics.  98 

U.S.     Bureau  of  statistics.  95 

Wilson,  J.  H..^ 37 

Congressional  documents — 

1870,1871 11 

1884 12 

1885,1886 13 

1890 14 

Periodicals  — 

1894 100 

1902 43 

Statistics: 

Great  Britain.     Foreign  office.  96 

Hawaiian  almanac 88 

Lung,  L 113 

U.  S.  Bureau  of  statistics 7,  95 

Congress 7 

Wolf,J 37 

Co7igressiona I  docu m ei its— 

1859 53 

1862 53,54 

1886 85 

1892 93,94 

1894 58 

1896 14 

1897 86 

1902 58 

Periodicals — 

1894 100 

Sugar: 

Wolf,J 37 

Congressional  documents — 

1894 94 

1903 102 

Periodicals — 

1890 99 

1898 91 

1902 108,109 

1908 48 

Cuba— 

U.  S.  Congress 102 

Wolf.J 37 

Congressional  documents — 

1902 102 

Hawaii — 

Congressional  docu  ments — 

1897,1900 86 


132 


SUBJECT  INDEX, 


Sugar:  Page 

United  States— 

Congressional  documents — 

1900 86 

Periodicals — 

1901 41 

1902 91 

See    also  International  con- 
ference on  SUGAR  bounties 

Switzerland: 

U.  S.  Congress 7 

Tariff  commission: 

American  academy  of  political 

and  social  science 23 

Periodicals — 

1906 47 

1908 48 

Tariff,  Conventional: 

American  academy  of  political 

and  social  science 23 

U.S.    Bureau  of  statistics 7 

Tariff,  Double: 

American  academy  of  political 

and  social  science 23,  24 

U.  S.    Bureau  of  statistics 7 

Periodicals — 
1905,1907 47 

Tariff  laws: 

MfcKinley    tariff    act    (1890- 
1894)— 
Great    Britain.       Foreign 

office 96 

Grey,  H.  G.  G.,  3d  earl ...        69 

Rice,  D.  H 98 

U.S.    Congress 7 

Laws,  statutes,  etc 8 

Congressional  documents — 

1893,1894 94 

Periodicals — 

1892 99 

1893 76 

1894 100 

Dingley     tariff      act      (1897- 
1909)— 
American  academy  of  po- 
litical and  social  science.         23 

U.S.     Congress 7 

La^rs,  statutes,  elc 8 

Periodically — 

1897 76 

1902 42 


Tariff  Laws:  page 
Payne  tariff  act  (1909-         )— 
Periodicals — 

1909 81 

Treaties  and  agreements: 
General — 

Borchardt,  F 26 

Borght,  R.  van  der 26 

Cobden  club Ill 

Dawson,  W.  H 112 

Fawcett,  H 28 

Fisk,G.M 28 

Great    Britain.       Foreign 

office 96 

Handelsvertrage 29 

Herod,  J.  R 29 

Hornbeck,S.  K 30 

International      American 

conference,  1889-1890..  30 
International    bureau    of 

the  American  republics  98 

Ldng.L 113 

Oncken,  A 33 

Philbert,V 33 

Raunig,  A.  G 34 

Schippel,  M 35 

Schraut,  M .  von 35 

Schuyler,  E 35 

Seabury,  G.J 35 

Smith,  R.  Mayo- 36 

U.S.    Congress 7 

Bejd.  of  state 8 

Laws,  statutes,  etc 8 

Treaties,  etc 8 

Vosberg-Rekow,  M 36 

Webster,  D 37 

Congressional  documents — 

1890 93 

1892 94 

1896 14,94 

1897 95 

1902 20 

Periodicals — 

1845,  1846,  1847,  1853, 

1886 38 

1892,1894 100 

1901 41 

1902 44 

1903 44,45 

1905 46,47 

1906 47 

1907 48 

1908,1909 49 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


133 


Treaties  and  agreements: 

Individual      treaties       ( United 
States)— 
Canada  (1854-1866)— 

Andrews,  I.  D 

Augier,  C 

Barclay,  SirT 

Bastabl'e,  C.  F 

Bates,  W.W 

Blaine,  J.  G 

Boston.     Board  of  trade  . 

B(  )urinot,  Sir  J.  G 

Brown,G 

Canada.     Parliament 

Debate  on  termination  of 
treaty  

Derby,  E.H 

Ely, A 

Foster,  J.  W 

Great    Britain.       Foreign 

office 

Treaties,  etc 

Harvey,  A 

Haynes,  F.  E 

Hopkins,  J.  C 

Howe,  J 

Johnson,  E.  F 

Moore,  J.  B 

New  York.     Chamber  of 
commerce 

Oliphant,  L 

Oliphant,  Mrs.  M.  O.  W.. 

Porritt,  E 

Robinson,  C 

Smith,  Gerrit 

Sumner,  C 

Watkin,  SirE.W 

Congressional  documents — 

1854 

1859,  1860 

1862 

1864 

1867,  1868 

Periodicals — 

1854,  1861,  1874 

Cuba  (1903-        )— 

Cuba.     Treaties,  etc 

Cuban-American  reciproc- 
ity bureau 

U.  S.     Circuit  court 

Congress 

Supreme  court 


Page 


64 
111 
24 
24 
25 
05 
65 
65 
66 
60,61 

54 
54,  68 

68 
69 

60,61 
60 
69 
70 
70 
70 
71 
32 

71 
71 
72 

72 
72,89 
72 
72 
73 

52 
53 
53,54 
54 
55 

74 

105 

105 

106 

7 

107 


Treaties  and  ac.reements:  i'ngo 

Individual      treaties       (United 
States)— 
Cuba  (1903-        )— 

Congressional  documents — 

1902 103 

1903 103,104 

1904 104 

Periodicals — 

1903  109,110 

1904 110 

Denmark  (1826-        )— 

U.  S.     Suprenie  court 89 

Dominican     Republic     (1867- 
1898)— 

U.S.     Supreme  court 90 

France  (1823-        )— 

Lyman,  T 31 

France  (1898-1909)— 

U.S.     Congress 7 

President 14 

Treaties,  etc 19,  21 

Congressional  documents — 

1900 16 

Germany  (1900-1906)— 

U.S.      Congress 7 

Wolf.J 37 

Periodicals — 

1900 40 

1906 47 

Germany  (1907-1910)— 

Shaw,  L.  M 35 

U.S.     Congress 7 

Treaties,  etc 20 

Congressional  documents — 

1908 20 

Periodicals — 

1907 48 

Great  Britain  (1782-        )— 

Blaine,  J.  G 65 

Great  Britain  (1815-        )— 

Lyman,  T 31 

Congressional  documents — 

1816 9 

1842 10 

Great  Britain  (1819-        )— 

Blaine,  J.  G 65 

Lyman,  T 31 

Congressional  documents — 
1818,1823 9 


134 


SUBJECT  INDEX 


Treaties  and  agreements:  Pa&e 
Individual       treaties       (United 
States)— 
Hawaii  (1875-1900)  — 

Brown,  H.  A...   88 

Debates 83,  85 

Heazelton,  G 88 

Robinson,  C 72,  89 

Searles,  J.  E  ,  jr 89 

Snow,  F 36 

Spalding,  R.P 89 

U.  S.     Congress 7 

Supreme  covrt 89,  90 

Treasury  dept 84 

Treaties,  etc 83 

Congressional  documerds — 

1876 83 

1883 84 

1884 84,85 

1886,  1887 85 

1894,1897 86 

1903 87,103 

Periodicals — 

1875 91 

Italy  (1900-1910)— 

U.  S.     Congress 7 

President 16 

Mexico  (1884-1887)— 

TNlexico.     Ministerio  de  fo- 

mento 22 

Congressional  documents — 

1883 12 

1886 13 

Periodicals — 

1885 38 

Netherlands  (1908-1910)— 

U.S.      Treaties,  etc 21 

Portugal  (1900-1910)— 

U.  S.     Congress 7 

President 15, 16 

Spain  (1906-1910)— 

U.  S.     Congress 7 

Treaties,  etc 20, 21 

Switzerland  (1906-1909)  — 

U.  S.     Congress 7 

Individual  treaties  (other  coun- 
tries)— 
France-Great    Britain     (1860- 
1882)— 

Boutarel,  A Ill 

Chamberlain,  J Ill 

Cobden  club Ill 

Cross,  J.  K 112 

Wolowski,  L.  F.  M.  K...  114 


Treaties,  Unratified:  Page 

Argentine  Republic  (1899)— 
Congressional  documents — 

1899 15 

1901 17 

Canada  (1874)— 

Brown,  G 66 

Canada.     Parliament 62 

'Carey,  H.  C 66 

Edmunds,  G.F 68 

Great  Britain.     Foreign  of- 
fice           62 

Kelley,  W.  D 71 

Lewis,  J 71 

Cuba  and  Porto  Rico  (1884)— 

New  York  free-trade  club       106 
Cong ress iona I  documents — 

1884 101 

Dominican  Republic  (1900) — 
Congressional  documents — 

1900 16 

1901 18 

Ecuador  (1900)— 

Congressional  documents — 

1900 - 16 

France  (1899)— 

Congressional  documents — 

1899 15 

1900 15.16 

1901 17 

1902 18.19 

Periodicals — 

1900 39 

Great    Britain.       Colonies 
(1899)— 
Congressional  documents — 

1899,1900 15 

1901 17,  18 

1902 18,19 

Periodicals — 

1899 39 

Hawaii  (1867)  — 

Congressional  documents — 

1867 83 

Mexico  (1859)  — 

Dunbar,  E.  E 28 

Congressional  documents — 

1860 11 

Newfoundland  (1902)— 

Boston.  Chamber  of  com- 
merce           65 

Congressional  documents — 

1902 58 

1903 58,59 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


135 


Treaties,  Unratikikd:  Page 

Newfoundland  ( 1902)— 
Periodicals— 

1904 79 

Nicaragua  (1899)— 

Congressional  doeinnents — 

1900 16 

Santa  Cruz  (1900)— 

Congressional,  documenls — 

1900,1901 17 

Zollverein,  German  (1844) — 
Congressional  documents — 

1844,1845 10 

Periodicals — 

1844,1846 38 

See  also  Kasson  treaties 
Treaty-making  power: 

Butler,  C.  H 3 

Robinson,  C 72,  89 

U.  S.  Supreme  court. 

Congressional  documertts — 

1884 57 

1887 85 

1902 20 

Periodicals — 

1886 38 

Trinidad  : 

Congressional  documents — 

1897 95 

Turks  Islands: 

Congressional  docxnneuts — 

1899,1900 15 

1901 17 

1902 18,19 

United  States: 
Colonies — 

Periodicals — 

1899 39 

See  also  Hawaii;  Philippines; 
Porto  Rico 
Commerce — 

Great     Britain.       Foreign 

office 96 

Jefferson,  T 30 

U.  S.  Bureau  of  statistics. .  7 

Congress 7 

Congressional  documents — 

1839 10 

1871 11 

1896 14 

Periodicals — 

1901 41 

1902 44 


United  States:  page 
Commerce — 
Argentine  Republic — 
Congression(d  documents — 

1896 14 

Brazil — 

Congressiomd  documents — 

1886 13 

1892 93 

British  America — 

Congressional  docu ments — 

1819 9 

1839,1842 10 

1851 51 

1862,1866 54 

Canada — 

American  academy  of  po- 
litical and  social  science.  23 

Andrews,  I.  D 64 

Barker,  W 64 

Canada.     Parliament. .  60,  62,  63 

Charlton,J 66 

Commercial     convention, 

Detroit,  1865 67 

Confidential       memoran- 
dum    56 

Derby,  E.  H (iS 

Detroit    board     of     com- 
merce   68 

Foas,  E.  N 68 

Hopkins,  J.  C 70 

Moffett,  S.  E 71 

New  York.     Chamber  of 

commerce 71 

U.  S.  Treasury  dept 52 

Ward,  E 72 

Willison,  J.  S 73 

Congressional  documents — 

1818 9 

1851,1852 51 

1859 53 

1862 53,54 

1866 54 

1867,1868 55 

1869 55,56 

1871,1876 56 

1884,1890 57 

1894 58 

Periodicals — 

1852,1872 74 

1897,1899,1900,1901 76 

1904 79 

China— 

Con gress lona I  documents — 

1896 14 


136 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


United  States:  Page 

Commerce — 
Cuba— 

Congressional  documents — 

1892 93 

Dominican  RepuVjlic — 
Congressional  docnments — 

1892 93,94 

France— 

Congressional  documents — 

1900 16 

Germany — 
Periodicals — 

1899 39 

1903 U 

1905 46,47 

Great  Britain — 

Chajjman,  S.  J 26 

Tazewell,  L.  W 3 

Congressional  documetds — 

1842 10 

Hawaii — 

Congressional  docu me7its — 

1886 85 

1894,1897 86 

Periodicals — 

1893,1902 91 

Japan — 
'  Congressional  documents — 

1896 14 

Mexico — 

Romero,  M 34,  35 

Congressional  documents — 

1878 11 

1884 12 

Porto  Rico — 

Congressional  documents— 

1892 . .    93,  94 

Periodicals — 

1902 91 

South  America— 
Periodicals — 

1900 40 

Spanish  America — 

Curtis,  W.  E , 27 

Hale,  E 97 

International  hureauof  the 

American  republics 98 

U.  S.  Bureau  of  statistics..        95 
Wilson,  J.  H 37 


United  States:  Page 

Commerce — 
Spanish  America — 

Congressional  documents — 

1870,1871 11 

1884 12 

1885,1886 13 

1890 14 

Periodicals — 

1894 100 

1902  .* 43 

Uruguay — 

Congressional  documents — 

1896 :         14 

West  Indies,  British — 

Great      Britain.     Foreign 

office 22 

Tazewell,  L.W 3 

Congressional  documents — 

1818 9 

Commercial  policy — 

Rabbeno,  U 34 

Smith,  R.  Mayo 36 

Periodicals — 

1899 39 

1902 43 

1910 49 

Commercial  union  withCanada — 

See  Canada 
Commercial  union  Avith  Cuba — 

See  Cuba 
Tariff  relations  with  France — 

American  chamber  of  com- 
merce, Paris 24 

Germany — 

Fisk,  G.  M 28 

Glier,L 29 

Periodicals — 

1903 44 

1905,1906 47 

Mexico- 
American  academy  of  po- 
litical and  social  science .         23 
Uruguay: 

Congressional  documents — 
1896 14 

Venezuela: 

Congressional  documents — 
1894 94 


SUBJECT   INDEX 


137 


West  Indies,  British:  Page 

Canada.     Parliament 60 

Great  Britain.     Foreign  office..        22 

Tazewell,  \..W 3 

CungrcsKional  document — 

1818 9 

1892 94 

1897 95 

See  also  Barbados;  Caicos  Is- 
lands; Jamaica;  Leeward 
Islands;  Trinidad;  Turks 
Islands;  Windward  Is- 
lands 


West  Indies,  Danish:  page 

See  Santa  Criz 
Windward  Islands: 

Congressional  documents — 

1897 95 

Zollverein,  German,  1818-1871: 

Lang,  L 113 

Webster,  D 37 

Congressional  documents — 

1844,  1845 10 

1862 53 

Periodicals — 

1844,1846 38 


^i 


fK?\ 


U,  C.BERKELEY  LIBRARIES 


CDmfil4'=lfib 


